Body Corporate 68792 v Memelink

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-202 [2016] NZHC 2452

IN THE MATTER of section 141 of the Unit titles Act 2010

AND

IN THE MATTER

of an originating application to appoint an administrator

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 68792
First Applicant

AND

SYNERGY ENTERPRISES LIMITED, JAMES AND CAROLINE MCKERNAN, STEVEN AND VALDA SCHECKTER AND GEOFFREY ARDEN

Second Applicants

AND

HARRY MEMELINK AND IAN TREVOR NIELL HAMILTON AS TRUSTEES OF LINK TRUST NO 1

First Respondent

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

D G Dewar for Applicants
Mr Memelink in Person

Judgment:

14 October 2016

JUDGMENT (COSTS) OF CLARK J

[1]     On 9 September 2016 I delivered a judgment extending the period of administration of Body Corporate 68792, and appointing Robert Gary Naylor as administrator. Associated orders and directions were made.

[2]      I awarded costs to the applicants on a 2B basis.  The applicants were invited, if they wished, to submit a memorandum which included a 2B costs calculation.

BODY CORPORATE 68792 v SYNERGY ENTERPRISES LIMITED, JAMES AND CAROLINE MCKERNAN, STEVEN AND VALDA SCHECKTER AND GEOFFREY ARDEN [2016] NZHC 2452 [14

October 2016]

Mr Memelink was to file any memorandum in response within five working days of

receipt of the applicants’ memorandum.

[3]      Mr Dewar, counsel for the applicants, filed a memorandum on 22 September

2016.  Mr Memelink’s memorandum in response was filed on 10 October 2016.

[4]      The  following  calculation  of  the  applicants’ costs  are  on  the  basis  of  a determination of an interlocutory application.

COSTS

22. Preparing and filing interlocutory application

0.6 days

$1,338.00

Appearance at hearing

0.5 days

$1,115.00

Sealing Orders

0.2 days

$446.00

Subtotal:

1.3 days

$2,899.00

DISBURSEMENT

Filingfee

$200.00

Sealingfee

$50.00

Total:

$3,149.00

[5]      Mr Dewar asks the Court to award an additional 1.5 days for preparation because the application for extended administration involved appearances and attendances which are not taken account of in the above costs calculation. Specifically, Mr Dewar refers to an appearance for the purpose of obtaining interim orders which were granted by Williams J on 29 June, the preparation and filing of memoranda and administrators’ reports and an affidavit.

[6]      No written submissions were filed for the hearing before me.  Nonetheless, Mr Dewar asks the Court to award additional costs taking into account the above appearances and attendances.

[7]      Mr Memelink opposes the additional costs.  He points out that the cost of an administrator providing regular written reports to the Court is already covered and levied by BC68792.  Claims for these reports as additional costs is unjust and unfair Mr Memelink says.

[8]      Mr Memelink’s memorandum addressed additional matters arising in other proceedings in which he is involved namely CIV-2013-485-5775, CIV-2016-485-141 and   CIV-2016-485-566.      Two   of   the   proceedings   have   been   brought   by Mr Memelink and either indirectly or directly involve Mr Dewar.   Mr Memelink referred to the stress and the cost of having to “fight these ongoing matters” and continue the cases.   For all these reasons he says neither the costs sought nor any additional costs should be granted.

[9]      I agree…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 68792 v Memelink and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Body Corporate 68792 brought an application to the High Court of New Zealand, seeking to extend the period of administration of the body corporate and to appoint an administrator. The application was made against Harry Memelink and Ian Trevor Niall Hamilton as trustees of Link Trust No 1, among others. The applicants sought costs on a 2B basis, and Mr. Dewar, counsel for the applicants, submitted a memorandum with a detailed costs calculation. Mr. Memelink, in response, opposed the additional costs sought by the applicants. The key legal issues before the Court were whether the costs claimed by the applicants were reasonable and whether there were grounds to award additional costs beyond what was calculated in the memorandum. The Court found that the costs of the administrators' reports should not be factored into the award of costs, as they were already covered and levied by the Body Corporate. The Court also determined that the costs calculated by Mr. Dewar for preparing and filing the interlocutory application, his appearance at the hearing, and sealing the orders, along with the filing and sealing fees, did not properly reflect the underlying principle that costs are to represent a reasonable contribution to costs actually and reasonably incurred. However, the Court found that aspects of the respondent's conduct of the proceeding justified the payment of increased costs. The Court allowed an additional 1.5 days for preparation, bringing the total costs to $4,724.00.
In summary, the Court allowed an additional 1.5 days for preparation, bringing the total costs to $4,724.00, which was in addition to the sum calculated in the schedule attached to Mr. Dewar’s memorandum dated 21 September 2016. The Court's decision was based on the reasonable conduct of the applicants and the unreasonable conduct of the respondent in resisting an inevitable outcome and making repetitive and irrelevant submissions. The Court emphasised that the increased costs were not due to the failure of the respondent to accept an offer of settlement, but rather due to the respondent's unreasonable conduct and the time and expense it caused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.