IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CIV-2015-485-484 [2016] NZHC 207
UNDER the Defamation Act 1992 BETWEEN
KAREN FRANCES ARNOLD Plaintiff
AND
FAIRFAX NEW ZEALAND LIMITED First Defendant
TIMOTHY RICHARD SHADBOLT Second Defendant
Hearing: 2 February 2016 Counsel:
P A McKnight and A J Romanos for Plaintiff
R K P Stewart and R G Cahn for First Defendant
F E Geiringer for Second DefendantJudgment:
23 February 2016
JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J
Introduction
[1] Karen Arnold sues Fairfax New Zealand Limited and Timothy Shadbolt. She says that Mr Shadbolt defamed her in four columns he wrote which Fairfax published in The Southland Times, two of which Fairfax also posted on its website Stuff. Fairfax and Mr Shadbolt defend those claims on the basis, first, that the columns did not carry the meanings claimed. If the jury decides that they did, and those meanings were defamatory, they both rely in the alternative on the defences of honest opinion and qualified privilege.
[2] To succeed in that, alternative, honest opinion defence:
ARNOLD v FAIRFAX NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2016] NZHC 207 [23 February 2016]
(a) Mr Shadbolt must prove that the defamatory meanings were his genuine opinion; and (b)
Fairfax must prove that the defamatory meanings did not purport to be its opinion and that it had no reasonable cause to believe that
Mr Shadbolt’s opinions which constitute the defamatory meanings were
not his genuine opinions.
[3]
Mr
Shadbolt has, in addition, counterclaimed against Ms Arnold.
Mr Shadbolt says that Ms Arnold defamed him in a letter she wrote to the Editor of The Southland Times, which was subsequently published in that paper. Mr Shadbolt’s claim is, however, only based on his being defamed in the eyes of the Editor, and not those of the readers of The Southland Times.
[4] In this interlocutory application, Ms Arnold asks the Court to:
(a) strike out the defendants’ alternative, honest opinion, defences; or
(b)direct (as pleaded) the defendants to identify which of the defamatory meanings pleaded are defended on the basis of honest opinion or (as argued) specify with more particularity the particulars which apply to the various defamatory meanings pleaded; and
(c) strike out certain of the defamatory meanings pleaded by Mr Shadbolt in his counterclaim.
Background
[5] Mr Shadbolt is the Mayor of Invercargill. Ms Arnold is an Invercargill City Councillor. Ms Arnold, and other councillors, have been critical of the substance of, and process relating to, proposed commercial transactions involving the Council’s wholly-owned subsidiary, Invercargill City Holdings Limited (Holdco). That company is, in turn, the parent company of Invercargill Airport Limited, Electricity Invercargill Limited and other entities. Mr Shadbolt, and others associated with him, have been similarly critical of proposals supported by Ms Arnold and others for the
development by the Invercargill City Council of kakapo and tuatara “recovery programme” facilities, designed to be tourist attractions (the “Kakaporium” and the “Tuatarium” respectively).
[6] The four columns that are the subject of these proceedings comment on those…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Arnold v Fairfax New Zealand Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NZHC 207
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues were whether the defendants could raise an alternative defence of honest opinion while denying that their publications carried the defamatory meanings alleged, and whether the defendants' particulars in support of their defence of honest opinion were sufficient. Arnold also sought to strike out certain defamatory meanings pleaded by Shadbolt in his counterclaim.
The court found that the defendants could raise an alternative defence of honest opinion while denying that their publications carried the defamatory meanings alleged. This approach was supported by the Court of Appeal in Television New Zealand Ltd v Haines. The court also found that the defendants' particulars in support of their defence of honest opinion were sufficient and did not require further specificity. Regarding Shadbolt's counterclaim, the court ruled that one of the defamatory meanings pleaded by Shadbolt could not be taken from Arnold's letter, while the other pleaded meanings could.
The court declined Arnold's applications to strike out the defendants' alternative, honest opinion defences and to require further specificity in the defendants' particulars. The court also declined Arnold's application to strike out certain defamatory meanings pleaded by Shadbolt in his counterclaim, except for one meaning that could not be taken from Arnold's letter.
The defendants were entitled to costs on the interlocutory application, to be determined by agreement or, if necessary, by the filing of memoranda not exceeding three pages by the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi