Body Corporate 166208 v York Trustees Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV 2018-404-2623

[2020] NZHC 2463

UNDER Declaratory Judgments Act 1908 and the Unit Titles Act 2010

IN THE MATTER

of Body Corporate 166208

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 166208

First Plaintiff

ROGER MURRAY BELL and WEBB ROSS JOHNSON TRUSTEES LIMITED

Second Plaintiffs

MASAMI TODA

Third Plaintiff

DAVID JOHN COLLIS and JILLIAN KAY GAPES

Fourth Plaintiff

PAMELA TAYLOR
Fifth Plaintiff

AND

YORK TRUSTEES LIMITED

First Defendant

LYON TRUSTEE NO 10 LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 2 June 2020

Appearances:

J Heatlie and J P Wood for the Plaintiffs D J Barr for the Defendants

Judgment:

21 September 2020


JUDGMENT OF DUFFY J


This judgment is delivered by me on 21 September 2020 at 4:00pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

BODY CORPORATE 166208 v YORK TRUSTEES LIMITED [2020] NZHC 2463 [21 September 2020]

[1]    The applicants, who are the defendants in this civil proceeding, apply for an order striking out the plaintiffs’ statement of claim. The strike out application is opposed by the plaintiffs.

[2]    The plaintiffs are the body corporate of a unit title development consisting of 60 apartment dwellings situated at 30 York Street Parnell Auckland and four owners of the said apartments, each of which is referred to respectively in the statement of claim as: units Y22, Y23, Y28 and Y16.

[3]    The applicants are the former and present owners of another apartment within this development, which is referred to in the statement of claim as Unit G.

[4]    The plaintiffs allege that a failure to carry out proper maintenance work has led to some of the apartments suffering leaks which largely seem to be coming from deck areas above the respective apartments. Some of the affected apartment owners entered into agreements with the body corporate for remedial work to be undertaken. The owners of Unit G did not, and they would not agree to the body corporate having access to Unit G to undertake maintenance and repair work.

[5]    The trigger for the plaintiffs bringing this proceeding is foul water which is alleged to have come from the base of Unit G and dripped onto the courtyard of Unit Y16 on or about 27 September 2017. There are alleged additional internal leaks, the source of which is not pleaded, that are also alleged to affect the units adjoining and or below Unit G.

The pleadings

[6]    The plaintiffs allege the applicants have breached various obligations that they owe under s 80 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (UTA); namely:

(a)to permit the body corporate or its agents to enter Unit G pursuant to  s 80;

(b)to undertake repairs and maintenance to Unit G necessary to prevent damage to common property, building elements and other units;

(c)to prevent harm, being loss of amenity to other unit owners;

(d)to prevent foul water from leaking into other units; and

(e)to prevent economic loss to the owners of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 166208 v York Trustees Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2463
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Body Corporate 166208, along with several unit owners, sought declarations and orders against York Trustees Limited and Lyon Trustee No 10 Limited (the applicants) to compel the applicants to allow access to Unit G to remedy leaks and other defects that allegedly cause damage to other units. The applicants applied for the plaintiffs’ claim to be struck out on the basis that it was untenable and that the Unit Titles Act 2010 did not permit the relief sought. The plaintiffs argued that the applicants could not challenge the jurisdiction of the court by way of strike out and that the court had jurisdiction to grant the relief sought. Duffy J held that the plaintiffs' claim was untenable because the plaintiffs had not identified any legal authority for the declarations they sought. The court could not make binding declarations of right based on hypotheses when the relevant facts were in dispute and could not make declarations on disputed estimations of the repair work believed to be required. The court was also not permitted to make declarations that the applicants were liable to the second to fifth plaintiffs because the plaintiffs had not identified the legal authority for such liability and none was obvious. The plaintiffs could either proceed to do the repair work and then seek recovery of costs under s 126 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 or apply for a scheme under s 74 of the Act. The court struck out the plaintiffs’ claim.

The court granted leave for the parties to file memoranda as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established