IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY
CIV-2012-454-000178 [2014] NZHC 2724
IN THE MATTER OF the Christine Bell Family Trust BETWEEN
CHRISTINE BELL Plaintiff
AND
PETER BRYCE THOMSON First Defendant
RICARDO WAYNE SCHWAMM Second Defendant
Judgment: 3 November 2014
JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J
BELL v THOMSON [2014] NZHC 2724 [3 November 2014]
[1] On 9 April 2014 I issued a judgment in this proceeding with the intention that this would resolve all matters between the parties in this long-running matter. This followed judicial settlement conferences and many subsequent negotiations following which agreement was reached between the parties.
[2] One issue has arisen between the parties however on which there appears to be some disagreement. This concerned a sum of $9000 being remitted tax arrears received by the Trust from the Inland Revenue Department and how that amount was to be finally distributed.
[3] On all of these matters Associate Judge Osborne in his minute in this proceeding dated 12 February 2014 at paragraph [8] stated:
[8] The solicitors for the plaintiff and the second defendant are secondly to co-operate to make a single approach to the Inland Revenue Department in relation to a request for consideration of remission of some or all of the approximately $9000 I have referred to. The draft of their letter to the Inland Revenue Department is to be provided to Mr Thomson by way of information but it is anticipated that he will support the sending of the letter in the form agreed by Messrs Paine and Tannahill. Any sum ultimately recovered from the Inland Revenue Department by way of remission is again to be distributed to the plaintiff [Ms Bell] and the second defendant [Mr Schwamm] in accordance with the two thirds/one third provision under the consent order.
[4] That minute of Associate Judge Osborne appears to differ from the orders made in my judgment given in this proceeding dated 9 April 2014 in which, at paragraph [10](b) and 10(c) I made the following orders:
[10] …
(b) In the event the request to the Department results in a remission, the remitted funds will fall to be included within the assets of the Trust and will be taken into account in the final distribution to be effected in terms of the following orders;
(c) The Trust is to be wound up and the trustees making the following payments to the following persons:
(i) By way of payment of professional fees and expenses, and in full and final settlement of all claims the first defendant may have in relation to the Christine Bell Family Trust, a sum equivalent to
33.34 percent of the assets of the Trust, available for
final distribution (“the available fund”), upon
presentation of a GST invoice by the first defendant;
(ii) By way of final distribution to the plaintiff and to the second defendant the remaining two-thirds of the trust funds to be allocated as to 44.44 percent of the available funds to the first defendant and 22.22…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v Thomson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 2724
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was the interpretation of the orders made in the earlier judgment and how the remitted tax arrears should be distributed among the parties. The court needed to determine whether the remitted funds should be included in the assets of the Trust and subject to the final distribution as outlined in the earlier orders, or whether the remitted funds should be distributed solely between the plaintiff and the second defendant. The court also had to consider the submissions of the parties and the context of the longstanding dispute in reaching its decision.
In reaching its decision, the court considered the terms of the earlier orders, which stated that any remission received from the Inland Revenue Department was to be included within the assets of the Trust and taken into account in the final distribution. The court also took into account the submissions of the parties and the context of the long-standing dispute. The court concluded that the just and reasonable resolution of the matter required the remitted funds to be distributed such that the first defendant received a portion towards his professional fees and expenses, and the balance was divided between the plaintiff and the second defendant. This resolution would finally bring the matter to a conclusion, despite the first defendant possibly being out of pocket in terms of certain of his legal fees and expenses.
The court made an order that the remitted tax arrears, along with any interest earned, were to be divided and paid as follows: (a) $1500 (plus interest thereon if any) to the first defendant; and (b) $7500 (plus interest thereon if any) to the plaintiff and the second defendant in the same shares as provided for in the earlier judgment. This order resolved the outstanding issues and brought the matter to a final conclusion.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi