IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE
CRI-2024-454-8
[2024] NZHC 1926
BETWEEN AOKAUTERE LAND HOLDINGS LIMITED
Appellant
AND
THE KING
Respondent
CRI-2024-454-10 BETWEEN
LESLIE WILLIAM FUGLE
AppellantAND
THE KING
Respondent
Hearing: 11 June 2024 Appearances:
S L Baigent for Appellants
B D Vanderkolk for Respondent
Judgment:
12 July 2024
JUDGMENT OF BOLDT J
(Appeal against sentence and refusal to grant name suppression.)
Introduction
[1] This case concerns Woodgate Heights, a residential subdivision in Aokautere, on the outskirts of Palmerston North. The appellants, who were actively involved in the Woodgate Heights development, are Mr Leslie Fugle and Aokautere Land Holdings Ltd (ALHL). Mr Fugle is ALHL’s sole director and shareholder.
AOKAUTERE LAND HOLDINGS LIMITED v R [2024] NZHC 1926 [12 July 2024]
[2] On 9 June 2023 each appellant pleaded guilty to a representative charge under s 338 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). Mr Fugle pleaded guilty to conducting earthworks contrary to a regional rule between 1 December 2019 and 29 January 2021,1 and ALHL pleaded guilty to a charge of contravening two abatement notices between 19 December 2019 and 29 January 2021.2
[3] On 23 February 2024, Judge D A Kirkpatrick convicted and sentenced the appellants.3 He fined Mr Fugle $72,000, and ALHL $28,000. In a second decision, issued on 3 April 2024, the Judge made an enforcement order under ss 314 and 339(5)(a) of the RMA.4 The order prohibits Mr Fugle, apparently for life, from conducting or directing any land disturbance activities in the Manawatū-Whanganui Region. The Judge also declined Mr Fugle’s application for name suppression; Mr Fugle sought suppression for a period of 18 months while he obtains funding for a new (and separate) development project.
[4] The appellants appeal against their fines, arguing they are manifestly excessive. Mr Fugle also appeals against the enforcement order, and against the Judge’s refusal to suppress his name and names associated with his new development.
Background
[5] On 17 February 2014, the Manawatū-Whanganui Regional Council (Horizons) granted resource consents over two adjoining parcels of land in Woodgate Heights. Mr Fugle was involved with both consents — he was a director of the company developing one parcel, and a representative of the company developing the other. The consents expired on 1 December 2019. Once the consents expired, Mr Fugle’s work on the site was governed by Horizons’ Regional Plan, known as the One Plan. The One Plan limited earthworks on the site to 2,500 square metres annually.
1 Resource Management Act 1991, s 338(1)(a) and s 9(2): maximum penalty of two years’ imprisonment or a fine not exceeding $300,000.
2 Section 338(1)(c): maximum penalty of a $600,000 fine.
3 R v Fugle [2024] NZDC 3674 [Sentencing decision].
4 R v Fugle [2024] NZDC 7270 [Enforcement order and name suppression decision].
[6] On 28 November 2019, a Horizons inspector visited Woodgate Heights and noted that earthworks on both parcels would produce unauthorised discharges of sediment. By then, ALHL…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Aokautere Land Holdings Limited v The King and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 1926
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's reasoning focused on the need for proportionality in sentencing, the importance of deterrence, and the necessity for enforcement orders to be narrowly tailored to the likelihood of future non-compliance. The court emphasised that while fines should act as a deterrent, they should not be so high as to be manifestly excessive, especially in cases where no immediate environmental harm was identified. The enforcement order was considered too prohibitive and not aligned with the principles of necessity and proportionality. The refusal to grant name suppression was upheld as the appellants did not demonstrate that publication would cause extreme hardship or undue suspicion on others involved in the new development project.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi