Boon v Estate of Tuwhangai

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA575/2022
 [2024] NZCA 107

BETWEEN

CHRISTINE EVELYN BOON
Appellant

AND

THE ESTATE OF NIKI UENUKUITERANGIHOKA TUWHANGAI
Respondent

Hearing:

7 February 2024

Court:

Goddard, Thomas and Wylie JJ

Counsel:

P V Cornegé and N A Jeffery for Appellant
L L Fraser and K L Vodanovich for Respondent

Judgment:

12 April 2024 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe respondent’s application to strike out the notice of appeal is declined. 

BThe appeal is dismissed.

CThere is no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Wylie J)

Introduction

  1. This appeal arises out of a dispute about the ownership of 335.184 shares (the shares) in Māori freehold land known as the Kawhia U2B block (the land).  There are 415 shares in the land and the shares comprise the majority shareholding.  The dispute arose between the appellant, Christine Boon, and the respondent, the late Niki Tuwhangai.  Mrs Boon is the adopted daughter, and administrator of the estate, of the late June Ormsby.  Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby were whānau; they were raised together and were very close. 

  2. In late-1989, Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby decided to purchase the shares from the then owner, Moekau Moke.  An agreement for sale and purchase was entered into.  The sale of the shares required the approval of the Māori Land Court.  After various preliminary issues had been sorted out, a meeting of all owners was summoned and, on 6 December 1991, they resolved to approve the sale of the shares to Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby as joint tenants.  An order was made confirming this resolution by the Māori Land Court on 23 March 1992 (the 1992 order).[1]  The purchase price was paid and the shares were transferred to Mrs Ormsby and Mr Tuwhangai.

    [1]Kawhia U2B Block (1992) 106 Otorohanga MB 84 (106 OT 84) [the 1992 order].

  3. Mrs Ormsby passed away in November 2016.  Some time later, Mr Tuwhangai filed an application for transmission by survivorship of Mrs Ormsby’s interest in the shares with the Māori Land Court.  Mrs Boon filed an objection.  She considered that the 1992 order should have recorded that the shares were to be transferred to Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby as tenants in common, with the result that the shares would not pass by survivorship.  Rather, a half interest in the shares would form part of Mrs Ormsby’s estate. 

  4. After unsuccessfully seeking to reverse the effect of the 1992 order in another proceeding before the Māori Land Court,[2] Mrs Boon applied to the Chief Judge of that Court under s 45 of Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993 (the Act).  Mrs Boon asserted that there had been a mistake in the presentation of the facts of the case to the Māori Land Court in 1992.  She asked the Chief Judge to correct the 1992 order pursuant to s 44.  Relevantly, s 44 provides that the Chief Judge can cancel or amend an order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boon v Estate of Tuwhangai and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal arises out of a dispute about the ownership of 335.184 shares in Māori freehold land. The dispute is between the appellant, Christine Boon, and the respondent, the late Niki Tuwhangai. Mrs Boon is the adopted daughter, and administrator of the estate, of the late June Ormsby. Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby were whānau; they were raised together and were very close. In late-1989, Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby decided to purchase the shares from the then owner, Moekau Moke. The sale of the shares required the approval of the Māori Land Court. After various preliminary issues had been sorted out, a meeting of all owners was summoned and, on 6 December 1991, they resolved to approve the sale of the shares to Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby as joint tenants. An order was made confirming this resolution by the Māori Land Court on 23 March 1992 (the 1992 order). Mrs Ormsby passed away in November 2016. Some time later, Mr Tuwhangai filed an application for transmission by survivorship of Mrs Ormsby’s interest in the shares with the Māori Land Court. Mrs Boon filed an objection. She considered that the 1992 order should have recorded that the shares were to be transferred to Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby as tenants in common, with the result that the shares would not pass by survivorship. Rather, a half interest in the shares would form part of Mrs Ormsby’s estate. After unsuccessfully seeking to reverse the effect of the 1992 order in another proceeding before the Māori Land Court, Mrs Boon applied to the Chief Judge of that Court under s 45 of Te Ture Whenua Māori Act 1993. Mrs Boon asserted that there had been a mistake in the presentation of the facts of the case to the Māori Land Court in 1992. She asked the Chief Judge to correct the 1992 order pursuant to s 44. After a contested hearing, the Chief Judge found that there had been a mistake in the presentation of the facts and that the Māori Land Court had erred in making the 1992 order. He amended the order to record that Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby held the shares as tenants in common rather than as joint tenants. Mr Tuwhangai appealed this decision to the Māori Appellate Court. That Court allowed the appeal and found that there had been no error in the presentation of the relevant facts to the Māori Land Court when it made the 1992 order. The Court revoked the order of the Chief Judge and affirmed the 1992 order. Mrs Boon now appeals the Māori Appellate Court’s decision. The late Mr Tuwhangai resisted the appeal and supported the Māori Appellate Court’s judgment. He also made a separate application seeking to strike out Mrs Boon’s appeal. The Court held that the evidence did not prove, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby intended to hold the shares as tenants in common. It was not satisfied that there was an error in the presentation of the facts to the Māori Land Court in 1992. As a result, the appeal was upheld. Under s 56(1) of the Act, the Court revoked the order made by the Chief Judge and affirmed the orders made by the Māori Land Court on 23 March 1992 and on 14 December 2018. Mrs Boon filed a notice of appeal in this Court against the judgment of the Māori Appellate Court. Mrs Boon asserted that the Court erred in its interpretation of key facts. She alleged that Mrs Ormsby and Mr Tuwhangai intended that the shares would be held by them as tenants in common and that Mr Tuwhangai’s evidence before the Chief Judge did not solely reflect his preferences with the benefit of hindsight, but rather demonstrated his intention and understanding at the time he purchased the shares. Further, it was alleged that the agreement for sale and purchase was not a red herring. Rather it was the legal foundation for the transaction which was subsequently approved by the 1992 order. It was noted that it includes the words “tenants in common”. It was alleged that the Māori Land Court erred in its conclusion that there was no error or omission by the Māori Land Court in 1992 and that the relevant errors and omissions were correctly identified by the Chief Judge. The Court held that the evidence did not prove, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Tuwhangai and Mrs Ormsby intended to hold the shares as tenants in common. It was not satisfied that there was an error in the presentation of the facts to the Māori Land Court in 1992. As a result, the appeal was upheld. Under s 56(1) of the Act, the Court revoked the order made by the Chief Judge and affirmed the orders made by the Māori Land Court on 23 March 1992 and on 14 December 2018. The respondent’s application to strike out the notice of appeal is declined. The appeal is dismissed. There is no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established