Attorney-General v District Court at Otahuhu

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND CA 268/00
BETWEEN ATTORNEY‑GENERAL (on behalf of the New Zealand Police)

Appellant

AND THE DISTRICT COURT AT OTAHUHU

First Respondent

AND JEREMY BROWN

Second Respondent

Hearing: 3 May and 5 June 2001
Coram: Richardson P
Gault J
Keith J
Blanchard J
Tipping J
Appearances: J C Pike and J D Sutton for Appellant
G M Illingworth and D C S Reid for Second Respondent
First Respondent abides decision of Court
Judgment: 13 June 2001

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY RICHARDSON P

Table of Contents

Para No

Issues  [1]
Background  [2]
The Summary Proceedings Act  [11]
Implied powers to make pre-trial rulings  [16]
Pre-trial rulings in summary proceedings:  the
   rival submissions  [22]
Discussion:  possession or power  [29]
Discussion:  implied power to order discovery pre-trial          [33]
Special Bill of Rights pre-trial process?  [40]
Conclusions and result  [56]

Issues

  1. This appeal raises two issues.   One concerns the claim to pre‑trial access by the defence to information held by an agency or person other than the prosecution.   More specifically, it relates to the discoverability pre‑trial of the instrument manual for the Intoxilyser 5000 breath‑testing device.   The other, and logically the first issue for decision, is whether the District Court in summary proceedings has power to rule pre‑trial on such access matters.   The case highlights the need for comprehensive legislation governing disclosure in criminal cases and including a statutory regime affecting non‑party discovery.

Background

  1. On 23 October 1999 Mr Brown was apprehended by a police officer who saw him driving his vehicle in an erratic manner.   After failing the initial breath-screening test, Mr Brown was breath‑tested using an Intoxilyser 5000 breath‑testing device.   Evidential breath test is defined in s2(1) of the Land Transport Act 1998 as "a test carried out by means of an evidential breath‑testing device in a manner prescribed in respect of that device".   The Intoxilyser device was of a kind approved for the purpose by the Minister of Police under the Transport (Breath‑Tests) Notice (No 2) 1989.   The test recorded a level of 1157 mg per litre of breath.   In terms of the definition of a conclusive evidential breath‑testing device in s2 and the provisions of s77 of the 1998 Act, where the level recorded is over 600 mg per litre of breath it is "conclusively presumed that the proportion of alcohol in the defendant’s breath at the time of the alleged offence was the same as the proportion of alcohol in the defendant’s breath indicated by the test".   Where the level recorded is between 400 and 600 mg per litre of breath the result is conclusive if the suspect declines the blood test option.

  2. Mr Brown was then arrested and charged with driving with excess breath alcohol contrary to s56 of the Land Transport Act.

  3. Mr Brown sought discovery from the prosecution of the manufacturer's instruction manual.   Supporting and opposing affidavits were filed.   The manual was held not by the Police but by the Institute of Environmental Science and Research Limited (ESR),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General v District Court at Otahuhu and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NZCA 187
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal considered an appeal brought by the Attorney-General on behalf of the New Zealand Police against a decision of the District Court which ordered the police to disclose the manual for the Intoxilyser 5000 breath-testing device. The Court found that the District Court had no jurisdiction to make the order in question. The majority found that the statutory scheme did not provide for a pre-trial ruling regime, and that the court's inherent powers did not extend to ordering disclosure from a non-party pre-trial. The majority also found that the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act did not provide a sufficient basis for ordering disclosure from a non-party pre-trial. The majority found that the s20 procedure would accommodate all relevant factors and meet the interests of justice. The appeal was allowed, and the orders made in the High Court were quashed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established