Armitage v Stylo Medical Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA200/2023
 [2023] NZCA 425

BETWEEN

ROSANNE ARMITAGE
Appellant

AND

STYLO MEDICAL SERVICES LIMITED
Respondent

Counsel:

Appellant in Person
R O Parmenter for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

6 September 2023 at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

The application for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision is declined.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. This review of a Deputy Registrar’s decision concerns an appeal against Associate Judge Brittain’s decision dismissing an application for orders staying or striking out liquidation proceedings brought by Stylo Medical Services Ltd (Stylo) against Hum Hospitality Ltd (Hum).[1]  Stylo and Hum have a long history of litigation arising from a lease by Hum of premises owned by Stylo.  The lease has now been cancelled and judgment entered against Hum for rental arrears.[2]  That judgment sum forms one of the grounds on which Stylo sought an order placing Hum into liquidation.

  2. Ms Armitage brings the appeal in her capacity as a creditor and shareholder of Hum.  She filed her notice of appeal on 17 April 2023.[3]  Security for costs was set at $7,060.[4]  Ms Armitage applied for an order dispensing with security for costs or, alternatively, reducing security and deferring the date by which it was payable.[5]  Her grounds for seeking a dispensation were that she is impecunious, that the appeal is genuine and reasonably arguable and there is a public interest in the issues raised.  A Deputy Registrar of this Court declined the application.  Ms Armitage applies for a review of that decision.

    [3]The notice of appeal was originally filed in the name of Hum Hospitality Ltd (Ms Armitage as personal guarantor), but an amended notice of appeal filed on 26 April 2023 named Ms Armitage personally as the appellant.

    [4]Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, r 35.

    [5]Rule 35(6).

  3. The Deputy Registrar set out the relevant legal principles at some length. Her summary of the principles was correct.  There is no need for me to restate them.

  4. It is accepted that Ms Armitage is impecunious.  The Deputy Registrar did not, however, consider that the appeal raised any substantive issue of public interest, nor that the grounds of appeal were reasonably arguable.  I agree with both conclusions.

  5. The appeal is part of a very long history of litigation between Hum and Stylo and the decision under challenge was one involving the application of established principles to the facts of the case. No issue of public interest arises.

  6. I turn to the Deputy Registrar’s assessment of the merits of the appeal and the question of whether the potential costs and benefits justified requiring Stylo to defend the judgment without the protection of security for costs.  There are seven grounds of appeal being advanced.[6]  They relate broadly to the Judge’s findings regarding (1) service of the proceedings, (2) advertising…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Armitage v Stylo Medical Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 425
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the case of Armitage v Stylo Medical Services Limited involves an appeal by Rosanne Armitage against a decision of Associate Judge Brittain. The appeal seeks to stay or strike out liquidation proceedings brought by Stylo Medical Services Limited against Hum Hospitality Limited. The litigation between Stylo and Hum stems from a lease agreement for premises owned by Stylo, which has now been cancelled and resulted in a judgment for rental arrears against Hum. Armitage, as a creditor and shareholder of Hum, filed a notice of appeal on 17 April 2023, seeking a review of a Deputy Registrar’s decision to decline her application for an order dispensing with security for costs or reducing security and deferring the date by which it was payable. The Deputy Registrar concluded that the appeal did not raise any substantive issue of public interest, nor were the grounds of appeal reasonably arguable.

The legal issues before the court included whether the appeal raised any substantive issue of public interest, whether the grounds of appeal were reasonably arguable, and whether the potential costs and benefits justified requiring Stylo to defend the judgment without the protection of security for costs. The court found that the appeal was part of a long history of litigation between Hum and Stylo, and the decision under challenge involved the application of established principles to the facts of the case. The court concluded that no issue of public interest arose and that the grounds of appeal were not reasonably arguable. The court also noted that the benefits to Armitage did not outweigh the potential costs of requiring Stylo to defend the appeal without security for costs.

The court held that the application for review of the Deputy Registrar’s decision is declined. The Deputy Registrar’s assessment of the merits of the appeal and the issue of whether the potential costs and benefits justified requiring Stylo to defend the judgment without security for costs was found to be correct. The court found no error in the Deputy Registrar’s conclusions that the grounds of appeal were not reasonably arguable and that the potential benefits did not outweigh the potential costs. As a result, the appeal for review is declined, and the original decision of the Deputy Registrar stands.

Background

Background to the litigation

Stylo Medical Services Ltd (Stylo) and Hum Hospitality Ltd (Hum) have a protracted history of litigation stemming from a lease of premises owned by Stylo. The lease has since been cancelled and Stylo obtained a judgment against Hum for rental arrears. Stylo subsequently sought to place Hum into liquidation on the grounds that Hum was insolvent due to the unpaid judgment sum. The liquidation application was dismissed by Associate Judge Brittain. Hum's creditor and shareholder, Rosanne Armitage, appealed the dismissal of the liquidation application. Armitage applied for a review of the Deputy Registrar's decision to decline her application for dispensing with security for costs or, alternatively, reducing security and deferring the payment date.

The appeal against the dismissal of the liquidation application was filed by Armitage on 17 April 2023, originally in the name of Hum but later amended to name Armitage personally as the appellant. Security for costs was set at $7,060. Armitage applied for an order dispensing with security for costs or, alternatively, reducing security and deferring the payment date. The Deputy Registrar declined the application, and Armitage now seeks a review of that decision by the Court of Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the grounds of appeal are reasonably arguable.
2. Whether the appeal raises any substantive issue of public interest.
3. Whether the potential costs and benefits of the appeal justify requiring Stylo to defend the judgment without the protection of security for costs.

Held
1. The court held that the grounds of appeal were not reasonably arguable.
2. The court held that the appeal did not raise any substantive issue of public interest.
3. The court held that the potential costs and benefits of the appeal did not justify requiring Stylo to defend the judgment without the protection of security for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal reviewed the decision of the Deputy Registrar to decline Ms Armitage's application for a review of the decision not to dispense with or reduce security for costs in relation to an appeal against an Associate Judge's decision dismissing an application for orders staying or striking out liquidation proceedings brought by Stylo Medical Services Ltd against Hum Hospitality Ltd. The Deputy Registrar declined the application on the basis that the appeal was neither genuinely reasonably arguable nor of public interest, and that the costs to Stylo of defending the appeal without security for costs outweighed any potential benefits to Ms Armitage. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Deputy Registrar's conclusions. The court found that the grounds of appeal were not reasonably arguable as they related to the application of established principles to the facts of the case, and did not involve any issue of public interest. The court considered the merits of the appeal and found that the potential costs and benefits did not justify requiring Stylo to defend the appeal without security for costs. The court noted that the appeal was part of a long history of litigation between Hum and Stylo, and that the Judge's decision was based on the fact that Hum had not paid the judgment debts, which entitled Stylo to bring the liquidation proceedings. The court also noted that Hum's claim against Stylo could still be advanced by a liquidator. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that where an appeal is part of a long history of litigation between the parties, involves the application of established principles to the facts of the case, and does not raise any issue of public interest, the court may decline to dispense with or reduce security for costs in relation to the appeal.