BETWEEN MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL Appellant AND G I T EVANS Respondent

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND BLENHEIM REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WAIHARAKEKE ROHE

CIV-2023-406-10

[2023] NZHC 3849

UNDER the Biosecurity Act 1993

IN THE MATTER

of an application under section 76 of the Act

BETWEEN

MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL

Appellant

AND

G I T EVANS

Respondent

Hearing: 30 August 2023

Appearances:

P A C Maw and M A Mehlhopt for Appellant

Q A M Davies and J S Marshall for Respondent

Judgment:

21 December 2023


JUDGMENT OF McQUEEN J


Table of Contents

Para Nos

Introduction  [1]

The BSA  [8]

Regional pest management plans  [12]
Implementation of regional pest management plans  [14]
Applications to the Environment Court  [15]

The 2015 NPD  [24]

The requirements for a plan’s objectives  [28]
Requirements for programme descriptions  [32]
Requirements for benefit and cost analysis  [34]

Factual background  [39]

The early years  [40]

The 2000s onwards  [42]

MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL v G I T EVANS [2023] NZHC 3849 [21 December 2023]

Commencement of proceedings in the Environment Court  [54]

The Environment Court decision  [58]

The issues  [59]
Jurisdictional matters  [60]
Substantive matters  [66]
Relief  [69]

Approach to appeal  [70]

Grounds of the Council’s appeal  [74]

The nature of the Environment Court’s findings and this Court’s

jurisdiction  [76]

First alleged error of law  [84]

The Council’s submissions  [85]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [87]
Discussion  [89]
Conclusion  [92]

Second alleged error of law  [93]

The Council’s submissions  [94]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [100]
Discussion  [105]

Conclusion  [115]

Third alleged error of law  [116]

The Council’s submissions  [117]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [119]

Discussion and conclusion  [120]

Fifth alleged error of law  [121]

The Council’s submissions  [122]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [126]

Is a site-led programme where containment or reduction remain as the
identified intermediate objective permitted under the 2015 NPD?              [129]
Risk of removal as opposed to protection of values  [142]
Conclusion  [145]

Sixth alleged error of law  [146]

The Council’s submissions  [147]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [150]
Discussion  [152]
Conclusion  [156]

Seventh alleged error of law  [157]

The Council’s submissions  [158]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [161]
Discussion and conclusion  [163]

Fourth alleged error (as to relief)  [166]

The Council’s submissions  [167]
Mr Evans’ submissions  [170]
Discussion  [173]
Conclusion  [176]

Summary of conclusions  [177]

Result  [179]

Costs  [181]

Introduction

[1]    The Marlborough District Council (the Council) appeals against an interim decision of the Environment Court dated 17 March 2023 regarding an application by Mr Geoffrey Evans under s 76 of the Biosecurity Act 1993 (the BSA).1

[2]    Mr Evan’s application under s 76 sought amendments to the Marlborough Regional Pest Management Plan 2018 (the 2018 RPMP), in respect of pest conifers (contorta pine/wilding pines) originally planted by the Marlborough Catchment Board as early as 1959, on land adjacent to ‘Stronvar Station’, a family-owned farm for which Mr Evans is a trustee (Stronvar).

[3]    Pest conifers create issues for farmland and particularly for areas rich in native biodiversity. They spread aggressively, reduce available grazing land and limit future land use. They grow densely, and are therefore destructive for native plants, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BETWEEN MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL Appellant AND G I T EVA... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 3849
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Marlborough District Council appeals an interim decision of the Environment Court regarding an application by Mr Geoffrey Evans under s 76 of the Biosecurity Act 1993. The Environment Court granted relief in the form of amendments to the Marlborough Regional Pest Management Plan 2018 in respect of pest conifers on land adjacent to ‘Stronvar Station’, a family-owned farm for which Mr Evans is a trustee. The Council submits that the Environment Court made errors of law which materially affected its findings. It argues that the Environment Court lacked jurisdiction to direct the inclusion of a site-led programme in the 2018 RPMP, and that it misapplied the Biosecurity Act 1993 and the National Policy Direction for Pest Management 2015. The Council says that this is a test case of the jurisdictional issues that arise on an application to the Environment Court under the Biosecurity Act 1993. Mr Evans opposes the Council’s appeal and says that the Environment Court made no errors of law. He also advances what is effectively a cross-appeal on a single point, saying that the Environment Court erred in not finding that the Council is an ‘exacerbator’ under the National Policy Direction for Pest Management 2015. I consider that both the Council’s appeal and Mr Evans’ cross appeal should be dismissed. The Environment Court properly limited its conclusions to the proposed amendments to the 2018 RPMP concerning pest conifers. There is no basis on which to conclude that the Environment Court made an error of law. I conclude that the Environment Court did not grant relief beyond its jurisdiction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established