Apatu v Apatu HC Napier CIV-2007-441-823

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2007-441-823

BETWEEN  ASHLEY KANARA APATU First Plaintiff

ANDWINIPERA EVA MAUGER Second Plaintiff

ANDKENNETH TAMA TE KAPUA APATU First Defendant

ANDNATHAN WIRIHANA APATU RENATA ROBIN APATU

ANDKATHERINE LOUISE BATES Second Defendants

Counsel:         J McLennan for Plaintiffs

M Macfarlane for Defendants

Judgment:      3 November 2011

JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J (AS TO COSTS)

In accordance with r 11.5, I direct the Registrar to endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 4.00pm on the 3rd November 2011.

Solicitors:

ASHLEY KANARA APATU V KENNETH TAMA TE KAPUA APATU HC NAP CIV-2007-441-823 3

November 2011

Holmden Horrocks, Barristers & Solicitors, telephone: (09) 303 3989

Sainsbury Logan & Williams, telephone: (06) 835 3069

Introduction

[1]      Before me are memoranda as to costs by both parties to these proceedings. By judgment delivered 10 May 2011 I found that the plaintiffs fail in all of their claims.   I invited memoranda as to costs to be filed if agreement could not be reached.

[2]      With respect to claim CIV-2009-441-515 (the claim brought by Ms Winipere (Wini) Mauger against Mr Terrence (Terry) Apatu) the parties are agreed that costs should  be given on  a  2B basis,  with  0.5  days  for the hearing,  if  indemnity or increased costs do not apply.

[3]      With  regard  to  the  main  claim,  CIV-2007-441-823  (brought  by  both plaintiffs), the defendants seek increased or indemnity costs against the plaintiffs for, they argue,  unreasonably declining a settlement  offer, taking hopeless  points  in argument and conducting their case in a way which caused wasted time and expense. Further,  the  defendants  seek  costs  for both  defendants’  counsel.    The  plaintiffs oppose costs on those bases.  The plaintiffs accept that costs should follow the event but on a 2B basis for one defendant’s counsel only.  The defendants accept that if costs are awarded on a scale basis that 2B is appropriate.

[4]      It is also pertinent to note at the outset that the plaintiffs have appealed against my 10 May 2011 decision.  The appeal was filed on 20 June 2011.  I consider the relevance of that below.

Background

[5]      These proceedings relate to a relatively protracted dispute between family members.   The issues all arise out of the disposition of the estate of the parties’ father, Mr Wirihana Apatu, who died in 1970.   The defendants were trustees and executors of their father’s estate.  The plaintiffs are half of the beneficiaries which

were to retain the residue of their father’s estate.   While some dispositions were directed by Wirihana Apatu to the beneficiaries, the beneficiaries were not to receive all of their entitlement until the death of their mother, Mrs Minola Apatu, who received a life interest in much of the estate.  Minola Apatu died in 2003.

[6]      The plaintiffs alleged breach of trust or fiduciary duty against the defendants in several respects.  Variously, claims were brought against one or other or both of the defendants.  Wini also brought some claims against Terry’s estate individually. Either before or during the hearing three of those claims were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apatu v Apatu HC Napier CIV-2007-441-823 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1656
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Ashley Kanara Apatu and Winipere Eva Mauger, brought claims against the defendants, Kenneth Tama Te Kapua Apatu and Nathan Wirihana Apatu Renata Robin Apatu and Katherine Louise Bates, relating to the disposition of their father’s estate. The proceedings were lengthy and involved numerous claims and counterclaims. The plaintiffs’ claims were ultimately unsuccessful, and the defendants sought indemnity or increased costs against the plaintiffs for various reasons, including the plaintiffs' unreasonable refusal of a settlement offer, taking of hopeless points, and conduct that caused wasted time and expense. The plaintiffs opposed these costs on the basis that the claims were not hopeless and that they should not be penalised for pursuing their claims. The defendants also sought costs for both sets of their counsel, while the plaintiffs argued that costs should only be awarded for one defendant’s counsel.

The court considered the appropriate basis for awarding costs, noting that indemnity costs should only be awarded in rare cases involving flagrant misconduct or breach of confidence. The court found that while the plaintiffs’ claims were not entirely without merit, their refusal to accept a settlement offer and the pursuit of certain claims that were statute-barred warranted an award of increased or indemnity costs. The court decided that one-third of the defendants’ costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, and the remaining two-thirds on a 2B basis. The court also determined that costs should be awarded for both sets of the defendants' counsel, but each set's costs should be reduced by 25% to account for the overlap in the defences. The court assessed the quantum of costs and ordered the plaintiffs to pay around $37,400 to the first defendant and $42,000 to the second defendants, inclusive of disbursements and GST.