Aspec Construction Wellington Limited v Fawcett

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-9311 [2015] NZHC 535

BETWEEN

ASPEC CONSTRUCTION

WELLINGTON LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

ANDREW JAMES FAWCET Defendant

Hearing: 6 October 2014 and 13 February 2015

Counsel:

M J Leggat for Plaintiff
T J Herbert for Defendant

Judgment:

23 March 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

[1]      The plaintiff (Aspec) applies for summary judgment against Mr Fawcet.   It asks for an order directing Mr Fawcet to pay it the sum of $327,500, plus interest and costs.

[2]      Mr Fawcet was late filing his notice of opposition to the summary judgment application, and was required to file an application for an extension of time to oppose the application.   Mr Fawcet’s application for extension of time was heard together with Aspec’s application for summary judgment.

Background

[3]      Aspec is a construction company.  One of its projects was the construction of an apartment development in Evans Bay Parade, Wellington.  The developer was a company called Delta Developments Limited (Delta), of which Mr Fawcet was a

director.

ASPEC CONSTRUCTION WELLINGTON LIMITED v ANDREW JAMES FAWCET [2015] NZHC 535 [23

March 2015]

[4]      By 2012 some of the apartments had leaks, and a dispute arose between Aspec and Delta.  An arbitration award was delivered in October 2012 determining the  final  amount  due  by  Delta  to  Aspec,  and  Aspec  subsequently  obtained  a judgment in this court requiring Delta to pay it the amount of $571,182.46 plus interest and costs.

[5]      Delta’s  liability  under  the  judgment  was  settled  on  terms  set  out  in  a settlement deed dated 12 June 2013 (the deed).  Mr Fawcet was a party to the deed. Under the deed, Delta was required to pay Aspec $49,500 by 28 June 2013, and by the same date it was to procure the delivery to Aspec of 330,000 unencumbered Barter Card Trade Dollars. Those obligations were duly discharged by Delta.

[6]      As their name suggests, Barter Card Trade Dollars (which I will refer to as “trade dollars”) are a form of alternative “currency”, which participating members use in member-to-member transactions for the sale and purchase of goods and services.  The detail of how the system works need not concern us for the purposes of this judgment, but an extract from the Barter Card website which Mr Fawcet produced states that purchases made with trade dollars allow a company to buy goods and services at an effective discount equal to its gross margins, and conserve cash reserves which would normally be depleted by such purposes.   The website extract says that one trade dollar is equivalent to $1 NZ for all intents and purposes, including tax, GST and pricing.   That “exchange rate” has been accepted by Mr Fawcet in his opposition to the summary judgment application.

[7]      Under the deed, Aspec was free to use the trade dollars to acquire such goods or services as it saw fit.   But to the extent it had not used the trade dollars by

18 June 2014, the deed conferred on Aspec the right to “put”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aspec Construction Wellington Limited v Fawcett and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 535
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aspec Construction Wellington Limited (Aspec) applied for summary judgment against Mr Andrew James Fawcet, seeking an order for Mr Fawcet to pay it $327,500 plus interest and costs. Mr Fawcet opposed the application but was late in filing his notice of opposition. He was granted an extension of time. The primary issue was whether Aspec was entitled to require Mr Fawcet to exchange cash for trade dollars he held, as per a settlement deed. The court found that Aspec's right to require Mr Fawcet to pay cash for the trade dollars was unconditional, as the settlement deed did not condition this right on Aspec fulfilling obligations under another clause. However, the court declined to order specific performance of this obligation, finding that Aspec had not shown that damages would not be an adequate remedy. The court entered summary judgment for Aspec on liability, with damages to be assessed at trial. The parties were directed to amend their pleadings to reflect the claim for damages, and a case management conference was set for a future date. Costs were reserved.