Berridge v Donovan HC Napier CIV 2009-441-344

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2009-441-344

UNDER  the Family Protection Act 1955

IN THE MATTER OF     the estate of Michael Evanghelos Claudatos

BETWEEN  J M BERRIDGE Plaintiff

ANDT P DONOVAN & T M CLAUDATOS Defendants

Judicial Settlement Conference:        17 March 2010

Judgment on Costs:  18 March 2010 at 4.00 pm

JUDGMENT AS TO COSTS OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment was delivered by Associate Judge Gendall on 18March 2010 at 4.00 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Solicitors:           Elvidge & Partners, Solicitors, PO Box 609, Napier

Willis Toomey Robinson, Lawyers, Private Bag 6018, Napier

J M BERRIDGE V T P DONOVAN & T M CLAUDATOS HC NAP CIV-2009-441-344  18 March 2010

[1]      At the Judicial Settlement Conference scheduled for this proceeding on 17

March 2010 settlement of the plaintiff’s claim against the defendants was reached and Consent Orders were made.

[2]      That settlement resolved all matters between the plaintiff and the defendants save the question of costs.

[3]      The  plaintiff  sought  payment  of  her  entire  costs  and  disbursements  in bringing this proceeding from the estate represented by the defendant trustees.  The defendants opposed an award of costs and disbursements to her.

[4]      At the settlement conference it was agreed that costs should be reserved and that I would decide the issue based upon oral submissions made to me at the time by counsel for the parties.

[5]      Those submissions were made and I now provide my judgment on the costs issue.

[6]      This proceeding involved a claim by the plaintiff, a daughter of the deceased Mr Michael Evanghelos Claudatos (“the deceased”) seeking some provision from his estate under the Family Protection Act 1955.  The claim was notionally opposed by the defendants as executors of the estate and Trustees of the Pelagos Trust and the Pelagos Two Trust.

[7]      Under the will of the deceased, his entire estate was effectively left to two trusts established in his lifetime the Pelagos Trust and the Pelagos Two Trust.  His will made no specific provision for either of his two children, first, his daughter the plaintiff and secondly, his son Thomas Michael Claudatos (“Thomas”), although they are both discretionary beneficiaries under the two Pelagos Trusts.

[8]      The plaintiff brought this present proceeding under the Family Protection Act

1955 upon the basis that her late father the deceased had breached his moral duty as testator to provide for her as his daughter.

[9]      The settlement reached in this proceeding, agreed to by the defendants both as executors of the estate and trustees of the Pelagos Trust and Pelagos Two Trust, provided for the deceased’s will to be modified so that his residuary estate was effectively divided equally between the plaintiff and Thomas in equal shares as his children.   The plaintiff, was to receive her one-half share of the residuary estate immediately but Thomas’s one-half share was to be held in trust until he attained the age of 30 years.

[10]     That said, the plaintiff’s claim in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Berridge v Donovan HC Napier CIV 2009-441-344 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 800
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiff, J M Berridge, sought provision from the estate of her deceased father, Michael Evanghelos Claudatos, under the Family Protection Act 1955. The defendants, T P Donovan and T M Claudatos, were the executors of the deceased's estate and trustees of two trusts established by him. The estate was left to the two trusts, with no specific provision for the plaintiff or her brother, Thomas Michael Claudatos. Berridge argued that her father had breached his moral duty to provide for her as his daughter. The parties reached a settlement where the deceased's will was modified to divide his residuary estate equally between Berridge and Thomas. The settlement provided for Berridge to receive her half share immediately, while Thomas's share was to be held in trust until he turned 30.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff's costs and disbursements in pursuing her claim should be paid from the estate of the deceased. Historically, in Family Protection proceedings, the estate was ordered to pay the costs of all parties, but recent cases suggested that costs should follow the event, in line with general costs principles. The court also considered the size of the estate and the plaintiff's success in modifying the will. The defendants opposed the plaintiff's claim for costs, arguing that it would unfairly impact Thomas, who had not participated in the proceedings.

The court found that, given the size of the estate and the plaintiff's success in modifying the will, it was appropriate to order that the plaintiff's costs and disbursements be paid from the estate. The court considered it fair for Thomas to bear half of the plaintiff's costs, amounting to approximately $7,500, from his share of the estate. This decision aligns with the traditional practice in Family Protection proceedings where the estate pays the costs of all parties. The court concluded that ordering the estate to pay the plaintiff's costs was a fair outcome given the circumstances of the case. The final order was that the plaintiff's reasonable costs and disbursements, estimated at around $15,000, would be met by the defendants and paid from the deceased's estate before any distribution to the residuary beneficiaries.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established