| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA483/2024 |
| BETWEEN | BETTY LEUINA SIO |
| AND | THE KING |
| Court: | Palmer, Grice and Gault JJ |
Counsel: | N P Chisnall KC for Applicant |
Judgment: | 5 November 2024 at 10 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
The application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Palmer J)
On 29 March 2023, Ms Betty Sio was found guilty, by Judge Y Yelavich in the District Court at Manukau, of two charges of dishonestly using a document.[1] On 16 August 2023, the Judge declined Ms Sio’s application to discharge her without conviction, and instead convicted her and imposed a fine of $3000.[2] On 1 July 2024, in the High Court at Auckland, Brewer J dismissed Ms Sio’s appeal against conviction.[3] Ms Sio applies for leave to bring a second appeal against conviction.
What happened?
[1]Serious Fraud Office v Sio [2022] NZDC 774 [District Court verdicts judgment] at [184].
[2]R v Sio [2023] NZDC 17631 [District Court sentencing judgment] at [56] and [64].
[3]Sio v R [2024] NZHC 1756 [High Court judgment] at [81]–[82].
Ms Sio was the Chief Executive Officer of a charitable organisation, the Pacific Island Safety & Prevention Project Incorporated (Project). Her friend Ms Tapualii Uitime was the Operations Manager. Ms Uitime pleaded guilty to representative dishonesty charges, including in relation to forging four invoices from fictitious suppliers, and dishonest use of four cheques.[4] Ms Sio and Ms Uitime both signed the four fictitious cheques. Ms Sio cashed two cheques and Ms Uitime cashed the other two. Around three hours after cashing the cheques, Ms Sio made a $3,000 cash deposit to her credit card account. The Crown alleged that, in succeeding days, Ms Sio went to the Sky City casino with Ms Uitime and lost money and made further cash deposits into her credit card and bank accounts.
[4]R v Uitime [2020] NZDC 20663.
The issue at Ms Sio’s trial was whether the prosecution could prove beyond reasonable doubt that Ms Sio knew the cheques she cashed were fraudulent.[5] In a careful and comprehensive 184 paragraph judgment, Judge Yelavich concluded, on the basis of specified circumstantial evidence, that Ms Sio knew, when she cashed the cheques “that the cash was not for legitimate suppliers or for the good faith remuneration of herself or Project employees”.[6]
[5]District Court verdicts judgment, above n 1, at [19].
[6]At [179].
In sentencing Ms Sio, the District Court Judge declined her application for a discharge without conviction.[7] She held that, taking into account the nature of the offending and the aggravating and mitigating factors, the overall gravity of the offending was moderate.[8] She considered it was speculative whether Ms Sio would be barred from social work registration or her future travel impacted; the impact on her employment, reputation, and mental health was a direct consequence of the offending…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BETTY LEUINA SIO AND THE KING and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZCA 560
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the proposed grounds for the second appeal involved a matter of general or public importance or if a miscarriage of justice might have occurred. The court found that neither threshold for granting leave to appeal was met. It concluded that the District and High Court Judges had carefully and properly assessed the text messages and expert evidence, and that any error did not amount to a miscarriage of justice. The court also found no error in the District Court's refusal to discharge Ms Sio without conviction. Consequently, the application for leave to bring a second appeal was declined.
The court's reasoning focused on the high thresholds for granting leave to appeal, emphasizing that not every error constitutes a miscarriage of justice. The court found that the proposed grounds for the second appeal did not rise to the level of a matter of general principle or importance. As such, the application was declined, and Ms Sio's conviction and sentence stand affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Ms Sio was initially tried and convicted in the District Court at Manukau on 29 March 2023. She subsequently applied for a discharge without conviction, which was declined by the same court on 16 August 2023. Following her conviction, Ms Sio appealed to the High Court at Auckland, which dismissed her appeal on 1 July 2024. Now, Ms Sio applies for leave to bring a second appeal against her conviction to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the District Court Judge err in her assessment of the text messages exchanged between Ms Sio and Ms Uitime?
2. Did the District Court Judge mischaracterise the evidence provided by the chartered accountant regarding Ms Uitime's need for the funds from the cheques Ms Sio cashed?
3. Did the High Court Judge err in his approach to section 232(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011?
4. Was there a miscarriage of justice in declining the application for a discharge without conviction?
Held
1. The Court held that the District Court Judge did not err in her assessment of the text messages exchanged between Ms Sio and Ms Uitime.
2. The Court held that the District Court Judge did not mischaracterise the evidence provided by the chartered accountant regarding Ms Uitime's need for the funds from the cheques Ms Sio cashed.
3. The Court held that the High Court Judge did not err in his approach to section 232(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011.
4. The Court held that there was no miscarriage of justice in declining the application for a discharge without conviction.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal began by noting the high thresholds for granting leave to appeal against a determination of a first appeal, which must involve a matter of general or public importance or a miscarriage of justice. The Court assessed the proposed grounds of appeal against these thresholds. Regarding the assessment of the text messages, the Court found that both the District and High Court Judges had carefully and reasonably treated the evidence. The text messages were relevant and did not require special caution, as they provided context for Ms Sio's knowledge at the time she cashed the cheques. As for the expert evidence, the Court held that it was open to the District Court Judge not to accept the speculative hypothesis presented by the chartered accountant. The High Court Judge's summary description of the nature of the appeal, read in context, did not lead the Court into error, as the threshold for a miscarriage of justice is high and not every error amounts to such a miscarriage. Finally, the Court found that there was no error in the District and High Court Judges' approach to the discharge without conviction, as the consequences of the conviction were proportionate to the gravity of the offending. Therefore, the application for leave to bring a second appeal was declined.