Body Corporate 340942 v Thomas

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2017-404-3083

[2020] NZHC 1856

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 340942

First Applicant

TREVOR ALLAN BROWN
Second Applicant

AND

ELIZABETH THOMAS (in her capacity as executor of the estate of ELWYN MAVIS PACKWOOD)

First Respondent

cont …/2

Hearing: 29 July 2020

Appearances:

D Bigio QC, L M Van and K A Logan for Applicants No appearance for Respondents (no opposition filed)

Judgment:

29 July 2020


JUDGMENT OF LANG J

[on application for variation of scheme of arrangement]


This judgment was delivered by me on 29 July 2020 at 11.30 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date……………

Counsel / Solicitors:

D R Bigio QC, Auckland Anthony Harper, Auckland

BODY CORPORATE 340942 v THOMAS [2020] NZHC 1856 [29 July 2020]

ANDREW SHAUN HOLDING, SANDRA HOLDING AND JENNIFER EDITH ROSWELL

Second Respondents

DEREK GEORGE BOWMAN, JEAN BOWMAN, AND BRUCE CYRIL MCNIECE

Third Respondents

CHRISTINE LEE CARR AND DEBORAH ANNE EVANS

Fourth Respondents

JOHN SAMUEL RUDD AND GREEN VALLEY TRUSTEES LIMITED
Fifth Respondent

DOROTHY MARIA ESADNI, HECTOR ADOLF JOHN DOMINIC EDADNI, CHRISTOPHER PAUL CARUANA, JOSEPH THOMAS CARUANA, AND PAULINE JOSEPHINE CARUANA

Sixth Respondents

GREGORY MURRAY AND LYNNE MURRAY

Seventh Respondents

PATCHAYA RAMMANIYA
Eighth Respondents

H W H HOLDINGS LTD
Ninth Respondent

TRAMS INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Tenth Respondent

RONALD WALTER STROUD AND BARBARA MERCY STROUD

Eleventh Respondents

KEVIN REEVES BROWNE, JUDITH LYNETTE BROWNE AND CHD

TRUSTEES NO. 9 LIMITED
Twelfth Respondents

/3

ANN JANE SMITH AND BLB TRUSTEES LIMITED

Thirteenth Respondents

LESLIE ROY BROWN, MABEL DOROTHY BROWN AND JANICE CHRISTIAN JOHNSON

Fourteenth Respondents

CATHERINE GRACE BOOTH AND DILYS BOOTH

Fifteenth Respondents

STEWART DAVID JOHNS AND KAREN MARGARET JONES

Sixteenth Respondents

ELSIE EDGINTON, RONNIE EGINTON AND DAVID ANDREW EDGINTON

Seventeenth Respondents

CLIFFORD SEYMOUR WHITELAW AND WILLIAM FRANCES MCENTEE

(as Executors)

Eighteenth Respondents

BEVERLY DENISE BANKS, LAWRENCE JOHN BANKS AND ANDREW OWEN THOMAS

Nineteenth Respondents

LLOMA ZARA BRIDGENS
Twentieth Respondent

LYLE JOHN MCILRAITH, WALTER HUGH KETTELWELL AND MALCOLM EVERARD TAYLOR

Twenty-First Respondent

GRANT ALEXANDR DRINKROW AND KAREN CHRISTINE DRINKROW
Twenty-Second Respondents

ASB BANK LIMITED
Twenty-Third Respondents

BANK OF NEW ZEALAND

Twenty-Fourth Respondents

/4

THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LIMITED

Twenty-Fifth Respondents

CHUBB INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED (ORION INSURANCE)

Twenty-Sixth Respondent

[1]    This proceeding relates to an apartment complex situated in Selwyn Road, Howick. The complex comprises a single building containing 23 residential apartment units.

[2]    On 11 April 2018, Palmer J approved a scheme of arrangement under s 74 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (the Act) providing for remedial work be carried out on the complex to address weathertightness issues that the unit owners had discovered.1

[3]    The body corporate subsequently commenced the remedial work under the scheme of arrangement approved by the Court. In carrying out this work it discovered that the complex will require additional remedial work that was not anticipated when the scheme was initially approved by the Court. The additional work relates particularly to internal walls, bathrooms and kitchens.

[4]    The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 340942 v Thomas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 1856
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Body Corporate 340942 v Thomas, the applicants sought to vary a scheme of arrangement under section 74 of the Unit Titles Act 2010, which had previously been approved by the Court. The scheme related to the remedial works required to address weathertightness issues in an apartment complex in Howick. The body corporate sought to vary the scheme to adjust the scope of the remedial work and the allocation of costs among the unit owners. This application was brought before Lang J, who was tasked with deciding whether the proposed variation of the scheme was appropriate.

The legal issues central to this case involved the criteria for approving a variation to a scheme of arrangement. The principles established in Tisch v Body Corporate No 318596 were applicable, which required the Court to consider whether the proposed scheme was sufficiently detailed, balanced the interests of all unit owners, and departed from the Act no more than necessary to achieve fairness. Furthermore, the Court needed to assess the level of support for the variation among the unit owners and whether the variation treated any unit owner unfairly.

Lang J determined that the proposed variation enjoyed broad support from the unit owners, as evidenced by the Extraordinary General Meeting where 17 out of 18 attending unit owners voted in favour of the variation. This level of support was deemed significant, particularly given the advanced stage of the remedial works. The concerns of Elizabeth Thomas, the sole dissenting unit owner, were addressed by the Court, which found that the cost allocation for internal partition walls should remain according to utility interest due to the presence of important infrastructure within those walls. In all other respects, Mrs Thomas would be required to meet the cost of the internal fitout of her unit similarly to other unit owners. The Court concluded that the proposed variation met the criteria for approval, as it was sufficiently detailed, balanced the interests of unit owners, and did not unfairly treat any unit owner.

In light of the findings, Lang J granted the body corporate leave to amend the interlocutory application by substituting a new Schedule One. An order was made approving the variation of the scheme of arrangement as sought in the amended application. This decision ensures that the remedial works can proceed in a manner that is fair and supported by the majority of unit owners, while addressing the specific concerns of the dissenting unit owner.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.