Aldrie Holdings Ltd v Clover Bay Park Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2014-404-99 [2016] NZHC 1482

BETWEEN

ALDRIE HOLDINGS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

CLOVER BAY PARK LIMITED First Defendant

ROGER WAYNE PROUT and SHERRELL ANNE PROUT as trustees of CLOVER BAY TRUST

Second Defendants

ROGER WAYNE PROUT Third Defendant

Hearing: 25 May 2016

Counsel:

S B W Foote and A H H Choi for Plaintiff
D J Clark and J S Clark for Defendants

Judgment:

1 July 2016

JUDGMENT (NO. 2) OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 1 July 2016 at 3.00pm pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Bell & Graham, Matamata Wilson McKay, Auckland Counsel:

S W B Foote, Auckland

ALDRIE HOLDINGS LIMITED v CLOVER BAY PARK LIMITED [2016] NZHC 1482 [1 July 2016]

CONTENTS

Background  [1] The High Court costs’ regime  [3] Which party was successful?  [6] The primary issue  [10] Calderbank principles  [14] Calderbank offer: competing submissions  [26] Calderbank offer:  analysis  [28] Remaining issues

(a)      Introduction  [42]

(b)      Claims for procedural steps on a 2B basis  [45] (c)      Court fees  [53] (d)      Expert fees and witness expenses  [57] (e)      Non-party discovery costs  [63] (f)       Disbursements  [66] Costs on the costs’ application  [68] Result  [71]

Background

[1]      On 24 February 2016, I gave judgment on claims brought by Aldrie Holdings Ltd (Aldrie) against Clover Bay Park Ltd (Clover Bay), the trustees of Clover Bay Trust and Mr Roger Prout (together, the Clover Bay interests), as well as counterclaims brought by those defendants against Aldrie.1     I found in favour of Aldrie on its claim under the Fair Trading Act 1986.  I assessed its loss, based on a difference in value between true market value and what Aldrie paid for the farm, at

$500,000.  I declined to award damages for any consequential losses.  Judgment was entered in favour of Aldrie against Clover Bay and Mr Prout (jointly and severally) in the sum of $250,000, together with interest.2   The difference between the proved loss of $500,000 and the amount awarded resulted from conduct on the part of Aldrie’s director, Ms Laboyrie, whom I regarded, “to a large extent, … [as] the author of Aldrie’s financial misfortune”.3   Aldrie’s claim against the Trust failed, as

did all counterclaims.4

1      Aldrie Holdings Ltd v Clover Bay Park Ltd [2016] NZHC 250.

2      Although the Trust was successful, for convenience I use the expression “Clover Bay interests”

to reflect the parties against whom costs are sought; namely, Clover Bay and Mr Prout.

3      Aldrie Holdings Ltd v Clover Bay Park Ltd [2016] NZHC 250 at paras [79]–[89; in particular para [87].

4 Ibid, at para [112].

[2]      Costs were reserved.   I had been informed that there was relevant pre-trial correspondence  to  which  I would  need  to  refer.    I heard  oral  argument  on  all questions of costs on 25 May 2016.

The High Court costs’ regime

[3]      The nature of this Court’s discretion on questions of High Court costs is set out r 14.1 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aldrie Holdings Ltd v Clover Bay Park Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1482
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was tasked with determining the costs associated with a proceeding between Aldrie Holdings Ltd (Aldrie) and Clover Bay Park Ltd (Clover Bay) and related parties. Aldrie had initially succeeded on a claim under the Fair Trading Act 1986, but failed on other claims. The court had to decide on the allocation of costs, including whether Aldrie was entitled to an uplift in costs due to a rejected Calderbank offer, and the costs associated with various procedural steps taken during the litigation. The court found that while Aldrie was the successful party overall, the rejection of the Calderbank offer was not unreasonable, and thus no uplift in costs was warranted. The court also assessed and adjusted various costs claimed by Aldrie, disallowing certain costs deemed unnecessary or unreasonable. Ultimately, the court ordered that Clover Bay and Mr Prout pay Aldrie costs and disbursements totaling $138,951.93, which included 2B scale costs, court fees, expert fees and witness expenses, and disbursements, after making several reductions and disallowances.