Bell v Thomson

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-454-000178 [2014] NZHC 724

IN THE MATTER OF       the Christine Bell Family Trust

BETWEEN  CHRISTINE BELL Plaintiff

ANDPETER BRYCE THOMSON First Defendant

ANDRICARDO WAYNE SCHWAMM Second Defendant

(Determined on the papers) Appearances:  G A Paine for Plaintiff

P B Thomson (First Defendant) in person
J Tannahill for Second Defendant

Judgment:                9 April 2014

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

The litigation

[1]      This litigation concerns a family trust.

[2]      The plaintiff, Ms Bell, settled the trust and is a beneficiary of the trust.

[3]      The first defendant is a solicitor appointed as trustee of the trust.  The second defendant is the other trustee.

[4]      Difficulties arose with the result that the trustees were unable to effectively administer the trust and to wind it up as was appropriately called for.

BELL v THOMSON [2014] NZHC 724 [9 April 2014]

[5]      Ms Bell issued this proceeding to have the second defendant removed as a trustee.

[6]      As a result of a settlement conference in November 2012 a Consent Order was made which appeared to resolve issues in the litigation.  There then arose some taxation issues which for a time precluded implementation of the settlement.

[7]      The parties have now  agreed  the terms of what will be a full and  final resolution.

[8]      The Court is satisfied that the orders to which Ms Bell and Mr Schwamm consent are an appropriate way of proceeding with the winding up of the trust.

[9]      Mr Thomson as the second trustee has confirmed that he abides the Court’s orders in relation to the agreement reached between Ms Bell and Mr Schwamm.  The other potential beneficiaries (adult children and grandchildren) had previously consented to any resolution which was acceptable to Ms Bell (their mother).

Orders

[10]     I order:

(a)      The plaintiff and the first defendant will cause to be sent promptly to the Inland Revenue Department a request for the remission of all or some of the penalties and interest imposed upon the Christine Bell Family Trust (“the Trust”) by the Department;

(b)In the event the request to the Department results in a remission, the remitted funds will fall to be included within the assets of the Trust and will be taken into account in the final distribution to be effected in terms of the following orders;

(c)      The Trust is to be wound up and the trustees making the following payments to the following persons:

(i)By way of payment of professional fees and expenses, and in full and final settlement of all claims the first defendant may have in  relation  to  the  Christine Bell  Family Trust,  a sum equivalent to 33.34 percent of the assets of the Trust, available for final distribution (“the available fund”), upon presentation of a GST invoice by the first defendant;

(ii)By way of final distribution to the plaintiff and to the second defendant the remaining two-thirds of the trust funds to be allocated as to 44.44 percent of the available funds to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v Thomson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 724
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bell v Thomson involved the Christine Bell Family Trust, with Christine Bell as the plaintiff and beneficiary, and Peter Bryce Thomson and Ricardo Wayne Schwamm as trustees. The litigation arose due to difficulties in effectively administering and winding up the trust. Bell sought to remove Schwamm as a trustee, and after a settlement conference, a Consent Order was made to resolve the issues. However, taxation issues temporarily halted implementation. Eventually, the parties agreed on a full and final resolution, which the Court approved. The Court ordered that the Trust be wound up, with the trustees making specified payments to the beneficiaries and the plaintiff. The request for remission of penalties and interest imposed by the Inland Revenue Department on the Trust was also approved, with any remitted funds to be included in the Trust's assets.

The central legal issue in this case was whether the proposed settlement and winding up of the trust was appropriate and fair to all parties involved. The Court needed to ensure that the proposed distribution of assets complied with the terms of the trust and was in the best interest of the beneficiaries. Additionally, the Court had to consider whether the proposed removal of Schwamm as a trustee was justified and whether the agreed-upon distribution of assets was equitable. The Court also needed to confirm whether the parties had appropriately resolved the taxation issues that had previously stalled the implementation of the settlement.

In reaching its decision, the Court considered the terms of the settlement agreement and the consent of all relevant parties, including the other beneficiaries who had previously consented to any resolution acceptable to Bell. The Court was satisfied that the proposed orders were an appropriate way of proceeding with the winding up of the trust and that the distribution of assets was fair and in accordance with the terms of the trust. The Court also confirmed that Thomson, as the second trustee, would abide by the Court's orders in relation to the agreement reached between Bell and Schwamm. The Court approved the orders for winding up the Trust and making payments to the beneficiaries and trustees as per the agreement.

The final orders of the Court included the remission of penalties and interest imposed on the Trust by the Inland Revenue Department, with any remitted funds to be included in the Trust's assets. The Trust was to be wound up, and the trustees were to make specified payments to the beneficiaries and the plaintiff. The primary relief sought by Bell, which was the removal of Schwamm as a trustee, was dismissed, as the parties had reached a full and final resolution. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established