Auckland Council v Body Corporate 366567

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA109/2024
 [2025] NZCA 78

BETWEEN

AUCKLAND COUNCIL
Appellant

AND

BODY CORPORATE 366567
First Respondent

THE PARTIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1
Second Respondents

Hearing:

13 March 2025

Court:

Katz, Thomas and Ellis JJ

Counsel:

C M Meechan KC, S C Price, M J Ferrier and C M Fairnie for Appellant
G M Illingworth KC and D J Powell for First and Second Respondents

Judgment:

27 March 2025 at 11.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to amend the respondent’s notice of cross-appeal is granted except in relation to proposed para 2.2.

BCosts will lie where they fall.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Ellis J)

  1. Auckland Council (the Council), Body Corporate 366567 and the owners of the apartments in a 40-level apartment building on Gore Street, Auckland Central (collectively, for convenience, the Body Corporate) have appealed and cross-appealed a decision of Walker J in the High Court.[1]  The Judge found the Council tortiously liable for losses resulting from certain defects in the Gore Street building but dismissed a number of other similar claims.  In broad terms, liability was established where the claims were not found to be statute barred and where the defects were proved, on the balance of probabilities, to be in breach of the building code.[2]

    [2]Building Regulations 1992, sch 1 [building code].

  2. The appeal and cross-appeal are scheduled to be heard over ten days in August this year.

  3. The Body Corporate has applied for leave to amend its grounds of cross‑appeal.[3]  Although the Council has consented to most of the proposed amendments, it continues to oppose two of them.  The question this judgment is concerned with is whether leave to make the two amendments should be granted.

Relevant law

[3]Because the appeals have already been set down for hearing and the application is opposed (in part), leave is required under r 34 of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

  1. There is no dispute as to the legal principles relevant to such an application.[4]  The touchstone is whether there is material prejudice or unfairness to the opposing party.  And as this Court said in McCollum v Thompson, the relevant unfairness stems from the fact that:[5]

    … if the party opposing the raising of the new point would, on an objective assessment, have fairly wished to run the case differently in the trial court had the point been raised, the appeal court cannot provide that opportunity without ordering a new trial.  To put a party to the delay and expense of a new trial because something that could have been raised in the trial court was not raised would be unjust.  Indeed, it would run against the principle that litigation should be final, and it would bring the administration of justice into disrepute.

First proposed amendment: “judicial methodology”

[4]The parties have referred, in particular to McCollum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Auckland Council v Body Corporate 366567 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZCA 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal and cross-appeal in Auckland Council v Body Corporate 366567 involve a dispute between the Auckland Council, the Body Corporate of an apartment building on Gore Street, Auckland Central, and the owners of the apartments in that building. The High Court found the Council tortiously liable for losses resulting from certain defects in the Gore Street building, but dismissed a number of other similar claims. The Court of Appeal is set to hear the appeal and cross-appeal over ten days in August this year. The Body Corporate has applied for leave to amend its grounds of cross-appeal. The Council has consented to most of the proposed amendments but opposes two of them. This judgment is concerned with whether leave to make the two amendments should be granted.

The Body Corporate seeks to amend the grounds of its cross-appeal in relation to the approach taken by the High Court to the assessment of certain defects in the Gore Street building. In particular, the Body Corporate argues that it should not have been required to prove on the balance of probabilities that the relevant defects in the building meant it would not comply with the functional requirements of the building code in future, and that something less is required. The Body Corporate contends that it should “only” need to prove that the existence of a particular defect meant there could be no “reasonable assurance” that the building code would be met. However, the Body Corporate did not raise this issue in the High Court. It was only partially raised in closing submissions, but the argument was not fully developed and the Court of Appeal was unable to assess whether the new ground (if permitted) would require new or different evidence. The Body Corporate has not persuaded the Court of Appeal that there is not a material risk of unfairness and prejudice if leave on this point were to be granted. Leave to include para 2.2 in the notice of cross-appeal is declined, accordingly.

The Body Corporate also seeks to amend the grounds of its cross-appeal in relation to the standard of proof required to establish the extent to which noise associated with remedial works necessitated the vacation of some of the Gore Street apartments. The Body Corporate wants to take a less binary approach than it did in the High Court. The proposed amended version of the “acoustic evidence” cross-appeal would read as follows: The Court erred in finding that NZS 6803:1999 was an appropriate standard to determine noise levels for the purpose of assessing losses resulting from the need to vacate Gore St during repairs. The Body Corporate’s “new” position is, in fact, grounded in the evidence of Mr Finley, which the Council had well before trial. The Court of Appeal is unable to see any material unfairness or other prejudice arising from the signalled change in position on appeal. We grant leave to amend accordingly.

The application for leave to amend the respondent’s notice of cross-appeal is granted except in relation to proposed para 2.2. As both sides have had a measure of success, costs will lie where they fall.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established