Body Corporate 326421 v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV2009-404-008136 [2013] NZHC 753

BETWEEN  BODY CORPORATE 326421

First Plaintiff

ANDWILLIAM MILLER AND RAEWYN MILLER & ORS

Second Plaintiffs

ANDAUCKLAND COUNCIL First Defendant

ANDBROOKFIELD MULTIPLEX CONSTRUCTIONS (NZ) LIMITED Second Defendant

ANDWALKER ARCHITECTS LIMITED Third Defendant

ANDDOWNER EDI WORKS LIMITED Fourth Defendant

ANDFACADE TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED Fifth Defendant

ANDCHARLES NORAGER & SONS LIMITED

Sixth Defendant

ANDBOSTIK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Third Party

Hearing:         11 April 2013

Appearances: C Meechan, J Heatlie and T Rainey for the Plaintiffs

A R Galbraith QC and L Douglas for the First Defendant
D J Broadmore for the Second Defendant
J N Batchelor-Smith for the Third Party
M G Ring QC and M J Francis for the Underwriters

Judgment:      15 April 2013

BODY CORPORATE 326421 V AUCKLAND COUNCIL HC AK CIV 2009-404-008136 [15 April 2013]

JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

This judgment was delivered by me on 15 April 2013 at 11.30 am

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:………………

Counsel: C Meechan, Auckland:  christine@meechan.co.nz

T Rainey, Auckland:  tim.rainey@raineylaw.co.nz

J Heatlie, Auckland:  jeanne.heatlie@raineylaw.co.nz

A R Galbraith, Auckland:  argalbraith@shortlandchambers.co.nz D J Broadmore, Auckland:  david.broadmore@buddlefindlay.com L J Douglas, Auckland:  ljd@heaneyco.com

J N Batchelor-Smith, Auckland:  julia.batchelor-smith@minterellison.co.nz

M Ring, Auckland:  mring@bar.co.nz

M  J Francis, Auckland:  mjfrancis@dacbeachcroft.com

[1]      The plaintiffs are the Body Corporate and owners of units in a multi-unit residential apartment and retail complex in Orewa, north of Auckland, known as the “Nautilus”.  They have issued these proceedings seeking to recover approximately

$22 million, being their estimate of the costs required to rectify alleged defects in the building.

[2]      The second defendant, Brookfield Multiplex Constructions (NZ) Limited (Brookfield Multiplex), was contracted to build the Nautilus as head contractor. Brookfield Multiplex not only faces the plaintiffs’ claims; the first and third defendants and the third party have cross claimed against it on the basis that if they are liable to the plaintiffs, they are entitled to contribution from Brookfield Multiplex as a concurrent tortfeasor.

[3]      Brookfield Multiplex went into liquidation on 3 December 2012.  This had the effect of staying the claims and cross claims against it in terms of s 248(1)(c) of the Companies Act 1993.  The liquidator has not given his consent to the proceeding continuing against Brookfield Multiplex because he does not wish to prejudice any insurance claim in respect of the company’s potential liability.

[4]      In these circumstances, the plaintiffs, the first and third defendants, and the third party, all apply for an order under s 248 for leave to continue their claims in the proceedings   against   Brookfield   Multiplex.   There   is   no   opposition   to   these applications and they can accordingly be granted.

[5] The plaintiffs also apply to join Brookfield Multiplex’s insurers (the Underwriters) as defendants to the proceedings, relying on the statutory charge created by s 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 or, alternatively, the comparable charge created by s 6 of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW). The parties accept that, for the purposes of the present application only, I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 326421 v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 753
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiffs, which include the Body Corporate and owners of units in a multi-unit residential and retail complex known as the "Nautilus," sought to recover approximately $22 million for the rectification of alleged defects in the building. The second defendant, Brookfield Multiplex Constructions (NZ) Limited, was the head contractor responsible for constructing the Nautilus. Brookfield Multiplex faced claims from the plaintiffs and cross-claims from the first and third defendants and a third party, who sought contribution from Brookfield Multiplex as a concurrent tortfeasor. Brookfield Multiplex went into liquidation, which resulted in the claims against it being stayed. The liquidator did not consent to the proceedings continuing against Brookfield Multiplex, as they did not wish to prejudice any insurance claim in respect of the company’s potential liability. The plaintiffs and the other parties sought leave to continue their claims against Brookfield Multiplex under s 248 of the Companies Act 1993. The plaintiffs also applied to join Brookfield Multiplex's insurers (the Underwriters) as defendants in the proceeding.

The central issue the court had to decide was whether s 9 of the Law Reform Act applied to the insurance contract between Brookfield Multiplex and the Underwriters. If it did, the parties agreed that leave should be granted to the plaintiffs and the first defendant under s 9(4) to claim against the Underwriters directly and for an order joining them to the proceeding. However, if s 9 did not apply to the insurance contract, the plaintiffs' alternative argument relied on s 6 of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act (NSW). The court held that s 9 of the Law Reform Act does not have extraterritorial effect and does not apply unless the New Zealand court has both personal jurisdiction and subject-matter jurisdiction in respect of the indemnity payment or debt. The situs of the debt was determined by the residence of the Underwriters, which was London. Therefore, the New Zealand courts had no subject-matter jurisdiction in respect of the monies payable by the Underwriters under the policy.

The applications by the plaintiffs, the first and third defendants, and the third party for leave to continue their claims in the proceeding against Brookfield Multiplex Constructions (NZ) Limited (in liquidation) were granted. However, the applications by the plaintiffs and the first defendant for leave to commence proceedings against the Underwriters were dismissed. The Underwriters were entitled to costs on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established