B v Police HC Napier CRI 2007 441 37

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CRI 2007 441 000037

BETWEEN  B

Appellant

ANDPOLICE Respondent

Hearing:         4 March 2008

Counsel:         P Ross for Appellant

Nicola Graham for Crown

Judgment:      20 March 2008 at 2:00pm

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J.

This judgment was delivered by

Hon. Justice Williams on

20 March 2008 at 2:00pm

pursuant to R 540(4) of the High Court Rules

……………………………..

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ……………………..

A.The appeal against conviction for driving with excess breath-alcohol is dismissed.

B.The appellant’s sentence of 100 hours Community Work, including her disqualification   for  9   months,   is   to   commence   immediately   after midnight on the day after delivery of this judgment.

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, Napier

Copy for:

Philip Ross, Napier

Judge Adeane, High Court Napier.

B V POLICE HC NAP CRI 2007 441 000037  20 March 2008

Issue

[1]      On 2 November 2007, the appellant, Ms B  , was convicted following a defended hearing in the Napier District Court on one charge of driving a motor vehicle   on   the   road   whilst   the   proportion   of   alcohol   in   her   breath   was

615 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath against a limit of 400 micrograms of alcohol per litre.

[2]      On the same date, she was ordered to serve 100 hours community work and was disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for nine months.

[3]      She has now appealed to this Court against conviction.  Her disqualification has been suspended pending determination of her appeal.

Ground of appeal

[4]      The principal ground on which the appeal is based is that factual findings made in the District Court were so patently improbable it was not open to Judge Adeane to conclude the elements of the offence had been proved beyond reasonable doubt.

[5]      Mr Ross, counsel for Ms B  , was at pains to endeavour to distinguish between that basis for appeal – something he submitted was open to reversal in this Court – and a finding on credibility by a fact-finder who had the opportunity of seeing and hearing the witnesses.

[6]      Ms Graham, on the other hand, for the Crown, submitted Judge Adeane made a credibility finding having evaluated the conflicting evidence before him, and accordingly this was an appeal essentially governed by the Supreme Court’s decision in Owen v R [2007] NZSC 102 paras [13]-[17].

Facts

[7]      About 10:45 pm on 26 July 2007, Constable Andrew stopped Ms B   at an alcohol checkpoint in Napier. She failed a passive breath test administered by a Dragar Alcotest 6510, calibrated for six months on 27 June 2007, that being a device approved by the Ministry of Transport by “Gazette” notice.

[8]      He required Ms B   to park nearby for a breath screening test. She did that. He tested her after assembling the Dragar device in accordance with the Transport (Breath Tests) Notice (No. 2) 1989. She failed.  He showed her the result and then required her to accompany him to a Police facility – commonly known…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read B v Police HC Napier CRI 2007 441 37 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZHC 362
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court was an appeal by Ms B against her conviction for driving with excess breath-alcohol, and her subsequent sentence. Ms B was convicted in the Napier District Court of driving a motor vehicle on the road while the proportion of alcohol in her breath was 615 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath, against a limit of 400 micrograms of alcohol per litre. The District Court imposed a sentence of 100 hours community work and disqualified Ms B from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for nine months. The appeal centred on the contention that the factual findings made by the District Court were so patently improbable that it was not open to Judge Adeane to conclude the elements of the offence had been proved beyond reasonable doubt.

The court was required to determine whether the District Court’s findings of fact were so patently improbable that the conviction should be set aside. This involved considering the credibility of the evidence presented by both the appellant and the Constable, and determining whether the District Court's assessment of the evidence was appropriate. The court needed to balance the appellant’s claims of procedural deficiencies against the Constable’s evidence of correctly following the required procedures and providing the necessary advice to Ms B.

The court held that the appeal was essentially against the factual findings made by the District Court, and the principles set out in Owen v R [2007] NZSC 102 applied. The Supreme Court in Owen emphasised that appellate courts should not lightly interfere with the fact-finding function of the trial court, especially when the trial court has had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses. The court found that Constable Andrew’s evidence was credible and that he had correctly followed the required procedures. The District Court Judge had a substantial advantage in assessing the credibility of the witnesses and had appropriately weighed the conflicting evidence. The court concluded that there was no basis to disturb the District Court’s findings.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellant’s sentence, including her disqualification from driving, was to commence immediately after midnight on the day after the delivery of the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established