Body Corporate 81340 v Knight

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-Ā-TARA ROHE

CIV 2016-485-220

[2018] NZHC 2143

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 81340

Applicant

AND

ZENA RENEE KNIGHT AND YEE GOOD FORTUNE INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Respondents

AND

WINIFRED MARIA BOSCH; and WINIFRED MARIA BOSCH,

EDWIN FREDERICK RUTHVEN COOKE and NICKOLAS MAXWELL COLE as

executors of the estate of Florus Bosch; and NICHOLAS MAXWELL COLE; AND GEERTRUDIA JACOMINA COLE; AND BLAIR ALLEN McCARDLE AND JOHN VINCENT McCARDLE

Interested Parties

Hearing: 30 April 2018

Counsel:

A J Knowsley and D W Hunt for Applicant N B Dunning for Respondents

Judgment:

20 August 2018


JUDGMENT OF ELLIS J


BODY CORPORATE 81340 v KNIGHT AND YEE GOOD FORTUNE INVESTMENTS LTD [2018] NZHC 2143 [20 August 2018]

[1]    Ms Knight and Yee Good Fortune Investment Ltd (Yee), own units in an apartment complex which, due to its proximity to the Paraparaumu Golf Course, is known as “the Links”.1 The complex has weathertightness issues. Steps have, since 2011, been taken to remediate these. Further work is required. But the applicants are engaged in a longstanding dispute with the Body Corporate and with the majority of unit holders both as to the nature of the remedial work required and about how payment for both past and present works should be apportioned. They have refused to pay the special levies that have been struck and (in Yee’s case) have stopped paying general levies. The say the levies are unlawful, although Yee has had judgment entered against it in that regard.2

[2]    The present object of the applicants’ dissent is the Body Corporate’s originating application for the approval of a scheme under s 74 of the Unit Titles  Act 2010 (the 2010 Act). That application has a four-day hearing scheduled for October 2018.

[3]    Ms Knight and Yee have applied to have the Body Corporate’s s 74 application struck out. They say that the draft scheme lacks merit and is being improperly sought by the Body Corporate. Although I will come back to the particular arguments advanced on their behalf later in this judgment, I record at the outset my view that such an application seems inapt. I say that because:

(a)it cuts across the purpose of the originating application process;

(b)it is indisputable (and as I understand it the applicants do not really dispute) that a scheme is required and, indeed, there have been Court directions to that effect;3


1      Ms Knight owns Unit 13 and Yee owns Unit 6. For convenience, I refer to them as “the applicants” in this judgment because it is their application for strike out which is its subject.

2      Yee Good Fortune Ltd v Body Corporate 81340 [2017] NZHC 611 (the recent result noted at the end of this judgment).

3 Discussed below at [28].

(c)it seems inconsistent with what s 74 plainly contemplates can be an iterative settlement/approval process;4 and

(d)many of the factual matters raised by the applicants in support of their application are both complex and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 81340 v Knight and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 2143
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Zena Knight and Yee Good Fortune Investments Limited, sought to have the Body Corporate’s s 74 application struck out. The Body Corporate sought approval of a scheme to remediate the damage caused by water ingress at the Links, an apartment complex. The applicants argued that the proposed scheme lacked merit and was improperly sought by the Body Corporate. They claimed that the scheme was an attempt to validate the Body Corporate’s unlawful conduct, to impose levies that it was not able to lawfully impose, to validate the unlawful imposition and collection of levies, and to protect the Body Corporate management from civil action. They also argued that the scheme was outside the scheme of both the 1972 and 2010 Unit Titles Acts, that the DMP had involved work on privately owned decks, balconies, cladding and doors and windows for which the body corporate was not responsible, and that the Body Corporate had had no authority to pursue the DMP. The applicants further argued that the remediation work had been done without definitive investigation into the causes of the leaking, that the scheme was inadequately detailed, and that too much was left to the discretion of the Body Corporate. They also claimed that the proposed sharing of the cost to each owner on a utility interest basis was unfair, that the scheme granted the Body Corporate unacceptably sweeping powers binding not only current but also future owners, and that membership support for the DMP was of little or no significance. Finally, they argued that it was impossible to ascertain what the outcome would be if the scheme were to be approved, because of the lack of clarity around the DMP.

The Court found that none of the matters raised by the applicants were of a kind that could properly lead to the s 74 being struck out. The Court observed that a strike out seemed conceptually ill suited to a case such as this, and that the application had raised issues which could usefully benefit from further thought. The Court dismissed the application to strike out the Body Corporate’s application for a scheme under s 74 of the 2010 Act, and ordered that costs should follow the event in the ordinary way, on a 2B basis.

The Court noted that subsequent to the hearing, Yee had been placed in liquidation, on the petition of the Body Corporate. The Court assumed that this would mean that it would be unable to oppose the substantive s 74 application in October without the consent of either the liquidators or the Court. The Court also noted that it would be a matter for Ms Knight to decide what she would do.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.