IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2021-404-001820
[2021] NZHC 2938
IN THE MATTER of an order settling scheme under s 74 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 BETWEEN
BODY CORPORATE 146499
Applicant
AND
MG PARTNERSHIP LIMITED & ORS
First Respondents
ASB BANK LIMITED
Second RespondentBANK OF NEW ZEALAND
Third Respondent
WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Fourth RespondentCHARLES ROSS GEORGE
Fifth RespondentANDREW DAVIDSON WALKER
Sixth Respondent
Hearing: 1 November 2021 Appearances:
C Baker for Applicant
No appearance by or on behalf of Respondents
Judgment:
1 November 2021
JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J
Solicitors: Price Baker Berridge (C Baker and C Makaza), Auckland
BODY CORPORATE 146499 v MG PARTNERSHIP LIMITED & ORS [2021] NZHC 2938 [1 November 2021]
[1] The applicant, Body Corporate 146499 (the Body Corporate), is the body corporate of a unit title development at 18 – 22 Moselle Avenue, Henderson, Auckland. It comprises a two-storey building with a series of 19 terraced commercial/light industrial units. The development suffers from a number of building defects, which necessitates a remediation project.
[2] The Body Corporate now applies for a Court order under s 74 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (the Act) settling a scheme for the reinstatement of the development. By minute dated 5 October 2021, Davison J made directions as to service on all registered owners of each of the units, all mortgagees over any of the units, the caveator of Unit J, the insurer of the Body Corporate and the Registrar-General of Land. They have all been served.
[3] No opposition to the application has been filed and the Body Corporate did not expect any such opposition. The scheme of repair was approved unanimously by a vote of 17 of the 19 unit owners at the Annual General Meeting on 17 December 2020. The registered owners of Units D and R neither sent apologies nor voted.
[4] The leading authority in relation to the approval of s 74 schemes is Tisch v Body Corporate 318596.1 The Court of Appeal held that the Act imposed a three-step process on a Court considering an application to settle a scheme:
(a)The Court had to be satisfied that the development had been damaged or destroyed. Damage probably had to be substantial;
(b)The Court had to decide how to settle a scheme;
(c)The Court had to decide on the terms of the scheme. The aim was to balance the interest of each unit owner to achieve the fairest outcome to all unit owners.
[5]It also commented that five guiding principles emerged from the case law:
(i)A scheme with broad support was preferred;
(ii)The scheme was to be appropriately detailed;
(iii)The order could have retrospective effect so long as the Body Corporate had acted in accordance with the scheme prior to the Court’s approval;
(iv)Normally work was to be done to the same standard and at the same time; and
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 146499 v Mg Partnership Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NZHC 2938
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the damage to the development was substantial enough to warrant a section 74 scheme, deciding how to settle the scheme, and determining the terms of the scheme. The court referenced Tisch v Body Corporate 318596 as the leading authority, which outlined a three-step process for approving a scheme: establishing the extent of the damage, deciding how to settle the scheme, and determining the terms of the scheme. The court also considered five guiding principles emerging from the case law: a scheme with broad support is preferred, the scheme must be appropriately detailed, the order can have retrospective effect if the Body Corporate acted in accordance with the scheme, work should be done to the same standard and at the same time, and the terms of the scheme should not deviate from the Act and Body Corporate Rules unless necessary for fairness.
The court found that the damage to the development was indeed substantial, justified a section 74 scheme, and that the scheme had broad support and was sufficiently detailed. The proposed scheme included provisions for the division and allocation of costs and dispute resolution. The court concluded that it was desirable for the work to be carried out under a single building contract to maximize efficiency and minimize cost and disruption. All costs were to be raised by charging owners in accordance with their utility interest, except for additional work requested by an owner, which would be charged to the relevant owner in full. The court found nothing in the proposed scheme that would adversely affect the interests of any unit owner or mortgagee.
The court therefore granted the order settling the scheme in terms of paragraphs 1.1 to 1.4 of the originating application dated 10 September 2021. The order settles the scheme for the reinstatement of the development and will allow the Body Corporate to proceed with the necessary repairs. The court's decision was based on the substantial damage to the development, the broad support for the scheme, and the appropriateness of the scheme's terms in balancing the interests of all unit owners.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi