IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CIV-2011-485-2486 [2012] NZHC 2615
UNDER the Resource Management Act 1991
IN THE MATTER OF an appeal from the Environment Court
BETWEEN ACTION FOR ENVIRONMENT INCORPORATED
Appellant
ANDWELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL First Respondent
ANDWELLINGTON BADMINTON ASSOCIATION INCORPORATED Second Respondent
Hearing: On the papers
Judgment: 9 October 2012
COSTS JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J
[1] On 13 July 2012 I issued a judgment dismissing an appeal by Action for Environment Incorporated (“AfE”) against a decision of the Environment Court granting a resource consent to the second respondent Wellington Badminton Association Incorporated (“Wellington Badminton”) to extend its facility known as Badminton Hall located on Town Belt land in the Wellington suburb of Hataitai. I reserved the question of costs. The first respondent, Wellington City Council (“the Council”) and Wellington Badminton, now apply for costs against AfE.
[2] The general position is clear. The party who fails with respect to a proceeding or an interlocutory application should pay costs to the party who
ACTION FOR ENVIRONMENT INCORPORATED V WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL (Costs) HC WN CIV-
2011-485-2486 [9 October 2012]
succeeds. As the successful parties, the Council and Wellington Badminton ask for costs of $5,452 and $4,512 respectively from AfE.
[3] AfE argues that no costs should be awarded against it, essentially on the ground that it is a public interest group and that it brought its appeal as a matter of public interest. In that, AfE relies on r 14.7(e) of the High Court Rules. That rule provides that this Court may refuse to make an order for, or may reduce, costs otherwise payable under the High Court Rules if “the proceeding concerned a matter of public interest, and the party opposing costs acted reasonably in the conduct of the proceeding”. Each of the parties referred me to the decision of Gibbs v New
Plymouth DC (No 2).[1] There Justice Heath helpfully reviewed both the general
principles as regards to costs and the more specific principles relating to increased and indemnity costs and the “public interest” ground on which costs otherwise payable may be reduced or refused. The following statement of principle, referred to by Justice Heath, appears applicable:[2]
There remains the question of costs. Although the appeal is to be dismissed, the appellants were not bringing the proceedings out of any motive of personal gain. They were pursuing the proceedings in the interest of taonga which is an important part of the heritage of New Zealand. Because of the different views expressed by the members of the Court of Appeal on the issues raised on this appeal, an undesirable lack of clarity inevitably existed in an important area of the law which it was important that their Lordships examine and in the circumstances Their Lordships regard it as just that there should be no order as to the costs on this appeal.
[1] Gibbs v New Plymouth DC (No 2) HC New Plymouth CIV-2004-443-115, 5 October 2006.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Action for Environment Incorporated v Wellington City Counci... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NZHC 2615
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case involved the principles governing costs in litigation, particularly in cases where the proceedings concern a matter of public interest. The Court needed to determine whether Action for Environment Incorporated, as a public interest group, was entitled to a reduction or refusal of costs under High Court Rules 14.7(e). The Court also needed to consider whether the way in which Action for Environment Incorporated conducted its appeal justified a reduction or refusal of costs.
In reaching its decision, the Court considered the nature of the public interest represented by Action for Environment Incorporated and the way in which the appeal was conducted. The Court concluded that Action for Environment Incorporated did represent a public interest, and its appeal, while broad, was not unreasonable given the complexity of the legal history of Town Belt land. However, the Court found that it would not be fair for Wellington Badminton Association Incorporated, which also represented a public interest, to not receive scale costs from Action for Environment Incorporated. The Court therefore ordered that scale costs of $4,512 be paid by Action for Environment Incorporated to Wellington Badminton Association Incorporated.
The final orders of the Court were that no costs be ordered against Action for Environment Incorporated by Wellington City Council, but that scale costs of $4,512 be paid by Action for Environment Incorporated to Wellington Badminton Association Incorporated.