Body Corporate 207624 v Grimshaw & Co

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV 2018-404-002107

[2023] NZHC 979

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 207624

Plaintiff

AND

GRIMSHAW & CO

Defendant

Hearing:

18 July - 22 July 2022

25 July – 29 July 2022
1 August – 5 August 2022
8, 9, 11, 12 August 2022

Appearances:

D R Bigio QC, A G Holden and A J McCombie for the Plaintiff L Taylor QC, P J L Hunt, R J Scott and J T Neville-Smith for the Defendant

Judgment:

28 April 2023

Reissued:

10 May 2023


JUDGMENT OF TAHANA J


This judgment was delivered by me on 28 April 2023 at 3.00pm and

re-delivered by me on 10 May 2023 in accordance with High Court Rules 2016, r 11.10

…………………………

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

D R Bigio QC, Auckland Wilson Harle, Auckland McElroys, Auckland

BODY CORPORATE 207624 v GRIMSHAW & CO [2023] NZHC 979 [28 April 2023]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

[Para No.]

INTRODUCTION  1

FACTUAL BACKGROUND  15

Spencer on Byron  15

Building Defects Litigation  17

Instructing Grimshaws  18

Byron Ave – High Court decision  23

Owners joining as second plaintiffs  24
Conduct and distribution agreement  27
First mediation with Multiplex and settlement offer  38

Unit Titles Act 2010  40
Second mediation with Multiplex  41
Communications with non-plaintiff owners  46
Application for s 74 scheme  48
Discovery from non-plaintiff owners  54
Amending the statement of claim  59
Communications with Grimshaws about the CDA  60
Resolution to approve CDA  78

Preparation for trial  81

Settlement  84
Grimshaws advise on distribution  95
Disputes arise over CDA  101

Interpleader proceedings  110

Remedial work  123

2013 Building Consent and tenders  123
Establishment of remedial works committee  126

Investigation and prototyping  131

Extension to building consent  139

Letter of intent with Brosnan  148
Commencement of remedial works  151

EVIDENCE  152

Narrative of events  152

Expert evidence  156

APPROACH TO ASSESSING PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE                 157

Legal principles  157

Questions to be asked  162

EXISTENCE OF DUTY QUESTION  163

Legal principles  165

Analysis  174

SCOPE OF DUTY QUESTION  182

Legal principles  183

Analysis  191

Circumstances and purpose of advice  191

Purpose of CDA  197
UTA10 coming into force  201
Risks of claims by non-plaintiff owners  206

Conclusion  211

BREACH OF DUTY QUESTION  215

Standard of care  216

Alleged breaches  219

Failing to advise after the UTA10 came into force  221

Changes under the UTA10  223
Jewett – Court of Appeal decision  243
Practice of defendants during settlement  256
Loss on sale claims  284

Conclusion on breach of duty  286

FACTUAL CAUSATION QUESTION  290

Interpleader proceedings  292

Would an alternative CDA have been agreed?  292

Analysis  298

Delays to construction  312

Body Corporate’s position on delay  313
Grimshaws’ position on delay  316

Contracting with Arrow  320

Rescoping  329

Delay to investigations and prototyping  353

Overall delay  368
Contract pricing and construction start date  385

DUTY NEXUS QUESTION  389

LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY QUESTION  393

Costs of interpleader proceedings  394

Estoppel  396

Settlement agreement  399

Conclusion  404

Construction related costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 207624 v Grimshaw & Co and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 979
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, delivered a judgment in the case of Body Corporate 207624 v Grimshaw & Co. The Body Corporate 207624 sued Grimshaw & Co for professional negligence, claiming damages due to the latter's failure to advise on a Conduct and Distribution Agreement (CDA). The Body Corporate alleged that Grimshaw & Co breached its duty of care by not advising it after the Unit Titles Act 2010 came into force, that the CDA was invalid or ineffective. The court had to determine several issues, including whether Grimshaw & Co owed a duty of care to the Body Corporate, the scope of that duty, if it was breached, and whether the breach caused the claimed damages.

The court found that Grimshaw & Co did owe a duty of care to the Body Corporate and that this duty extended to advising on the CDA after the Unit Titles Act 2010 came into force. The court determined that Grimshaw & Co breached this duty by failing to advise the Body Corporate of the potential invalidity or ineffectiveness of the CDA. The breach caused the claimed damages, as the non-plaintiff owners' disputes over the CDA led to the interpleader proceedings and increased repair costs.

Regarding the defences, the court held that the claim was not statute-barred, the Body Corporate was not estopped from claiming damages, and the 2015 Settlement Agreement did not preclude the Body Corporate from claiming for losses suffered due to Grimshaw & Co's breach of duty. The court also found that the improved condition of the Building did not constitute betterment, and the Body Corporate had not failed to mitigate its losses.

The court awarded the Body Corporate damages for interpleader costs, increased repair costs, and interest on the damages, less interest earned on the settlement funds. The Body Corporate was also granted interest on the damages from the date the loss was quantified until the date of payment. The parties were directed to undertake calculations of damages in accordance with the court's methodology and confer with each other. If they could not agree on the calculations, they could file a memorandum and any supporting documents addressing the differences in calculations. The court encouraged the parties to agree on costs between themselves and granted the Body Corporate the right to file a costs memorandum if they could not agree.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.