ANZ National Bank Ltd v Tower Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA194/2009
[2010] NZCA 267

BETWEENANZ NATIONAL BANK LIMITED
First Appellant

ANDING (NZ) LIMITED
Second Appellant

ANDTOWER INSURANCE LIMITED
First Respondent

ANDVERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Second Respondent

Hearing:30-31 March 2010

Court:William Young  P, Glazebrook and Hammond JJ

Counsel:J E Hodder SC and B A Davies for Appellants
C T Walker and M C Smith for First Respondent
S A Armstrong for Second Respondent

Judgment:25 June 2010 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The cross-appeal is dismissed.

B        The appeal is allowed, in part. 

CWe make a declaration:

(i)that the Bank is entitled to delivery up (by Tower) of the information set out in [132] of this judgment, in the manner contemplated by [137] of this judgment; and

(ii)the Bank may pass that information to Vero.

DWe remit the proceeding to the High Court, for such further hearings and orders as may be required to give effect to C(i), above.

EBoth in the High Court, and in this Court, each party has enjoyed a real measure of success.  There will be no order for costs in either court.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Hammond J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction  
The end of a lucrative commercial relationship  [1]
Characterising the former relationship[7]
The outcome in the High Court  [9]
      The issues on the appeal[12]

Issue 1: was the Bank’s letter to the first respondent of 7 August
2008 a valid notice of termination under the ANZ agreement?

Chronology and further background[14]

The arguments  [22]
      Discussion  [33]
      A postscript: estoppel  [37]

Issue 2: is Tower entitled to renew bank-branded policies?
Introduction  [40]
The relevant contractual provisions: the National Bank agreement      [45]
      The relevant contractual provisions: the ANZ agreement  [56]
      The novations  [71]
      The High Court judgment  [73]
      Discussion  
      1.  Introduction  [76]
      2.  The textual arguments   [81]
      3.  The scheme of the agreements  [85]
      4.  The arguments from commercial context  [87]
      5.  Conclusion  [106]

Issue 3: the extent of the Bank’s entitlement to information held
by Tower about bank-branded policies and policy holders

Introduction  [108]
      The agreements  [109]
      The orders sought  [111]

The High Court judgment  [112]

The broad arguments for the parties  [114]
      The agreements in more detail  [117]
      Discussion  [140]

The effect of the Privacy Act 1993 on ANZ’s entitlement to and
use of information
  

1.  Introduction  [141]
      2.  Purpose for which the information was collected  [145]
      3.  No ‘Disclosure’  [152]
      4.  Authorisation  [156]
      5.  Breach of confidence  [161]
      6.  A fall-back argument  [162]
      7.  Conclusion  [163]

Issue 4: Disclosure to, and use by, Vero of the information
yielded up
  [168]

Conclusion  [173]

Introduction

The end of a lucrative commercial relationship

[1]       A feature of modern banking practice is that of “cross selling”.  In addition to the traditional practices of taking deposits and making loans, a bank will sell to its customers financial “products” such as insurance, credit cards, KiwiSaver accounts, travel products and the like.  The aim is to offer customers a single point of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ANZ National Bank Ltd v Tower Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZCA 267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In ANZ National Bank Ltd v Tower Insurance Ltd, the Court of Appeal of New Zealand was called upon to determine several issues arising from the termination of a business relationship between ANZ National Bank Ltd and Tower Insurance Ltd. The relationship involved the sale of bank-branded insurance policies by ANZ to its customers, written by Tower. The appeal centred on the rights and obligations of the parties following the Bank's termination of the agreements. The Court dismissed the cross-appeal and allowed the appeal in part. It made a declaration that the Bank is entitled to receive certain specified information from Tower and that the Bank may pass that information to Vero Insurance New Zealand Ltd, its new insurer. The Court also remitted the proceeding to the High Court for further hearings and orders as may be required to give effect to the declaration. The Court found that Tower is entitled to renew bank-branded policies, contrary to the Bank's argument that it should have exclusive rights to offer renewals post-termination. The Court held that the textual arguments, the scheme of the agreements, and the commercial context favoured Tower's position. Regarding the information held by Tower, the Court determined that the Bank is entitled to specific information related to bank-branded policies and policyholders, but not all of Tower's data. The Court also found that the Bank is not constrained by the Privacy Act 1993 or the general law of confidence in using the information for its purposes, including marketing to customers through its new insurer, Vero.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established