NOTE: PUBLICATION OF NAME, ADDRESS, OCCUPATION OR
IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF COMPLAINANT/PERSON UNDER THE
AGE OF 18 YEARS WHO APPEARED AS A WITNESS PROHIBITED BY
SS 203 AND 204 OF THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE ACT 2011.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA
CA670/2023
[2024] NZCA 454
BETWEEN J (CA670/2023) Appellant AND THE KING Respondent
| Hearing: | 13 May 2024 |
| Court: | French, Campbell and Cull JJ |
| Counsel: | K R Pascoe for Appellant |
| M J R Blaschke for Respondent |
J was sentenced in the District Court to seven years and six months’
imprisonment by Judge Greig,[1] after he was convicted by a jury of three charges of
doing an indecent act on a child under 12, one of which was a representative charge.[2]
[1] R v [J] [2023] NZDC 22952 [Sentencing decision]. We have anonymised the appellant’s name to
[2] Crimes Act 1961, s 132(3); maximum penalty 10 years’ imprisonment.
J appeals this sentence on two grounds:
(a) the starting point was based on exaggerated aggravating factors— regarding the duration, frequency and nature of the offending—that had
no evidential basis; and
(b) the starting point was excessive and outside the available range.
Background to the offending
The complainant is J’s biological daughter. J was charged with offending
against the complainant when she was five to seven years old, from the start of 2017
to the end of 2019, a period of three years.
J’s offending consisted of using the complainant to masturbate himself. He
would put his penis between the complainant’s legs and thrust back and forth or, on
some occasions, move the complainant back and forth against him. He ejaculated on
at least one occasion. There were two instances of this on which J was found guilty.
The above is undisputed.
There were additional undisputed instances of offending, including at least one
incident of J rubbing the complainant’s vagina while she was in the shower or bath
with him, and at least one incident where he had the complainant masturbate him with
her hand (although this was not a discrete charge).[3] In addition, he showed the
complainant pornography on multiple occasions, often before sexually offending
against her.
[3] Sentencing decision, above n 1, at [3].
The duration and frequency of the offending is a disputed issue on appeal.
There are further aspects of the offending that are contested, including whether the
complainant was clothed during the offending.
The sentencing decision
Prior to the first scheduled date for sentencing, the Crown and defence had
submitted starting points of three and a half to four years’ imprisonment and
three years’ imprisonment respectively. Defence counsel also requested time to obtain
a psychologist’s report on the basis that J had been sexually abused himself as a child.
The Judge issued a minute adjourning the sentencing to allow for the completion of a
s 27 report but also to address the likely sentence he was minded to impose.[4] The
Judge signalled this as follows:[5]
[T]he sentence I had in mind today…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BETWEEN J (CA670/2023) Appellant AND THE KING Respondent and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZCA 454
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court reviewed the contested factual findings and concluded that not all of the judge’s findings were supported by the evidence. The judge’s findings regarding the duration, frequency, and nature of the offending were exaggerated. The court found that the offending occurred over a one-year period rather than a two-year period and did not happen on the complainant’s seventh birthday. The court also found that the comparison of the offending to rape was excessive. The court determined that the starting point of eight and a half years’ imprisonment was manifestly excessive. In the absence of appellate tariff guidance, the court adopted a starting point of five years’ imprisonment, reduced by 12 per cent for the appellant’s background and remorse, resulting in a sentence of four years and five months’ imprisonment.
Background
Background to the litigation
J was sentenced in the District Court by Judge Greig. J appealed the sentence to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the starting point was based on exaggerated aggravating factors and was excessive. The appeal was heard by French, Campbell, and Cull JJ on 13 May 2024. K R Pascoe appeared for the appellant, and M J R Blaschke appeared for the respondent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the sentencing judge err in basing the starting point on exaggerated aggravating factors that were not supported by the evidence?
2. Was the starting point excessive and outside the available range for this type of offending?
Held
1. The Court found that the sentencing judge erred in basing the starting point on exaggerated aggravating factors that were not supported by the evidence.
2. The Court concluded that the starting point of eight years and six months’ imprisonment was excessive and outside the available range for this type of offending. The sentence was manifestly excessive.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court reviewed the factual findings made by the sentencing judge regarding the duration, frequency, and nature of the offending. The Court found that the judge's findings on the duration and frequency of the offending were exaggerated and not supported by the evidence. The judge's finding that the offending occurred over a two-year period, including on the complainant's seventh birthday, was incorrect as the complainant did not reside with the appellant after the tenancy ended on 1 January 2019. The Court also found that the judge's comparison of the offending to rape was excessive. The judge had compared the present offending to the case of Nichol, where the defendant had committed the most serious of five instances of offending against three children. However, the Court found that the offending in the present case, while serious, was not as serious as the offending in Nichol nor closely comparable on the facts.
The Court then considered the range of starting points for sentencing on this charge. The Court found that the starting point of eight years and six months’ imprisonment was excessive in light of the current range of starting points for this type of offending. The Court adopted a starting point of five years’ imprisonment, which balanced the seriousness of the offending with the need for consistency in sentencing. The Court applied a 12 per cent reduction to the starting point for the appellant’s background and remorse, resulting in an end sentence of four years and five months’ imprisonment. The Court allowed the appeal against sentence and substituted the sentence of seven years and six months’ imprisonment with a sentence of four years and five months’ imprisonment.