AN v Counties Manukau District Health Board

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF NAME OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF THE APPLICANT.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA133/2016
[2016] NZCA 226

BETWEEN

AN
Applicant

AND

COUNTIES MANUKAU DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD
Respondent

Hearing:

16 May 2016

Court:

Randerson, Miller and Winkelmann JJ

Counsel:

DN (on behalf of Applicant)
H H Ifwersen for Respondent

Judgment:

25 May 2016 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application to strike out the appeal is granted.

BThe applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application          for leave to appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

CThe Registrar must refund the applicant’s payment of the filing fee and          security for costs, subject to deductions for the costs order.

D        Order prohibiting publication of the name or identifying particulars of          the applicant. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Miller J)

  1. The respondent, Counties Manukau District Health Board (the DHB), moves to strike out this appeal, which is brought by DN on behalf of his wife AN, for whom he holds an enduring power of attorney, against a High Court judgment refusing a writ of habeas corpus.[1]

  2. AN suffers from dementia and she is detained in a secured dementia unit at a private rest home in Auckland.  Her detention was authorised pursuant to interim orders made on 22 February 2016 by the District Court under the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988 (PPPR Act) following an urgent hearing.  AN was represented in the District Court by an experienced barrister and solicitor.  DN opposed the order and his daughter supported it. 

  3. Reasons were given on 10 March 2016.  They record, among other things, concerns about the quality of care that DN provided for his wife at home and difficulties experienced by hospital staff in dealing with him.  The Court directed that a further hearing be held in July or August 2016 with benefit of further evidence.

  4. A right of appeal lies against the order made by the District Court, but that right must be exercised in the High Court;[2]  this Court has no jurisdiction to hear an appeal direct from the District Court’s PPPR Act decision.  DN did not appeal.  Instead he applied to the High Court for a writ of habeas corpus.

    [2]Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988, s 83.

  5. The High Court dismissed DN’s application on the ground that AN is detained pursuant to a regular order of the District Court and habeas corpus is not the appropriate procedure for deciding complaints about her detention.[3] 

    [3]HC decision, above n 1, at [41]–[49].

  6. DN filed a notice of appeal on 16 March 2016 in this Court against the High Court decision to deny habeas corpus.  In a minute issued on 17 March 2016 Wild J explained to DN that he was seeking to challenge the merits of a lawful order made under the PPPR Act and, as Thomas…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AN v Counties Manukau District Health Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of AN v Counties Manukau District Health Board concerns an appeal against a High Court judgment which refused a writ of habeas corpus. The applicant, DN, who holds an enduring power of attorney for his wife AN, who suffers from dementia, seeks to challenge the legality of her detention in a secured dementia unit at a private rest home in Auckland. The Court of Appeal was asked to strike out the appeal as it was brought against the High Court decision, rather than the District Court decision which authorised AN's detention. The appeal was found to be an attempt to review the District Court order, which this Court lacks jurisdiction to hear. The issues raised by the appeal were not susceptible to summary determination and required a full hearing.

The Court of Appeal held that the appeal should be struck out as it was an attempt to review the District Court order, which this Court lacks jurisdiction to hear. The issues raised by the appeal were not susceptible to summary determination and required a full hearing. The writ of habeas corpus cannot be pleaded for the collateral purpose of challenging complex administrative law issues. The Court of Appeal also found that DN had persisted in pursuing the appeal despite being made aware of its futility. Therefore, the appeal was struck out and DN was ordered to pay the respondent costs for a standard application for leave to appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

The Court of Appeal granted the application to strike out the appeal and ordered DN to pay the respondent costs for a standard application for leave to appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements. The Court also ordered the Registrar to refund the applicant's payment of the filing fee and security for costs, subject to deductions for the costs order. The Court maintained the suppression of AN's name to protect her privacy interests and ordered that the publication of the name or identifying particulars of the applicant is prohibited.

This case highlights the importance of understanding the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal and the appropriate avenues for challenging a decision. It also underscores the need for parties to focus their energies on the pending merits hearing in the District Court, rather than pursuing a futile appeal. The Court of Appeal's decision to strike out the appeal and order costs demonstrates the Court's commitment to ensuring that its resources are not wasted on baseless appeals.

Background

Background to the litigation

AN is a woman suffering from dementia who is detained in a secured dementia unit at a private rest home in Auckland. Her detention was authorised by interim orders made by the District Court under the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988 (PPPR Act) following an urgent hearing on 22 February 2016. DN, who holds an enduring power of attorney for AN, opposed the order in the District Court, where AN was represented by an experienced barrister and solicitor. Reasons for the District Court's decision were given on 10 March 2016, and a further hearing was directed to be held in July or August 2016 with benefit of further evidence. DN did not appeal the District Court order but instead applied to the High Court for a writ of habeas corpus, which was dismissed on the ground that AN is detained pursuant to a regular order of the District Court and habeas corpus is not the appropriate procedure for deciding complaints about her detention.

DN filed a notice of appeal on 16 March 2016 in the Court of Appeal against the High Court decision to deny habeas corpus. In a minute issued on 17 March 2016 Wild J explained to DN that he was seeking to challenge the merits of a lawful order made under the PPPR Act and, as Thomas J noted in the High Court, should do so by an application for review under s 86 of that Act or an appeal under s 83 or an application to the High Court for judicial review. He advised that an appeal to the Court of Appeal against the habeas corpus judgment was bound to fail because the PPPR Act order is regular on its face. DN filed a second notice of appeal on 24 March, alleging that the High Court "validated" the District Court decision and including complaints about AN's representation in the District Court, complaints that her medical practitioner refuses to stand down despite DN's allegations against him, an allegation that the rest home lacks the capacity to care properly for her, and general allegations of failures of process and conflicts of interest. The respondent, Counties Manukau District Health Board, moved to strike out the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court of Appeal have jurisdiction to hear an appeal against the District Court order made under the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988?
2. Are the issues raised by the appeal properly susceptible to fair and sensible summary determination?
3. Does the District Court order specify the jurisdiction under which it was made, and is the order authorised by the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988?
4. Are the costs awarded to the respondent appropriate, and should they be on a standard or indemnity basis?
5. Should the publication of the name or identifying particulars of the applicant be prohibited to protect the privacy interests of the applicant?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal has no jurisdiction to hear an appeal against the District Court order made under the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988.
2. The issues raised by the appeal are not susceptible to fair and sensible summary determination.
3. The District Court order specifies the jurisdiction under which it was made and is authorised by the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988.
4. The costs awarded to the respondent are appropriate and should be on a standard basis.
5. The publication of the name or identifying particulars of the applicant is prohibited to protect the privacy interests of the applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal granted the application to strike out the appeal and concluded that it had no jurisdiction to hear an appeal against the District Court order under the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act 1988. The Court noted that the right of appeal from a District Court order under this Act must be exercised in the High Court. The Court also found that the issues raised by the appeal were not susceptible to summary determination and required a full hearing. The Court held that the District Court order specified the jurisdiction under which it was made and was authorised by the Act. The Court awarded costs to the respondent on a standard basis and found that the publication of the name or identifying particulars of the applicant should be prohibited to protect the privacy interests of the applicant.

The Court of Appeal found that the appeal was in substance an attempt to review the District Court order, which the Court lacked jurisdiction to hear. The Court noted that the issues raised by the appeal were important and contested factual issues that could only be determined after hearing witnesses both lay and expert. The Court also found that the District Court order was regular on its face and specified the jurisdiction under which it was made. The Court held that the issues raised by the appeal were not susceptible to summary determination and required a full hearing. The Court also noted that the appeal had no prospects of success and that the applicant would be better to focus on the pending merits hearing in the District Court.

The Court of Appeal awarded costs to the respondent on a standard basis, reflecting the jurisdictional nature of the proceedings. The Court found that the applicant's persistence in pursuing the appeal justified an award of costs. The Court also found that the publication of the name or identifying particulars of the applicant should be prohibited to protect her privacy interests. The Court noted that the applicant was a vulnerable person for purposes of the Family Courts Act and the Protection of Personal and Property Rights Act. The Court held that the suppression of the applicant's name was necessary to protect her privacy interests.