Adams v Touchtwo Ltd HC Auckland CIV 2009-404-5274

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2009-404-5274

BETWEEN  COLIN DENNIS ADAMS  and

RICHARD NEIL ADAMS and the

E W PARKER TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED

Plaintiffs

ANDTOUCHTWO LIMITED First Defendant

ANDLOUIS PHILIP JONES Second Defendant

ANDJULIE CLAIRE CHRISTIE Third Defendant

ANDBFS AUCKLAND LIMITED Fourth Defendant

ANDHOWARD STANLEY MOORE Fifth Defendant

ANDGILLIAN PATRICIA MOORE Sixth Defendant

ANDCAROLINE ROSER CHAPMAN Seventh Defendant

Hearing:         25 March 2010

Counsel:         G P Blanchard and P A Chambers for Plaintiffs

T J Cooley for First to Third Defendants
No appearance for Fourth to Seventh Defendants

Judgment:      7 May 2010 at 4:30pm

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF HUGH WILLIAMS J.

COLIN DENNIS ADAMS AND RICHARD NEIL ADAMS AND THE E W PARKER TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED V TOUCHTWO LIMITED AND ORS HC AK CIV-2009-404-5274  7 May 2010

This judgment was delivered by The Hon. Justice Hugh Williams on

7 May 2010 at 4:30pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

……………………………………………..

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

AThe lease in question having been surrendered by operation of law, the plaintiffs’ application for summary judgment against the First to Third defendants, and the First to Third defendants’ application for summary judgment against the plaintiffs are both dismissed for the reasons set out in this Judgment.

B        Costs are to lie where they fall.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Paragraph

Introduction  [1] Facts:  [4] (1) Lease and Assignments  [4]

(2) Defaults, Further Assignment, Termination                   [13]

(3) Evidence  [16] Submissions:

(1) Plaintiff’s surrender by operation of law  [25]

(2) Express or Implied Agreement  [26] (3) Estoppel by Convention  [28] (4) Contractual Mistakes Act 1977  [31] (5) Failure to Mitigate/Unreasonable Refusal to Assign      [32] (6) Touchtwo Defendants  [37] (7) Plaintiffs’ Reply  [44]

Discussion and Decision:

(1)  Surrender by operation of law and Re-grant of the

Lease of 7 December 1999  [45] (2)  Contractual Mistakes Act 1977  [84] (3) Express or Implied Agreements/Estoppel by Convention [91] (4) Unreasonable Refusal of Consent to Assignment/

Mitigation of Loss  [97] Quantum of Claim  [101]

Result  [104]

Introduction

[1]      In this proceeding the plaintiffs, the Trustees of the C R Adams Trust, seek summary judgment against the First-Third Defendants (“the Touchtwo defendants”) for $431,929.19, the sum which the plaintiffs say is owing under a lease dated

7 December 1999 and the Touchtwo defendants seek summary judgment against the Adams Trust on the basis that none of the causes of action in the claim against them can succeed.

[2]      The pivotal question on which both applications depend is whether the lease has been surrendered by operation of law. Broadly put, if it has, then the Adams Trusts  cannot  obtain  summary  judgment.     If  it  has  not,  then  the  Touchtwo defendants’  application  to  strike  out  the  relevant  portions  of  the  claim  cannot succeed.

[3]      It was said by counsel that the point in issue appears not to be the subject of any directly applicable precedent in this country.

Facts:

(1)    Lease and Assignments

[4]      The central facts are straightforward.

[5]      The Adams Trust has at all material times been the registered proprietor of the property…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adams v Touchtwo Ltd HC Auckland CIV 2009-404-5274 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 873
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a dispute between the plaintiffs, the Trustees of the C R Adams Trust, and the first to third defendants, Touchtwo Limited and others, over a lease of property at 144 Parnell Road, Auckland. The plaintiffs seek summary judgment against the Touchtwo defendants for $431,929.19, the sum they claim is owing under a lease dated 7 December 1999, while the Touchtwo defendants seek summary judgment against the plaintiffs on the basis that none of the causes of action in the claim against them can succeed. The pivotal issue before the court was whether the lease had been surrendered by operation of law. The court found that the lease had been surrendered by operation of law when the term was extended beyond the original expiry date, resulting in a re-grant of a new lease. Consequently, the Touchtwo defendants could not be held liable for any breaches of the lease after the extension date. The court also noted that New Zealand law does not follow the English approach to this issue, as reflected in the Property Law Act 2007. As a result, the plaintiffs' application for summary judgment against the Touchtwo defendants, and the Touchtwo defendants' application for summary judgment against the plaintiffs, were both dismissed. Costs were to lie where they fell. The case was to be listed for mention in the Duty Judge's list on 9 June 2010 to make appropriate orders for the future conduct of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established