Bain v Minister of Justice

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2013-404-439 [2013] NZHC 743

BETWEEN  DAVID CULLEN BAIN Applicant

ANDMINISTER OF JUSTICE Respondent

Hearing:         11 April 2013

Counsel:         M P Reed QC & M A Karam for Applicant

K P McDonald QC & E Child for Respondent

Judgment:      16 April 2013

JUDGMENT OF KEANE J [re application for transfer]

This judgment was delivered by  on  16 April 2013 at 4pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Date:

Solicitors:

Crown Law Office, Wellington

Counsel:

M P Reed QC & M A Karam, Auckland

DAVID CULLEN BAIN V MINISTER OF JUSTICE HC AK CIV 2013-404-439 [16 April 2013]

[1]      In 1995 David Bain was convicted of the murders in 1994 of five members of his family. In 2007 the Privy Council quashed his convictions and ordered that he undergo a new trial.1 In June 2009, at his second trial, he was acquitted on all counts. He had then spent 13 years in prison. On 25 March 2010 he applied to the then Minister of Justice, Hon Simon Power, seeking compensation.

[2]      Mr Bain was not then eligible to be considered under the Cabinet Guidelines governing compensation for wrongful conviction and imprisonment. The Privy Council had granted his appeal but it had ordered a retrial. The retrial order made him ineligible under the Guidelines.

[3]      Mr Bain relied rather on the Cabinet decision approving the Guidelines, dated

2 December 1998, under which Cabinet agreed that 'the Crown reserve the right, in extraordinary circumstances, to consider claims falling outside the criteria specified

... on their individual merits, where this is in the interests of justice.'

[4]      On 10 November 2011  the Minister appointed Hon Ian  Binnie QC,  CC, formerly a Judge of the Supreme Court of Canada, to report to him on Mr Bain's claim. On 30 August 2012 Mr Binnie QC reported to the present Minister, Hon Judith Collins, recommending that Mr Bain be compensated in an amount to be fixed by Cabinet in the exercise of its discretion.

[5]      The Minister, after taking advice from the Crown Law Office and from the police, on 26 September 2012 appointed Hon Dr R L Fisher QC, a former Judge of this Court, to 'peer-review' the Binnie report. On 13 December 2012, in an interim report, Dr Fisher put in issue Mr Binnie QC's method of analysis, and thus his conclusions and recommendation. He recommended a fresh review.

[6]      Mr Bain and his advisers did not receive a copy of either report until the Minister released them publicly on 13 December 2012. The Minister considered that she was not obliged to release the Binnie report to Mr Bain and his counsel any earlier, or to release to them the Fisher report at all, or to consult with them about

either report.

1      Bain v R [2007] UKPC 33, (2007) 23 CRNZ 71 (PC).

[7]      To report responsibly to Cabinet, the Minister considered, she was entitled, indeed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bain v Minister of Justice and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 743
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

David Bain, a man who was wrongfully convicted and imprisoned for the murders of his family members, sought judicial review after the Minister of Justice did not compensate him for his wrongful conviction and imprisonment. Bain had applied for compensation in 2010, but the Minister did not consider him eligible under the Cabinet Guidelines for compensation. Bain argued that the Minister had a duty to compensate him in "extraordinary circumstances." The Minister appointed a judge to review Bain's claim, but Bain and his counsel did not receive a copy of the report until it was released publicly. Bain argued that the Minister breached his right to natural justice by not consulting with him about the report. The Minister argued that she was not required to consult with Bain and that the case should be heard in Wellington, not Auckland. The court found that Bain was entitled to file his application for review in Auckland, as of right, because a material part of his claim arose in Auckland. The court declined to transfer the case to Wellington because it found that nothing turned on where the case was argued, and it could be argued equally well in Auckland or Wellington. The court ordered that Bain was entitled to costs, according to scale 2B and any related disbursements.

The legal issues in this case were whether Bain was entitled to file his application for review in Auckland, and whether the case should be transferred to Wellington. The court found that Bain was entitled to file his application in Auckland because a material part of his claim arose in Auckland. The court declined to transfer the case to Wellington because it found that nothing turned on where the case was argued. The court reasoned that the case could be argued equally well in Auckland or Wellington, and it could proceed on the same day in either city. The court took no account of Bain's submission that he had suffered an injustice calling for redress, that he was without means, and that the Minister was seeking to deny him equality of arms. Whether he had suffered an injustice warranting compensation was the very issue Cabinet must decide, and he had not disclosed his means, or explained why he had not applied for legal aid. The court found that Bain was entitled to bring his application for review in the Auckland Registry of this Court and declined the Minister's application for transfer of the case to the Wellington Registry.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established