Barron v Hutton HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-7270

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-404-7270

BETWEEN  SUSAN PATRICIA BARRON First Plaintiff

ANDTHE OFFICIAL ASSIGNEE ON BEHALF OF DENNIS SCOTT BARRON

Second Plaintiff

ANDANTHONY MAURICE HUTTON First Defendant

ANDGRAEME TREVOR STEPHENS AND MARY STEPHENS

Second Defendants

ANDIAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Third Defendant

ANDFORENSIC & INDUSTRIAL SCIENCE LIMITED

Fourth Defendant

ANDNICHOLAS GARTH POWELL Fifth Defendant

Hearing:         9 June 2011

Counsel:         NW Woods for First and Second Plaintiffs to oppose

No appearance for First and Second Defendants
PM Smith for Third Defendant in support
B Rooney for the Fourth and Fifth Defendants in support

Judgment:      13 September 2011 at 4:00 PM

JUDGMENT OF TOOGOOD J

This judgment was delivered by me on 13 September 2011 at 4:00 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

BARRON V HUTTON & ORS HC AK CIV-2010-404-7270 13 September 2011

Table of Contents  Paragraph

Number Introduction        [1] The disputed issues of fact and law   [8] The applications under consideration  [10] The second plaintiff  [13] Security for costs  [14]

Decision as to security for costs  [21] Strike out application  [24] Paragraph 18(g)  [26] Paragraph 18(h)      [33]

Fourth cause of action  [35]

Fifth cause of action  [41]

Introduction

[1]      In 2002 and 2003, Susan Barron and her now-estranged husband Dennis

Barron built a new brick and tile house at 73 Waimahia Avenue, Weymouth.   On

6 December 2006, the first defendant, Mr Hutton, carried out carpet cleaning and insect spraying on the property.   Mr Hutton was then an employee of Auckland Carpet Steam „N‟ Dry Cleaning Limited (“ACSD”), a company now in liquidation. It is alleged that Mr Hutton undertook the spraying of insecticide in the property negligently, either in terms of the method of application or as to the contents of the spray, or both.

[2]      The nature of the contaminants in the spray is a matter of serious dispute between scientific witnesses engaged by the parties, but the plaintiffs say that people have suffered ill health, and that the attempts by, or on behalf of, the defendants to remedy the obvious damage to the property have been inadequate and/or carried out negligently, and that monetary compensation offered is inadequate to compensate them for their loss.  A scientific witness engaged by Mrs Barron, Mr Molony, has

gone so far as to say that the property is not “fit for human habitation”1  and “is

incapable of remediation without demolition.”2

[3]      The second defendants were the directors and shareholders of ACSD.  It is alleged they controlled, managed and operated the company‟s  carpet cleaning and pest control business, and it is said that Mr Stephens “personally guaranteed” the company‟s cleaning activities.

[4]      The  third  defendant,  IAG  New  Zealand  Limited  (“IAG”)  is  sued  in  the capacity of underwriter of a public liability policy under which, it is alleged, ACSD was insured in respect of the events giving rise to the plaintiffs‟ claims.  IAG is also sued in the capacity of insurer of Mr and Mrs Barron under a homeowner insurance

policy and a home contents insurance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barron v Hutton HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-7270 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Susan Barron and her now-estranged husband Dennis Barron built a new house in 2002 and 2003. Anthony Maurice Hutton, an employee of Auckland Carpet Steam „N‟ Dry Cleaning Limited (ACSD), carried out carpet cleaning and insecticide spraying at the property on 6 December 2006. The plaintiffs claim that Mr Hutton negligently carried out the spraying, and that the property has been contaminated with harmful substances as a result. The plaintiffs further claim that attempts to remedy the damage have been inadequate and negligent, and that the monetary compensation offered is insufficient to compensate for their losses. The defendants deny the allegations and dispute the extent of the contamination and the remediation required. The third defendant, IAG New Zealand Limited, is sued in its capacity as the underwriter of a public liability policy for ACSD, as well as the insurer of the plaintiffs under a homeowners and home contents insurance policy. The fourth and fifth defendants are scientific consultants engaged by IAG to carry out tests and advise on remedial steps for the alleged damage. The third defendant applied to strike out certain parts of the plaintiffs' claim, including the reduced expectancy of life of the plaintiffs, compensation for the care and maintenance of their grandchild who allegedly suffered permanent brain injury, and the alleged failure of the third defendant to pay proper compensation to the plaintiffs. The third defendant also sought payment of security for costs by the plaintiffs. The fourth and fifth defendants also sought orders for payment of security for costs. The court found that the threshold for requiring security for costs was not met, as only one set of costs would likely be awarded, and the Official Assignee would be able to meet any such award. The court struck out the parts of the plaintiffs' claim related to reduced expectancy of life and the alleged brain injury of the grandchild, as they were barred by the Accident Compensation Act 2001. The court also struck out the fifth cause of action in so far as it was pleaded against IAG as ACSD's insurer, but allowed the fifth cause of action against IAG as the plaintiffs' insurer to proceed. The plaintiffs were directed to file and serve an amended statement of claim within 21 days. Costs were reserved.

In summary, the High Court of New Zealand Auckland Registry dismissed the applications for security for costs and struck out certain parts of the plaintiffs' claim. The court allowed the fifth cause of action against IAG as the plaintiffs' insurer to proceed but struck out the fifth cause of action against IAG as ACSD's insurer. The plaintiffs were directed to file and serve an amended statement of claim within 21 days, and costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established