Beach Arena Limited v Waikoro Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA486/2021
 [2022] NZCA 454

BETWEEN

BEACH ARENA LIMITED
Appellant

AND

WAIKORO LIMITED
First Respondent

SAREN LOO
Second Respondent

CON YUEN LU
Third Respondent

WEI YUEN LOO
Fourth Respondent

GEN YUEN LOO
Fifth Respondent

Hearing:

28 March 2022 (further submissions 13 April 2022)

Court:

Gilbert, Simon France and Dunningham JJ

Counsel:

D G Collecutt for Appellant
MJW Lenihan for First Respondent
No appearance for Second to Fifth Respondents

Judgment:

28 September 2022 at 9.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay costs to the first respondent for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

  1. In response to the first respondent’s claim for monies due under a lease signed in December 2012, the appellant filed a statement of defence and counterclaim in August 2020 partly relying on alleged misrepresentations inducing the lease.  The High Court struck out parts of the statement of defence and counterclaim, as amended in November 2020, on the basis the claims were barred by the Limitation Act 2010.[1]  The appellant now appeals against part of that judgment.

Background  

  1. On 20 December 2012, Beach Arena Ltd (Beach), as lessee, entered into a deed of lease with Waikoro Ltd (Waikoro), as lessor, in respect of the old Station Hotel (renamed “Arena”) situated on Beach Road, Auckland City and two adjacent development lots, one having frontage onto Beach Road and the other onto Anzac Avenue.  At the time the lease was entered into, the hotel was in poor condition and was being used as student accommodation.  The lease was for a term of 10 years at an annual rental of $600,000 (plus GST) and outgoings.  The lease contained a call option exercisable by Beach by 20 December 2015 in respect of all three properties at a price of $12.6 million (plus GST) and a put option exercisable by Waikoro at the same price at the end of the call option period.  Separate options in respect of the development lots or the hotel were also included.

  2. The principals of Beach and Waikoro, respectively Mr Neville Mahon and Mr Timothy Edney, have known each other for some 30 years.  Unfortunately, they fell out as a result of difficulties they encountered with this investment.

  3. Soon after Beach took possession, Mr Mahon discovered that the hotel was in much worse condition than he first thought and that it required significant remediation works.  Mr Mahon also soon became aware that the insurance premium had increased markedly to almost $145,000.  This was 12 times higher than the amount advised by Mr Edney in response to Mr Mahon’s inquiry in May 2011, approximately 19 months before the lease was signed. 

  4. Beach needed to borrow to pay the insurance and maintenance costs.  Funding was provided by Mr Edney’s interests, through Waimauri Ltd (Waimauri).…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beach Arena Limited v Waikoro Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZCA 454
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Beach Arena Limited, the appellant, filed a counterclaim against Waikoro Limited, the first respondent, in a proceeding brought by Waikoro to recover monies due under a lease. The counterclaim was based on alleged misrepresentations made by Waikoro prior to the execution of the lease. The High Court struck out parts of the counterclaim as barred by the Limitation Act 2010. Beach now appeals against that part of the judgment. The appeal was dismissed.

The court considered the basis for the counterclaim, which was that Beach was induced to enter into the lease by misrepresentations or non-disclosures by Waikoro. Beach contended that it only became aware of the misrepresentations during the trial of a related proceeding in March 2020, and that this was within the limitation period under section 14 of the Limitation Act. However, the court found that Beach had knowledge of sufficient facts to pursue its misrepresentation claim more than six years before the counterclaim was filed. It knew of the increased insurance premium soon after the lease was signed, and it borrowed money from Waikoro's interests to fund it. The court held that the misrepresentation claim was statute-barred and could not be saved by amendment.

The court also considered whether relief could be granted under section 50 of the Limitation Act. However, Beach had not made an application for relief under that section before the strike-out application was ruled on. The court found that the High Court did not err in striking out the relevant parts of the counterclaim.

Background

Background to the litigation

Beach Arena Limited (Beach) entered into a lease with Waikoro Limited (Waikoro) in December 2012 for the old Station Hotel (renamed "Arena") in Auckland City and two adjacent development lots. The lease was for a term of 10 years at an annual rental of $600,000 (plus GST) and outgoings. The lease included a call option exercisable by Beach by 20 December 2015 and a put option exercisable by Waikoro at the end of the call option period. Beach took possession of the hotel, which was in poor condition and used as student accommodation. Shortly after, Beach discovered significant remediation works were required, and the insurance premium had increased to almost $145,000, which was 12 times higher than previously advised by Waikoro. Beach borrowed money to cover the increased insurance and maintenance costs from Waimauri Ltd, an entity associated with Waikoro's principal, Timothy Edney. The debt was not repaid on the due date. Beach carried out various works, including upgrading the rooms and facilities. In September 2014, the parties agreed to market the property for sale, which was eventually sold in 2016. In December 2019, Waikoro issued proceedings against Beach and others for amounts said to be due under the lease, totalling $2,263,339. Beach filed a statement of defence and counterclaim in August 2020, partly relying on alleged misrepresentations inducing the lease.

The High Court struck out parts of Beach's statement of defence and counterclaim on the basis the claims were barred by the Limitation Act 2010. Beach appealed against part of that judgment. The appeal was heard on 28 March 2022, with further submissions made on 13 April 2022. The Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 28 September 2022, dismissing the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the counterclaim was brought within time under section 14 of the Limitation Act 2010.
2. Whether relief could be granted under section 50 of the Limitation Act 2010.

Held
1. The court held that the counterclaim was brought outside the limitation period under section 14 of the Limitation Act 2010. Specifically, the court found that the appellant had knowledge of all facts necessary to bring the claim more than six years before filing the counterclaim. As such, the claim was time-barred.
2. The court also held that relief could not be granted under section 50 of the Limitation Act 2010. The court found that no application for relief under section 50(2) was made before the court decided that a defence to the ancillary claim had been established. Therefore, the court struck out the relevant parts of the defence and counterclaim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal brought by Beach Arena Limited against the decision of the High Court to strike out parts of their statement of defence and counterclaim. The High Court had found that the claims were barred by the Limitation Act 2010. In considering whether the counterclaim was brought within time under section 14 of the Limitation Act, the Court of Appeal found that Beach had knowledge of all facts necessary to bring the claim more than six years before filing the counterclaim. This included knowledge of the increased insurance premium and the poor condition of the property. As such, the claim was time-barred.

The Court of Appeal also considered whether relief could be granted under section 50 of the Limitation Act. The court found that no application for relief under section 50(2) was made before the court decided that a defence to the ancillary claim had been established. The Court of Appeal held that the failure to make an application under section 50(2) was not a mere procedural irregularity, but a statutory requirement. Therefore, the court struck out the relevant parts of the defence and counterclaim.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that claims brought outside the limitation period under section 14 of the Limitation Act 2010 cannot be saved by an application for relief under section 50 of the Limitation Act 2010 if the application is not made before the court decides that a defence to the ancillary claim has been established. This decision follows established principles of limitation periods and the requirements of section 50 of the Limitation Act 2010. The Court of Appeal did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority on this point.