Body Corporate S73368 v Otway

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2015-470-146 [2016] NZHC 1070

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE S73368

Plaintiff

AND

ROSALIND KAY OTWAY (NOW ROSALIND KAY WRIGHT) AND HOLFORD SANDFORD TRUSTEE SERVICE COMPANY LIMITED First Defendants

PHILLIP HERBERT DORR SHARON LESLEY DORR and DONALD RAYMOND PILBROW Second Defendant

Hearing: 7 and 8 March 2016

Appearances:

D P Shore with N Pouwels-Strang for Plaintiff on 7 March 2016
D P Shore for Plaintiff on 8 March 2016
G Brittain for Defendants

Judgment:

8 March 2016

Reasons:

23 May 2016

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDG R M BELL

Reasons for Judgment delivered by me on 23 May 2016  at 10:00am

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………………………………….

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

McCaw Lewis (Daniel Shore), Hamilton, for the plaintiff

Lyon O’Neale Arnold (M O’Neale), Tauranga, for the defendants

BODY CORPORATE S73368 v OTWAY (WRIGHT) AND HOLFORD SANDFORD TRUSTEE [2016] NZHC 1070 [23 May 2016]

[1]      At the end of the hearing on 8 March 2016 I said that I would dismiss the

plaintiff’s application for summary judgment.  I now give my reasons.

[2]      The plaintiff sues the defendants under s 126 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 to recover some of the expenses it incurred in carrying out repairs which it says benefited the defendants’ units substantially more than other units.   It is the body corporate for a unit title development, Tower Two, 1 Marine Parade, Mt Maunganui. There  is  a  neighbouring  building,  Tower  One.  The  defendants  each  own  an apartment on the first floor of Tower Two, apartments 1A and 1B respectively.  The building has a podium at street level with shops, and a 10-floor tower on top with residential apartments.  There are seven shops and 38 apartments, a total of 45 unit titles.    The  defendants’ apartments  on  the  first  floor  have  exclusive  access  to extensive balcony areas on the top of the podium.

[3]      For  some  years,  at  least  since  2009,  the  shops  at  street  level  suffered problems with water ingress.   The body corporate investigated the problem, took professional advice and undertook remedial work.1    It levied all the owners to pay for the work.   After the work was completed, the body corporate considered that certain units within the complex had benefited more than the others.  It contends that the first and second defendants are among those who received additional benefits.  In

this proceeding, it seeks to recover the expenses it says it incurred in providing those additional benefits to the defendants’ units.  It claims $223,792.46 from each of them under s 126.  It applied for summary judgment.

Summary judgment principles

[4]      There is no dispute as to the applicable principles.   There is a convenient summary in Krukziener v Hanover Finance Ltd.2

The principles are well settled.   The question on a summary judgment application is whether the defendant has no defence to the claim; that is, that there is no real question to be tried. … The court must be left without any

1      There were similar problems…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate S73368 v Otway and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1070
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand dealt with an application for summary judgment brought by Body Corporate S73368 against Rosalind Kay Otway and Holford Sandford Trustee Service Company Limited, and Phillip Herbert Dorr, Sharon Lesley Dorr, and Donald Raymond Pilbrow. The body corporate sought to recover expenses for repairs that it claimed benefited the defendants' units substantially more than other units. The defendants contested the claims, arguing that the benefits were not substantial or that the apportionment of costs was inequitable. The court had to decide whether the body corporate had established that the defendants had no defence to the claim. The court found that there were significant disputes over the nature and extent of the benefits, the validity of the cost claims, and the appropriateness of the apportionment. The court also noted that the body corporate had not joined all the relevant parties and that it might have to reassess its approach to the litigation. The court dismissed the application for summary judgment and ordered a case management conference. The defendants were awarded costs for preparation and hearing the application, but not for filing notices of opposition.