Body Corporate 336323 v Selwyn District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-000089 [2015] NZHC 1522

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 336323

First Plaintiff

ANTHONY VERNON SMITH & ORS Second Plaintiff

BODY CORPORATE 349497
Third Plaintiff

ALFRED WILLIAM TAYLOR & ORS Fourth Plaintiff

AND

SELWYN DISTRICT COUNCIL First Defendant

C LUND & SON LIMITED Second Defendant

TERRACE DOWNS LIMITED Third Defendant

ST JOHN DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED Fourth Defendant

GRAHAM BOND LIMITED First Third Party

ALUTECH WINDOWS & DOORS LIMITED

Second Third Party

HERBERT LAWRENCE JOHN GOVAN Fourth Third Party

CHRISTOPHER JOHN PREBBLE Fifth Third Party

CHRIS PREBBLE ARCHITECTS LIMITED

Sixth Third Party

A & H TILING LIMITED Seventh Third Party

BODY CORPORATE 336323 v SELWYN DISTRICT COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 1522 [2 July 2015]

BEHAVDDIN HOOMAN SHOLEPAK Eighth Third Party

RYAN COATING SERVICES LIMITED Ninth Third Party

BENJAMIN WILLIAM RYAN Tenth Third Party

GRAHAM DOUGLAS ARMITAGE Eleventh Third Party

Hearing: 18 June 2015

Appearances:

M J Wallace and K L Maclean for Applicant/Second Defendant P H Bremer and M R C Wolff for Respondents/Plaintiff and Second Plaintiffs

Judgment:

2 July 2015

INTERIM JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

Introduction

[1]      Terrace Downs is a golf course and accommodation complex in Coleridge Road, near the Rakaia Gorge in Canterbury.   Among other buildings, there are a number of apartments, which were erected in Stages.  The first plaintiff is the body corporate, under the Unit Titles Act 1972, for the apartments known as Stage 2 of Terrace Downs Apartments (“the apartments”), and the third plaintiff is the body corporate for Stage 3.  The second and fourth plaintiffs are the current owners of the apartments in these Stages, respectively.

[2]      The  first   defendant   is   the   Local  Authority  in   the   area,   which   had responsibilities in relation to the building work on the property under the Building Act 1991, the second defendant is the building contractor for Stages 2 and 3, and the third and fourth defendants were responsible for the development.

[3]      The plaintiffs allege that the apartments were constructed with a number of defects and as a result there has been moisture ingress through the exterior envelopes of  the  buildings  in  which  the  apartments  are  contained,  and  into  the  structure, timbers, stone veneer of the chimneys, internal linings, electrical fittings, floor coverings and curtains.  The plaintiffs say that extensive repairs will be required to rectify the defects and damage, and that in addition to incurring this loss, they have suffered consequential losses by way of loss of rental income (as the apartments are used as part of a commercial accommodation complex), the cost of alternative accommodation, and other related costs.  They also say that as a result of the defects identified  in  the buildings  they have lost  part  of the  value  of their apartments, presently estimated at five per cent.

[4]      The plaintiffs lay responsibility for this at the door of the Council in relation to its issuing of building consents, its inspection of the works during construction, and its issue of code compliance certificates, and on the developers.  They also lay…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 336323 v Selwyn District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiffs, who are body corporates and owners of apartments in two stages of a golf course and accommodation complex, sought to bring claims against the defendants for defects in the construction of the buildings. The second defendant, Lund, applied for an order striking out the claims against it on the ground that they were filed outside the time limits set for the issuing of proceedings by the Limitation Act 1950. The sole issue in this application was whether the causes of action in relation to Stage 2 and in relation to Stage 3 accrued more than six years before the respective dates on which this proceeding was commenced in relation to each of those Stages.

The court found that the pleadings against Lund did not disclose a cause of action arising within the limitation period. The plaintiffs argued that none of the plaintiffs had sufficient knowledge of the state of the buildings before July 2008 for the causes of action to have accrued, in terms of the principle enunciated in Hamlin. However, the court found that the facts disclosed on this application did not enable the Court to reach the degree of certainty on this point which would be required for the claim against Lund to be struck out. In short, the court was not certain it could not succeed. But it could not succeed on the pleading as it stood.

The court ordered that the application to strike out should be adjourned to give the plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their pleading. If the plaintiffs elected to amend their pleading against Lund, they were to file and serve an amended statement of claim by 4 August 2015, and Lund was to file and serve a memorandum by 18 August advising the Court whether it wished to proceed with its application to strike out, or whether it could be dismissed. If the plaintiffs did not file an amended statement of claim by 5 pm on 4 August, their claim against Lund would be struck out at that time without further order, and the call on 20 August 2015 would be vacated. Costs were reserved for the time being, and an award of costs would be considered once the application was finally determined.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established