ANZ National Bank Limited v Ting

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-007769 [2012] NZHC 2860

BETWEEN  ANZ NATIONAL BANK LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDTAI TING Defendant

Hearing:         3 October 2012 (Heard at Auckland)

Appearances: S-J Telford for Plaintiff

C J Orton for Defendant

Judgment:      31 October 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE [as to summary judgment application]

Introduction

[1]      A bank lends money to a property investor resident in China.   It does so twice.   It lends $175,200 and $160,800.  Soon afterwards the investor arranges an overdraft facility with the bank and proceeds to draw down on that facility.   The investor (through an attorney) buys properties in Auckland and secures repayment of the loans with mortgages.  He becomes unable to keep up loan payments.  The bank exercises its power of sale over the two properties. After crediting of the proceeds of sale, there is still $223,951.01 owing overall on the loans.   The bank demands

payment. The investor does not pay. The bank issues this proceeding.

ANZ NATIONAL BANK LIMITED V TING HC AK CIV-2011-404-007769 [31 October 2012]

[2]      Dates in the sequence of events were:

20 May 2011 – issue of Property Law Act 2007 notice

August/September 2011 – sale of the two properties

17 October 2011 – bank’s demand before proceeding

1 December 2011 – proceeding issued

[3]      The  bank’s  legal  executive,  in  an  affidavit  in  support  of  the  summary judgment application, deposes that the defendant has not provided any reason to the bank that would give him a defence to the bank’s claim.  There is no challenge to that evidence in the evidence for the defendant.  The defendant does not suggest that he raised any issue with the bank either immediately following his defaults in mid-

2010 or following the 20 May 2011 Property Law Act notice down to when his notice of opposition was filed (after substituted service) in June 2012.

[4]      Rhonda Graham, a partner of the bank’s solicitor’s law firm, deposes that on

19 August 2011 she had a telephone call from a male who said he was an interpreter and a friend of one Mr Lin who had placed a caveat over the two property titles.  In the course of the conversation, the caller was clearly seeking to avert the bank’s pending (the next week) mortgagee auction.  After discussions about the caveat, the caller asserted that the situation was:

... the Bank’s fault because Mr Ting had had finance to build and when the

“GFC” happened, his finance was withdrawn.

[5]      Ms Graham indicated to the caller that she did not understand what he meant and asked if he was talking about the National Bank, to which the caller replied:

Maybe, maybe Westpac.

[6]      Ms  Graham  repeatedly  in  the  conversation  asserted  the  bank’s  right  to

proceed and advised the caller to get legal advice.  She did not hear from the caller

again.  Neither Mr Ting nor his attorney subsequently contacted the bank about the subject matter of the telephone call.  As I have said, Mr Ting’s first raising of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ANZ National Bank Limited v Ting and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2860
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In ANZ National Bank Limited v Ting, the High Court of New Zealand considered a summary judgment application brought by the ANZ National Bank against Tai Ting. The bank sought repayment of two loans totaling $336,000, which were secured by mortgages over two properties in Auckland. After the bank exercised its power of sale over the properties following Ting's defaults, there remained an outstanding balance of $223,951.01. Ting did not dispute the existence of the debt or the calculations but raised several defences, including breach of duty in exercising the power of sale, breach of the Fair Trading Act, mistake, and dishonest assistance in a breach of trust. The court dismissed these defences as they were either not supported by evidence or were legally untenable. Ting's principal defence was equitable estoppel, alleging that the bank had promised to lend him further monies to build homes on the properties, which he relied upon when taking out the loans. The court found that Ting's reliance on the alleged promise was unreasonable due to language barriers and the lack of any written confirmation. Additionally, the court found that the promise, if it existed, was not unequivocal and could not be relied upon indefinitely. Given the absence of any credible defence, the court granted the bank's summary judgment application, ordering Ting to pay the outstanding debt plus interest and costs.