Apatu v Apatu HC Napier CIV-2010-441-195

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2010-441-195

BETWEEN  ASHLEY KANARA APATU Plaintiff

ANDKENNETH TAMA TE KAPUA APATU AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF WIRIHANA TIPENE APATU

First Defendant

ANDNATHAN WIRIHANA APATU, RENATA ROBIN APATU AND KATHERINE LOUISE BATES AS EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF WIRIHANA TERRENCE APATU

Second Defendants

Hearing:         1 December 2011 (Heard at Napier)

Counsel:         No appearance for Plaintiff

M. Macfarlane - Counsel for Defendant

Judgment:      19 December 2011 at 2:30 PM

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment was delivered by Associate Judge Gendall on 19 December 2011 at

2.30 pm under r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Solicitors:           Tamatekapua Law, PO Box 106 454, Auckland

Sainsbury Logan & Williams, Solicitors, P Box 41, Napier

AK APATU V KTT APATU AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF WIRIHANA TIPENE APATU & ANOR HC NAP CIV-2010-441-195 19 December 2011

Introduction

[1]      For decision is an application seeking security for costs against the plaintiff brought by the defendants as executors of the estate of Mr Wirihana Terrence Apatu (Mr Terry Apatu) and of the estate of Mr Wirihana Tipene Apatu (Mr Wirihana Apatu).

[2]      That application has not been formally opposed by the plaintiff, Mr Ashley Apatu,  and  no  appearance  was  made  on  his  behalf.    On  30  November  2011, however, a memorandum was received from the counsel for the plaintiff, Ms Kapua, informing the Court that the plaintiff has now been successful in his application for legal aid with respect to these proceedings.  Ms Kapua further advised the Court at paras [5] and [6] of her memorandum:

5.        It is therefore submitted that it would be unjust in the circumstances to require security for costs given the process (plaintiff now being legally aided) to date.

6.          However counsel does not intend to do more than raise this matter with the

Court, given the late notice of the grant and will abide the Court’s decision.

Background

[3]      The parties have been involved in protracted litigation which began in 2007. Mr Ken Apatu the first defendant, and Mr Terry Apatu were the executors and trustees of the estate of their late father, Wirihana  Tipene Apatu (Mr Wirihana Apatu).  The plaintiff is the brother of Mr Ken and Mr Terry Apatu and the son of Mr Wirihana Apatu.   Mr Wirihana Apatu died in 1970.   The plaintiff (along with others)  is  also  a  beneficiary  of  Mr  Wirihana  Apatu’s  estate.    All  proceedings between these parties have generally related to the administration of the estate of their father Mr Wirihana Apatu by Mr Ken Apatu and Mr Terry Apatu.  That history is set out in the recent judgment of Williams J: Apatu v Apatu HC Napier CIV-2007-

441-823, 3 November 2011.

[4]      Those proceedings (CIV-2007-441-823) also concerned another plaintiff, Ms Winipera Mauger, sister to the plaintiff and the defendants.  She was a plaintiff with respect to all of the claims brought by the plaintiff Mr Ashley Apatu and, as well, she brought separate proceedings against Mr Ken and Mr Terry Apatu,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apatu v Apatu HC Napier CIV-2010-441-195 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 2018
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Associate Judge Gendall considered an application for security for costs made by the defendants in the case of Apatu v Apatu. The application was brought by the executors of the estates of Mr Wirihana Terrence Apatu and Mr Wirihana Tipene Apatu against the plaintiff, Ashley Kanara Apatu, who is the brother of the executors and the son of their late father, Mr Wirihana Apatu. The plaintiff had recently been granted legal aid for the proceedings, and the defendants argued that this made him impecunious and thus required him to provide security for costs. The court had to decide whether to exercise its discretion to order security for costs, considering the plaintiff's impecuniosity and other relevant factors.

The court found that the plaintiff's claims were weak and had little chance of success. The claims related to alleged breaches of trust, fiduciary duties, and equitable fraud concerning two blocks of land associated with the estate of Mr Wirihana Apatu. The court noted that the plaintiff's claims had already been considered and rejected in previous proceedings, and the passage of time further diminished the likelihood of success in the present case. Additionally, the claims were considered to be personal rather than related to the administration of the estate, and thus subject to a limitation period that had expired.

Despite the plaintiff's receipt of legal aid, the court found that exceptional circumstances existed for ordering security for costs. The court reasoned that the plaintiff's claims were unreasonable and pursued in bad faith, considering factors such as the timing of the claims, the previous unsuccessful litigation, and the likelihood of the claims succeeding. Therefore, the court ordered the plaintiff to provide security for costs in the amount of $20,000, to be paid within 30 working days, and stayed the proceedings until the security was provided. The defendants were also granted costs on a category 2B basis, along with disbursements as fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established