Alderton v Sixty-Six Auckland Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2023-404-137 [2024] NZHC 2263
IN THE MATTER OF 199-201 Anzac Valley Road, Waitakere, Auckland

BETWEEN

PETER and LINDA ALDERTON as trustees of the PETER ALDERTON FAMILY

TRUST

Applicants

AND

SIXTY-SIX AUCKLAND LIMITED

First Respondent

DOKAD TRUSTEES LIMITED and PETER WILLIAM MAWHINNEY

Second Respondents

Hearing: 21 September 2023 plus material filed in October and November 2023 (including an application to adduce further evidence) and further material filed in May and June 2024

Appearances:

A Low for the Applicants

P W Mawhinney, the second-named second respondent, in person No appearance by or for the other respondents

Judgment:

13 August 2024


JUDGMENT OF GAULT J


This judgment was delivered by me on 13 August 2024 at 11.30am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………………

Solicitors / Counsel:

Ms AAH Low, Barrister, Auckland

Mr K Mackie (applicants’ instructing solicitor), Mackie and Co., Auckland The Respondents

ALDERTON v SIXTY-SIX AUCKLAND LTD [2024] NZHC 2263 [13 August 2024]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction  [1]
Post-hearing developments  [7]

Factual background  [15]

Scope of originating application  [29]

Application to adduce further evidence  [30]

Section 339 – legal principles  [35]

Analysis  [39]

Co-owners

The extent of the share in the property of any co-owner by whom, or in respect of whose estate or interest, the application for the order is made  [42]

The nature and location of the property  [44]

The number of other co-owners and the extent of their shares  [46]

The hardship that would be caused to the applicant by the refusal of the order,

in comparison with the hardship that would be caused to any other person by the making of the order  [47]

The value of any contribution made by any co-owner to the cost of improvements to, or the maintenance of, the property  [73]

Any other matters the Court considers relevant  [74]

Conclusion  [83]

Compensation  [84]

Result  [88]

Costs  [89]

Introduction

[1]    By originating application,1 Mr and Mrs Alderton (the Aldertons) as trustees of the Peter Alderton Family Trust (PAFT) seek orders under s 339 of the Property Law Act 2007 (PLA), primarily requiring them to acquire the respondents’ 1/10 interest in a property on Anzac Valley Road, Waitākere (the property).

[2]    The Aldertons say that in 1997, before the parties agreed to share ownership in the property they were purchasing, Mr Mawhinney (the second-named second respondent) said he would transfer the 1/10 interest to them without payment once an access issue had been resolved. In 1997, access over the forestry road on the property was needed by Mr Mawhinney’s interests to develop two other lots. Neither lot now exists as it did in 1997, and by 2017 Mr Mawhinney’s interests no longer owned any neighbouring land.

[3]    The primary ground of opposition was that acquisition of the 1/10 share would cause hardship because access to other land up the forestry road remains a live issue given   the   Mawhinney   interests’  other…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alderton v Sixty-Six Auckland Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 2263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Alderton v Sixty-Six Auckland Limited involved an application by Peter and Linda Alderton, trustees of the Peter Alderton Family Trust, to compel the sale of a 1/10 share in a property in Anzac Valley Road, Waitākere, Auckland, to them. The respondents were Sixty-Six Auckland Limited and Peter William Mawhinney, who held the 1/10 share as trustees. The court was required to decide whether the application should be granted under section 339 of the Property Law Act 2007, considering various factors such as the extent of the shares, nature and location of the property, and the hardship caused to each party if the order was made or not made. The court also had to address whether further evidence presented post-hearing should be admitted.

The court found that the property in question was owned by co-owners and that the Aldertons had a significantly larger share (9/10) compared to the respondents (1/10). The court concluded that the Aldertons would suffer considerable hardship if the order was not granted, as they were unable to make necessary improvements to the property without the consent of the co-owners, and there was no immediate intention to sell but concerns about the impact of the co-owners' share on future sale value. Conversely, the court found that the hardship claimed by the respondents was not sufficient to outweigh that of the Aldertons. The court also rejected the respondents' arguments relating to subdivision consents and forestry rights as not pertinent to the application. The court ordered the sale of the 1/10 share to the Aldertons for $10,000, considering the benefit of removing the "blot" on their title and set costs against the respondents jointly and severally.