Attorney-General v Ngati Apa

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA173/01
CA75/02

BETWEENNGATI APA, NGATI KOATA, NGATI KUIA, NGATI RARUA, NGATI TAMA, NGATI TOA AND RANGITANE


First Appellants

ANDTE ATIAWA MANAWHENUA KI TE TAU IHU TRUST


Second Appellants

ANDTHE ATTORNEY-GENERAL


First Respondent

ANDNEW ZEALAND MARINE FARMING ASSOCIATION INCORPORATED


Second Respondent

ANDPORT MARLBOROUGH LIMITED


Third Respondent

ANDMARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL


Fourth Respondent

Hearing:1-4 July 2002

Coram:Elias CJ
Gault P
Keith J
Tipping J
Anderson J

Appearances:  H C Keyte QC, L G Powell and M T Lloyd for Appellants


K L Ertel and E M Cleary for Te Atiawa Appellants
J M Dawson and A M McGregor for Te Runanga o Muriwhenua (supporting appellants)
W M Wilson QC for Maori not otherwise represented
T Arnold QC, H M Aikman and F Sinclair for First Respondent
G W R Palmer and M C W Hickford for Second Respondent
M J Hunt for Third Respondent
B P Dwyer for Fourth Respondent

Judgment:19 June 2003 

JUDGMENTS OF THE COURT

Judgments
  Para No
Elias CJ [1]
Gault P [93]
KEITH AND ANDERSON JJ [126]
Tipping J [183]

ELIAS CJ

Table of Contents
 Paragraph
     Number
The appeal [1]
The legal status of customary interests in land [14]
Ownership of foreshore and seabed [49]
Jurisdictional objection that seabed not “land” [55]
Area-specific legislation [58]
The Harbours Acts 1878 and 1950 [59]
Territorial Seas Acts [62]
Section 9A Revesting Act [64]
The Resource Management Act 1991 [75]
Investigation of title to land bounded by sea [77]
Conclusion [90]
Result [91]

The appeal

[1]       For the purposes of Te Ture Whenua Maori Act 1993, all land in New Zealand has one of six statuses identified by s129(1) of the Act.  The six possibilities are:  Maori customary land; Maori freehold land; general land owned by Maori; general land; Crown land; and Crown land reserved for Maori. 

[2]       The Maori Land Court has jurisdiction under s18(1)(h) of the 1993 Act to determine for the purposes of any proceeding in that Court “or for any other purpose” whether any specified land “is or is not Maori customary land or Maori freehold land or General land owned by Maori or General land or Crown land”.  The Court also has jurisdiction to make declarations by way of status orders under s131(1) that land has the status of Maori customary land.  This jurisdiction is not exclusive.  The jurisdiction of the High Court to determine any question relating to the particular status of any land is not affected (s131(3)).  The Maori Land Court has however exclusive jurisdiction under s132 to investigate the title to such land and to grant an order vesting it in those found on investigation to be entitled to it.  The effect of a vesting order is to change the status of land from Maori customary land (held according to tikanga Maori) to Maori freehold land (held in fee of the Crown and in respect of which under ss139-141 the District Land Registrar must issue a fee simple title under the Land Transfer Act 1952).

[3]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General v Ngati Apa and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NZCA 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ngati Apa and other appellants applied to the Maori Land Court to determine if certain foreshore and seabed areas in the Marlborough Sounds were Maori customary land. The Attorney-General and other respondents objected, arguing that the Maori Land Court had no jurisdiction to make such a determination. The Maori Appellate Court referred questions to the High Court, which ruled that Maori customary land could not extend below the low water mark. The Maori parties appealed to the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal held that customary property interests continued at common law until lawfully extinguished. Legislation recognising Maori customary land assumed its continued existence. There was no presumption of Crown ownership as a consequence of the assumption of sovereignty. The Court found that seabed and foreshore were "land" for the purposes of the Maori Land legislation. The Court allowed the appeal and held that the Maori Land Court had jurisdiction to determine if the foreshore and seabed were Maori customary land.

The Court found that In Re the Ninety-Mile Beach was wrongly decided and should not be followed. The Court also held that area-specific legislation and the Territorial Seas Acts did not extinguish any Maori customary property. The Foreshore and Seabed Endowment Revesting Act 1991 did not affect any Maori customary property that had not already been extinguished.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established