Annex Developments Limited v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2016-409-000847 [2017] NZHC 706

BETWEEN

ANNEX DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED First Defendant

AND

PETER J TAYLOR & ASSOCIATES LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 28 March 2017

Appearances:

S D Munro and A L Davidson for Plaintiff
C J Hlavac for First Defendant
K A Muir for Second Defendant

Judgment:

11 April 2017

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

Introduction

[1]      The  plaintiff, Annex  Developments  Limited  (Annex)  owns  a  property  in Woolston, Christchurch.   Prior to the sequence of earthquakes which struck the Canterbury region in 2010 there were numerous buildings on the site, let to some 50 tenants.   Some of the buildings were up to 120 years old, though some had been constructed more recently.   Significant damage was caused by the earthquake sequence,  and particularly by the substantial earthquakes on 4 September 2010,

26 December 2010, 22 February 2011 and 13 June 2011.

[2]      Annex held insurance cover on the buildings with the first defendant, IAG New Zealand Limited (IAG), which it had arranged through its broker the second

defendant,  Peter  Taylor  & Associates  Limited  (Peter  Taylor).    IAG  had  issued

ANNEX DEVELOPMENTS LTD v IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD and ANOR [2017] NZHC 706 [11 April 2017]

policies for material damage (MD) to the property, and for business interruption (BI). Both policies had been renewed on 29 July 2010 and provided cover for a one year period to 29 July 2011.

[3]      Annex made claims under the MD policy in respect of damage incurred as a result of the earthquakes on each of the above dates.  Annex carried out temporary and emergency repairs to some of the buildings and lodged interim claims.  The sum of $170,388.05, was paid by IAG.   A further claim for temporary or emergency repairs carried out after the 22 February 2011 earthquake for the sum of $145,696.19 was made in June 2011, but was not paid at the time.

[4]      A claim  under  the  BI  policy  for  loss  of  rent  was  made  in  the  sum  of

$59,358.12, and paid by IAG.  A further claim for $394,030.17 was made but not paid before the parties entered a settlement agreement.

[5]      In February 2012 settlement was reached between Annex and IAG.   This provided for a cash payment to Annex of $9,430,000 in full settlement and by way of discharge of all claims to the date of settlement under both the MD and BI policies, in respect of loss or damage by earthquake events up to the date of settlement.  In the release  document  Annex  acknowledged  receipt  of  progress  payments  totalling

$229,746.35.   It is accepted that this figure represents the two progress payments referred to above, though they do not add to precisely this sum.   Payment of the settlement sum was made on 8 February 2012.

Summary of Annex’s claim in this proceeding

[6]      Annex seeks an order under the Contractual Mistakes Act 1977.  It says that the settlement agreement was entered under a mutual mistake about the extent of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Annex Developments Limited v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 706
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Annex Developments Limited brought a claim against IAG New Zealand Limited for relief under the Contractual Mistakes Act 1977. The claim arose out of a settlement agreement reached between the parties in February 2012, which settled all claims arising out of earthquake damage to Annex’s property. Annex sought to set aside the settlement on the basis that it had been entered into under a mutual mistake as to the extent of cover under the insurance policies. The claim was dismissed.Annex contended that when it entered into the settlement agreement with IAG it was under a mistaken belief that the maximum sum IAG could be liable for under the policies was the amount stated in the policy schedule. Annex maintained that had it known the true extent of cover under the policies it would have negotiated for a settlement sum materially higher than the sum it received. The true extent of cover, according to Annex, was the sum insured in the policy schedule plus certain payments which were not made by IAG. IAG contended that its obligation under the policies was to reinstate the maximum sum insured on the basis of payments which were made, not those which were not made, and that the settlement agreement was reached on the basis that the maximum sum insured had been reinstated by the payments which were made. The Court found that the policy did not provide that the maximum sum insured was reinstated when an interim payment ought to have been made, but was not. Accordingly, the settlement agreement was reached on the basis that the payments which were made were in addition to the maximum sum insured. The settlement sum of $9,430,000 was in addition to the payments made by IAG. Therefore, there was no substantially unequal exchange of values. Summary judgment was entered in favour of IAG.