Bilgola Enterprises Ltd v Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND CA69/99
CA81/99
BETWEEN BILGOLA ENTERPRISES LIMITED

First Appellant

AND LAMBTON QUAY BOOKS LIMITED

Second Appellant

AND

J TODD AND A B TODD

Third Appellant

AND

B R CADDY AND J A CADDY

Fourth Appellant

AND DYMOCKS FRANCHISE SYSTEMS (NSW) PTY LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 29, 30, 31 May, 1 & 2 June 2000
Coram: Richardson P
Henry J
Keith J
Appearances: J R F Fardell, A I C Denton and M Peters for Appellants
R J Asher QC, J L Land and R E Butcher for Respondent
Judgment: 6 July 2000

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY HENRY J

  1. The proceedings giving rise to this appeal and cross-appeal followed cancellation of three franchise agreements.   The High Court hearing, which commenced 28 September 1998, occupied in all some seven weeks, involving a large volume of evidence and a mass of documentary material.   In a judgment delivered on 26 February 1999, and reported at 8 TCLR 612 Hammond J rejected all claims made by the franchisees under the agreements, and allowed one of the several claims made by the franchisor granting a series of orders for relief.   This has been a dispute bitterly contested between the parties since the inception of proceedings, with a plethora of issues being raised on both sides.   The hearing in this Court was not notable either for any significant narrowing of the trial issues or for focussing on central appeal points.   The parties appeared determined to repeat most of the many arguments which were presented to the High Court

General background

  1. The respondent is the franchise arm of the Dymocks group of companies, which operates a well established retail bookselling business based in Australia.   Its franchising system was extended to New Zealand.   On 24 May 1994, the third appellants Mr and Mrs Todd entered into a franchise agreement with the respondent (Dymocks) in respect of leased premises known as the Atrium, situated in central Auckland.   They assigned their interests to the first appellant, Bilgola a company of which they are the shareholders and directors.   On 7 November 1996 Bilgola entered into a second similar franchise agreement relating to premises in Newmarket Auckland.   A third franchise agreement was entered into on 18 December 1996 for premises in central Wellington, the franchisee being the second appellant, a company in which the Todds and the fourth appellants Mr and Mrs Caddy were shareholders and directors.   The Todds and the Caddys feature in the proceedings as guarantors.   The premises in respect of each agreement were leased by the franchisee, the lessor in each case being independent of Dymocks.   It is convenient to refer to the franchisees as Bilgola.

  2. The respective rights and obligations of the parties are effectively governed by the franchise agreements.  The relationship between the parties deteriorated from early 1997, their differences coming to a head when on 6 February 1998 Dymocks issued a notice cancelling the three agreements.   This action was treated by Bilgola as a repudiation by Dymocks which it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bilgola Enterprises Ltd v Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NZCA 113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal against the High Court decision that Dymocks Franchise Systems (Dymocks) lawfully cancelled three franchise agreements with Bilgola Enterprises (Bilgola) and was entitled to substantive relief. Bilgola had counterclaimed for damages arising from wrongful repudiation by Dymocks. The Court of Appeal held that Dymocks' cancellation was unlawful and that Bilgola lawfully cancelled the agreements for repudiation by Dymocks. The Court of Appeal quashed the High Court's declaration that Dymocks lawfully terminated the franchise agreements and allowed Bilgola's appeal in part. The Court of Appeal held that clauses 9H and 5P of the franchise agreements continued to operate after termination. The Court of Appeal dismissed Bilgola's appeal against the dismissal of its action, including the costs order made against it. Both parties having been successful in part and unsuccessful in part, there would be no orders as to costs in this Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established