ABC v Complaints Assessment Committee

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

ORDER PERMANENTLY PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF NAMES, ADDRESS OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF APPELLANT.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-409-000992 [2012] NZHC 1901

BETWEEN  ABC Appellant

ANDCOMPLAINTS ASSESSMENT COMMITTEE

Respondent

Hearing:         12 June 2012

Appearances: A H Waalkens QC for Appellant

C J Lange for Respondent

Judgment:      1 August 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF CHISHOLM J

A        The appeal is allowed.

BThe order for permanent suppression of the appellant’s name made by the Disciplinary Tribunal is reinstated.

REASONS

ABC V COMPLAINTS ASSESSMENT COMMITTEE HC CHCH CIV-2011-409-000992 [1 August 2012]

Introduction

[1]      Having  been  found  guilty  of  disgraceful  conduct  under  the  Medical Practitioners Act 19951 by the Medical Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, Dr ABC was censured and ordered to pay a fine and costs.   The Tribunal also imposed conditions as to his practice.  His name was permanently suppressed.

[2]      The Complaints Assessment Committee then appealed to the District Court against the Tribunal’s failure to remove Dr ABC’s name from the register or to suspend him.    It  also  appealed  against  the  order for name suppression.    Judge Doherty dismissed the appeal against sentence but allowed the appeal against name suppression and set aside the Tribunal’s suppression order.

[3]      Dr  ABC  now  appeals  to  this  Court  pursuant  to  s  121  of  the  Medical Practitioners Act against the decision setting aside the Tribunal’s order for name suppression.  This appeal is confined to questions of law and six questions of law have been stated for the opinion of this Court.

Background

[4]      The Disciplinary Tribunal found that on two occasions during 1985 Dr ABC had sexual intercourse with the complainant who was then aged 16 years.  At the time Dr ABC was in his early thirties.  Despite the doctor’s denial, the Tribunal also found that the complainant was one of his patients at the relevant time.

[5]      A complaint was not made to the Health and Disability Commissioner until

2001, which was about 16 years after the conduct giving rise to the charge had occurred.   Although  the  appellant  was  charged  in  2002,  the  hearing  before  the Tribunal did not commence until late 2009 because of what the Judge aptly described as “interlocutory warfare”.

[6]      Having delivered a substantive decision in which it found that the charge against the appellant had been proved, the Tribunal then conducted a further hearing

1 Now replaced by the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003.

concerning penalty and name suppression.   Its decision on those matters was delivered on 1 October 2010.

[7]      When granting permanent name suppression the Tribunal took into account: the passage of time (25 years) since the conduct had occurred; absence of any complaints  during  that  period  (or  earlier);  the  conduct  was  “entirely”  out  of character; potential harm to the appellant’s practice which involved a number of other  partners;  potential  harm  to  his  wife  and  children;  implications  for  the appellant’s rehabilitation if his name was published; and the absence of any evidence that other medical practitioners would necessarily be impugned if the appellant’s name was not published.

[8]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABC v Complaints Assessment Committee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1901
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ABC, a medical practitioner, was found guilty of disgraceful conduct by the Medical Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, which resulted in a censure, a fine, and costs. The Tribunal also imposed conditions on ABC's practice and ordered the permanent suppression of his name. The Complaints Assessment Committee appealed against the Tribunal's failure to remove ABC's name from the register or to suspend him, as well as the order for name suppression. The District Court dismissed the appeal against sentence but allowed the appeal against name suppression and set aside the Tribunal's suppression order. ABC appealed to the High Court against the decision setting aside the Tribunal's order for name suppression. The appeal was allowed, and the order for permanent suppression of ABC's name was reinstated.

The High Court found that the District Court erred in law when it applied the statutory test pursuant to s 106(2) of the Act, which requires the order of permanent name suppression sought to be "desirable". The District Court had not properly considered the impact of publication on ABC's family and medical practice, as well as the tension between publication and the efficacy of orders made for the purpose of rehabilitation. The High Court held that the Tribunal correctly exercised its discretion to order permanent suppression of ABC's name, taking into account the interests of any person and the public interest, and that the appeal was allowed.