| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA342/2021 [2024] NZCA 453 |
| BETWEEN | RAYMOND IVEAGH JURY |
| AND | THE KING |
| Court: | Cooke, Collins and Osborne JJ |
Counsel: | C W J Stevenson and S J Parry for Appellant |
Judgment: | 18 September 2024 at 10 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
The application for recall is declined.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Collins J)
Mr Jury has applied to have us recall our judgment delivered on 16 July 2024 in which we dismissed his appeal against his conviction for the murder of Mr Rikihana.[1] Through his counsel, Mr Stevenson KC, Mr Jury submits that we failed to give sufficient reasons for rejecting one of his grounds of appeal.
The ground of appeal in issue alleged that a letter written by Mr Maney and his second statement to the police implicating Mr Jury in the murder of Mr Rikihana could not be reconciled with CCTV footage showing the movements of Mr Jury’s car the night Mr Rikihana was murdered.
In our judgment, we said:
(a)While there were inconsistencies between Mr Maney’s letter and his statement to the police,[2] there were also a number of consistencies between those documents. There were also consistencies between Mr Maney’s letter and second statement to the police and other evidence.[3]
(b)The letter written by Mr Maney and his second statement to the police together with the CCTV footage supported the Crown case that Mr Jury had travelled to Mr Maney’s home with Mr Rikihana in the back of his car after Mr Rikihana had been severely beaten.[4]
(c)Contrary to Mr Stevenson’s submissions, Mr Maney’s letter and second statement to the police were not totally inconsistent with the CCTV footage.[5]
[2]At [57]
[3]At [58].
[4]At [59]–[60].
[5]At [59].
The argument put forward to recall our judgment is:
(a)based upon an erroneous reading of our judgment; and
(b)does not pass the test required for recall set out by the Supreme Court in Uhrle v R[6] and Jolley v R.[7] In those judgments, the Court emphasised that the test for recall recognises that the power to recall is an exceptional step that ensures the court is able to respond to circumstances “in order to avoid injustice”.[8]
[8]Uhrle v R, above n 6, at [29], referred to in Jolley v R, above n 7, at [14].
The application for recall is declined.
Solicitors:
Te Tari Ture o te Karauna | Crown Law Office, Wellington for Respondent
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BETWEEN RAYMOND IVEAGH JURY Appellant AND THE KING Responden... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZCA 453
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the earlier judgment adequately addressed the appellant's claim that the evidence of Mr Maney's letter and police statement was inconsistent with CCTV footage, thereby undermining the Crown's case. The court examined whether the inconsistencies were sufficient to warrant a different outcome and whether the appellant's submissions accurately reflected the earlier judgment. The court concluded that the earlier judgment sufficiently addressed the inconsistencies, finding that there were both consistencies and inconsistencies between Mr Maney’s accounts and the CCTV footage, and that these elements collectively supported the Crown's case.
In declining the recall application, the court noted that the appellant's arguments misinterpreted the court's earlier judgment and failed to meet the high threshold for recall as outlined in previous Supreme Court decisions. The court emphasized that the power to recall judgments is reserved for exceptional circumstances to prevent injustice. As the appellant's application did not meet these criteria, the court maintained its earlier decision to dismiss the appeal. The court's decision underscores the importance of accurately interpreting judicial opinions and adhering to established legal standards when seeking to recall a judgment.
The court's decision resulted in the dismissal of the appellant's application for recall, affirming the earlier judgment that rejected his appeal against his conviction for the murder of Mr Rikihana.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Jury's appeal against his conviction for the murder of Mr Rikihana was heard and dismissed by the Court of Appeal on 16 July 2024. Following this, Mr Jury applied to the Court of Appeal to recall the judgment on the basis that the court failed to give sufficient reasons for rejecting one of his grounds of appeal. The application for recall was heard on the papers and was declined on 18 September 2024.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal erred in its judgment by failing to give sufficient reasons for rejecting the ground of appeal concerning the alleged inconsistencies between the evidence of Mr Maney's letter and statement and the CCTV footage.
Held
1. The Court of Appeal did not err in its judgment by failing to give sufficient reasons for rejecting the ground of appeal concerning the alleged inconsistencies between the evidence of Mr Maney's letter and statement and the CCTV footage.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for recall brought by Raymond Iveagh Jury, the appellant, who sought reconsideration of the Court's earlier judgment dismissing his appeal against his conviction for the murder of Mr Rikihana. The appellant argued that the Court had failed to give sufficient reasons for rejecting a specific ground of appeal, which claimed inconsistencies between evidence provided by Mr Maney and CCTV footage. The Court of Appeal found that the appellant's application for recall was based on an erroneous reading of their judgment and did not meet the stringent test for recall as established by the Supreme Court in Uhrle v R and Jolley v R. The Court emphasized that the power to recall is an exceptional step intended to prevent injustice. The Court concluded that the appellant's argument did not satisfy the criteria for recall, as it did not demonstrate that the earlier judgment led to a miscarriage of justice. The Court reaffirmed its earlier findings that there were both inconsistencies and consistencies between Mr Maney's letter and statement and the CCTV footage, and that these inconsistencies did not undermine the overall support for the Crown's case. The Court's decision underscored the high threshold required to successfully challenge a Court of Appeal judgment through an application for recall.