Body Corporate 366567 v Equus Industries Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA21/2022
 [2022] NZCA 80

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 366567
First Appellant

AMER LIMITED & ORS
Second Appellants

AND

EQUUS INDUSTRIES LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

22 March 2022

Court:

Kós P, Woolford and Dunningham JJ

Counsel:

G B Lewis and S N Zellman for Appellants
E-J M Tucker for Respondent
C M Meechan QC and S C Price for Auckland Council

Judgment:

25 March 2022 at 3pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe appellants are granted leave to adduce the reply evidence tendered.

CThere is no order for costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Kós P)

  1. This appeal concerns an $140 million claim alleging defective approval and construction of a large apartment block on Gore Street, Auckland.   Naturally, the primary defendant is the local authority.  Trial is expected to take 20 weeks.  Three prior fixtures have been vacated.  Trial is now due to commence in May 2022.  Exigency abbreviates this judgment.

  2. The question here is whether the appellant plaintiffs should have leave to file evidence in reply to evidence filed by the respondent defendant, one of the building subcontractors.  The evidence filed by the respondent was to support an affirmative defence of contributory negligence.  Walker J declined the appellants leave to file reply evidence.[1] 

    [1]Body Corporate 366567 v Auckland Council [2021] NZHC 3578 [Judgment appealed]. The proceeding was filed in 2014, predating the Senior Courts Act 2016, so prior leave to appeal this interlocutory judgment is not required: Judicature Act 1908, s 66.

  3. The primary defendant, Auckland Council (the Council), pleaded contributory negligence by the appellants in these terms, summarised by Lang J in a minute:[2]  

    In an amended statement of defence filed on the close of pleadings date in November 2018 the Council pleaded affirmative defences based on contributory negligence and voluntary assumption of risk.  It will argue that unit owners who obtained minutes of meetings of the body corporate held after 25 June 2009 acquired their units with knowledge of the defects and therefore voluntarily assumed risk when they did so.  It will allege that unit owners who failed to obtain copies of the minutes prior to acquiring their units are guilty of contributory negligence.

    [2]Body Corporate 366567 v Auckland Council HC Auckland CIV-2014-404-716, 28 June 2019 at [2]. The Council’s pleading is not before us.

  4. The respondent however pleaded it in slightly different terms:[3] 

    If the plaintiffs are able to satisfy the Court that damage has been suffered (which is denied) then the plaintiffs have caused or contributed to their own loss in that they:

    (a)purchased the property without seeking appropriate expert advice in relation to the condition to the building prior to purchase; and

    (b) purchased the property at a time when there was a heightened awareness of defects to buildings and failed to protect themselves from that loss.

    [3]This is the current pleading, filed in January 2019.  The original was filed in December 2014.

  5. The appellants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 366567 v Equus Industries Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZCA 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal brought by Body Corporate 366567 and Amer Limited against Equus Industries Limited, a subcontractor in a case concerning an $140 million claim for defective approval and construction of an apartment block in Auckland. The appeal was filed against an interlocutory decision by Walker J, who declined leave to file evidence in reply to evidence filed by the respondent to support an affirmative defence of contributory negligence. The trial was expected to take 20 weeks and had already been delayed by three prior fixtures. The appeal was heard by Kós P, Woolford and Dunningham JJ and the decision was handed down on 25 March 2022.

The central issue for the Court of Appeal was whether the appellants should have leave to file evidence in reply to evidence filed by the respondent in support of an affirmative defence of contributory negligence. The respondent filed evidence in November 2021, which the appellants sought to rebut by filing their own evidence two weeks later. The High Court declined leave for the appellants to file their evidence in reply. The Court of Appeal was satisfied that the High Court had erred in doing so and that the appellants should be granted leave to adduce their evidence in reply.

The Court of Appeal held that the High Court had erred in declining leave for the appellants to file evidence in reply to the respondent’s evidence. The Court held that the respondent had not objected to the late pleading of the appellants' reply and had proceeded on the basis that the affirmative defences were live and contested. The Court held that natural justice required the appellants to be allowed to adduce evidence in response to the respondent’s evidence unless to do so would be contrary to the interests of justice. The Court of Appeal held that the appellants' responsibility for the late pleading of their reply did not mean that they should be precluded from filing evidence in reply to the respondent’s evidence. The Court held that the respondent’s evidence was brief and not onerous to receive, and there was no risk that it would dislodge any fixture or otherwise render an injustice.

The appeal was allowed and the appellants were granted leave to adduce the reply evidence tendered. There was no order for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for $140 million alleging defective approval and construction of an apartment block on Gore Street, Auckland. The primary defendant is the Auckland Council, while Equus Industries Limited is a respondent, one of the building subcontractors. The proceeding was filed in 2014. The Council pleaded contributory negligence and voluntary assumption of risk as affirmative defences, arguing that unit owners who obtained minutes of meetings of the body corporate held after 25 June 2009 acquired their units with knowledge of the defects and therefore voluntarily assumed risk when they did so. Unit owners who failed to obtain copies of the minutes prior to acquiring their units are guilty of contributory negligence. The respondent pleaded a similar affirmative defence in slightly different terms. The appellants failed to file a reply answering either affirmative defence, as required by r 5.62 of the High Court Rules 2016. As a result, the affirmative defences might be treated as admitted, but the Court has a substantial discretion to do justice. The respondent filed evidence in support of the affirmative defence in the form of a supplementary statement from its expert, a Mr Hunt, on 2 November 2021. The appellants sought leave to file evidence in reply from its expert, a Mr Jones, two weeks later. However, the application was declined.

The appeal came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, with Kós P, Woolford, and Dunningham JJ hearing the case. The hearing took place on 22 March 2022, and the judgment was delivered on 25 March 2022 at 3 pm. The appeal concerns the question of whether the appellant plaintiffs should have leave to file evidence in reply to evidence filed by the respondent defendant, one of the building subcontractors. The evidence filed by the respondent was to support an affirmative defence of contributory negligence. Walker J declined the appellants leave to file reply evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appellant plaintiffs should have leave to file evidence in reply to evidence filed by the respondent defendant, one of the building subcontractors.
2. Whether the respondent's evidence in support of the affirmative defence of contributory negligence raises new matters beyond the scope of the affirmative defence pleaded by the respondent.

Held
1. The Court allowed the appeal, granting the appellants leave to file evidence in reply to the respondent's evidence.
2. The Court made no order for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by addressing the issue of whether the appellants should have leave to file evidence in reply to the respondent's evidence. The appellants had not filed a reply to the respondent's affirmative defence of contributory negligence as required by r 5.62 of the High Court Rules 2016. However, the Court held that the absence of a reply may not be determinative, and the Court has a substantial discretion to do justice in the matter. The respondent filed evidence in support of its affirmative defence in the form of a supplementary statement from its expert, Mr Hunt, on 2 November 2021. The appellants sought leave to file evidence in reply from its expert, Mr Jones, on 16 November 2021. The Court held that the High Court erred in declining the appellants leave to file reply evidence, and that natural justice required the appellants to be allowed to adduce evidence in response to the respondent's evidence unless it would be contrary to the interests of justice. The Court found that the respondent's evidence was not onerous and would not render an injustice. Therefore, the Court allowed the appeal and granted leave for the appellants to adduce the reply evidence tendered. The Court made no order for costs given that this was an interlocutory appeal and the appellants must take some responsibility for what had occurred.

The Court then addressed the issue of whether the respondent's evidence raised new matters beyond the scope of the affirmative defence pleaded by the respondent. The Court found that the respondent's evidence related more to matters already put in issue by the Council's affirmative defence, and saw neither error nor prejudice. Therefore, the Court held that the respondent's evidence did not raise new matters beyond the scope of the affirmative defence pleaded by the respondent.