Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Limited v Nathan

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA577/2016
[2017] NZCA 202

BETWEEN

BROADSPECTRUM (NEW ZEALAND) LIMITED
Applicant

AND

JASON ARAMIHA NATHAN
Respondent

Hearing:

15 May 2017

Court:

Kós P, Asher and Brown JJ

Counsel:

J O Upton QC for Applicant
T P Cleary for Respondent

Judgment:

23 May 2017 at 4.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal dismissed.

BThe applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a Band A basis together with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Kós P)

  1. The applicant, Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Ltd (Broadspectrum), seeks leave to appeal against a decision of the Employment Court ordering that the respondent, Jason Nathan, be reinstated to his former position in Broadspectrum’s employment, together with orders for payment of lost wages and costs in the Employment Relations Authority.[1]

    [1]Nathan v Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Ltd [2016] NZEmpC 135.

  2. Mr Nathan had been employed as a lines mechanic by Broadspectrum and was an acting team leader in June 2013 when he responded to an incident in Wellington.  In the course of that response one of his team members received an electric shock.  Broadspectrum commenced a disciplinary investigation leading to Mr Nathan’s dismissal in August 2013.  Broadspectrum pursued a personal grievance claim for unjustified dismissal and sought “reinstatement”. 

  3. Before the Authority, Broadspectrum agreed to meet the remedies sought in Mr Nathan’s Statement of Problem, but only reinstating him to a position no less advantageous than his former position.  That is, not to his previous job.  Mr Nathan was unwilling to accept that at the hearing. 

  4. In its decision some 10 days after the hearing the Authority expressly did not determine whether the dismissal was lawful or not.  Given Broadspectrum’s concession, the Authority said it would simply determine remedies.  It directed reinstatement of Mr Nathan to a position no less advantageous than his previous role.  Reinstatement to his former role was not granted. 

  5. Mr Nathan challenged the remedies ordered in an appeal to the Employment Court.  Two alleged errors of law were pleaded: erroneous reliance on evidence from two witnesses, and a wrongful order not to award costs.  But in substance it seems to us the appeal also canvassed two other broader questions: whether the Authority was right not to determine justifiability of the dismissal, and whether it acted in breach of natural justice in not hearing further from Mr Nathan in evidence before any determining remedy.

  6. The Employment Court in a decision dated 28 October 2016 allowed the appeal on both grounds advanced.  It then considered what remedies should be granted.  The Court concluded that the appropriate remedy was to order Mr Nathan be reinstated to his previous position (at the same location) “but in a staged manner to ensure his reintegration into the workforce is achieved as smoothly as possible”.[2]  Lost wages and costs were also directed.

    [2]At [85].

  7. Broadspectrum now seeks leave to appeal to this Court.  Such appeal must be on a question of law only,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Limited v Nathan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZCA 202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Limited sought leave to appeal against a decision of the Employment Court that reinstated Jason Nathan to his former position within the company, along with payment of lost wages and costs. Nathan, a lines mechanic and acting team leader for Broadspectrum, was dismissed following an incident in which one of his team members received an electric shock. The Employment Court allowed Nathan’s appeal on the basis that the Authority had not determined the justifiability of the dismissal and had not heard Nathan’s evidence before determining the remedy. Broadspectrum now seeks leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the Authority's decision was legally flawed.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Authority's decision was legally sound and whether Broadspectrum's concession of liability and remedy necessitated further investigation by the Authority. The Court considered that Broadspectrum's questions pertained to the specific facts of the case and did not present matters of general or public importance. The Court noted that the Authority had failed to make a liability determination, contrary to statutory requirements, and had proceeded with remedy determinations without proper consideration of Nathan's evidence. The Court held that Broadspectrum's concession did not absolve the Authority from its duty to determine liability and that the Authority's failure to do so was problematic.

The Court of Appeal dismissed Broadspectrum's application for leave to appeal. It found that Broadspectrum's questions did not meet the threshold for appeal on a question of law due to their lack of general or public importance. The Court further concluded that the Authority's failure to determine liability before deciding on remedies was a significant error, and the partial concession by Broadspectrum did not justify bypassing this step. The Court of Appeal ordered Broadspectrum to pay Nathan's costs for the appeal on a Band A basis, along with usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Jason Nathan was employed by Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Limited as a lines mechanic and acting team leader. In June 2013, during a response to an incident in Wellington, one of Mr Nathan's team members received an electric shock. Broadspectrum initiated a disciplinary investigation, leading to Mr Nathan's dismissal in August 2013. Broadspectrum subsequently pursued a personal grievance claim for unjustified dismissal and sought reinstatement before the Employment Relations Authority. Broadspectrum agreed to meet the remedies sought in Mr Nathan's Statement of Problem, but only reinstating him to a position no less advantageous than his former position, not to his previous job. Mr Nathan challenged the remedies ordered in an appeal to the Employment Court. The Employment Court allowed the appeal and ordered Mr Nathan's reinstatement to his previous position, along with lost wages and costs.

The case originated in the Employment Relations Authority, where Broadspectrum sought reinstatement of Mr Nathan. The Authority ordered reinstatement to a position no less advantageous than Mr Nathan's previous role, but not to his former position. Mr Nathan appealed this decision to the Employment Court, which allowed the appeal and ordered reinstatement to his previous position, along with lost wages and costs. Broadspectrum then sought leave to appeal the Employment Court's decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the question of whether the Authority was correct not to determine the justifiability of the dismissal a matter of general or public importance?
2. Does the Authority have a duty to determine liability and remedy even if a party concedes on the remedy?
3. Was there a breach of natural justice in not hearing further from Mr Nathan in evidence before determining the remedy?

Held
1. The court concluded that the question of whether the Authority was correct not to determine the justifiability of the dismissal was not a matter of general or public importance.
2. The court held that the Authority has a duty to determine liability and remedy even if a party concedes on the remedy.
3. The court found that there was a breach of natural justice in not hearing further from Mr Nathan in evidence before determining the remedy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for leave to appeal against the Employment Court's decision. The Court of Appeal held that the questions raised by the applicant, Broadspectrum (New Zealand) Limited, were of no general or public importance and were not deserving of further hearing before the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal noted that any question concerning whether the Authority needed to go further with its investigation into liability and remedy, if a party conceded liability and remedy, was necessarily fact and context specific and lacked general or public importance.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the Employment Court's characterisation that the Authority's determination in this case was more akin to some sort of consent order, but one made without the consent of one of the parties. The Court of Appeal held that the Authority's obligation under s 157 of the Employment Relations Act 2000 was to determine a matter according to its substantial merits. The Court of Appeal found that the Authority failed to meet the requirements of s 157(1) of the Act by not making a liability determination at all before imposing a remedy when remedies were very much in issue. The partial remedial concession of the applicant did not justify any such shortcut. The Court of Appeal also held that there was a breach of natural justice in not hearing further from Mr Nathan in evidence before determining the remedy. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that the Authority has a duty to determine liability and remedy even if a party concedes on the remedy and that there must be compliance with the requirements of natural justice.