AAM Limited v Exotica Enterprise Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2016-404-2850 [2018] NZHC 1399

BETWEEN

AAM LIMITED

Plaintiff

MUMTAJ YUNUS AGARBATTIWALA
Second Plaintiff

AND

EXOTICA ENTERPRISE LIMITED

First Defendant

DARIUS KARANI
Second Defendant

MANUKA MASTERS LIMITED

Third Defendant

Hearing: on the papers

Counsel:

Second Plaintiff in person

Judgment:

13 June 2018


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH


[1]        The second plaintiff applies without notice for an order directing that she be permitted to represent the first plaintiff (AAM) in this proceeding.

[2]        The plaintiffs were originally represented by Mr Vincent Naidu of Vinci Law, Auckland, but on 21 March 2018 the second plaintiff caused a memorandum to be filed stating that the plaintiffs were now acting in person.

AAM LTD v EXOTICA ENTERPRISE LTD [2018] NZHC 1399 [13 June 2018]

[3]        The case was called before me in the chambers list on 27 March 2018, and I advised the second plaintiff that, while she may represent herself as second plaintiff, she is not entitled to appear or file documents on behalf of AAM, which is a limited liability company.

[4]        A fixture was made for the hearing of an application by the defendants for further discovery, further particulars of the plaintiffs' statement of claim, and security for costs, and those applications were heard by Associate Judge Bell on 16 April 2018.

[5]        In the meantime, a four-day fixture had been allocated for the trial of the proceeding, commencing on 11 June 2018.

[6]        In an oral judgment given by the Associate Judge on 16 April 2018, the plaintiffs were ordered to give the particulars sought by 28 May 2018. They were also ordered to file and serve an affidavit of documents, disclosing the documents in the schedule to an application the defendants had filed. His Honour vacated the fixture for 11 June 2018, and allocated a new fixture, for five days commencing on 29 April 2019.

[7]On the topic of representation of AAM, Associate Judge Bell said:

[18]A company can appear in the High Court only through counsel.1 On the other hand in the District Court a company may be represented by its directors.2 If the plaintiffs' claims were for $350,000 or less, this case   could   be   transferred   to   the   District   Court   so   that    Ms Agarbattiwala could appear for the company without a lawyer. As I understand the plaintiffs' claims, their losses are said to be more than

$350,000 even though they have not been fully calculated at this stage.

[19]Ms Agarbattiwala says that she has been talking to lawyers with a view to their acting for the plaintiffs. The lawyers made it clear that they would not act if the fixture for 11 June were maintained. They did not consider they would have enough time to prepare. As it happens, I am adjourning the matter but I am not adjourning for that reason. I expect Ms Agarbattiwala to have arranged legal representation for the plaintiffs by 30 April 2018 and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AAM Limited v Exotica Enterprise Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The application was brought by Mumtaj Yunus Agarbattiwala, who sought leave to represent AAM Limited, a family-owned company, in the proceeding. The case was originally filed in March 2016 and involves claims against Exotica Enterprise Limited, Darius Karani, and Manuka Masters Limited. The plaintiffs allege that the defendants engaged in unfair business practices, leading to the failure of AAM and significant financial losses. The defendants have applied for further discovery, particulars, and security for costs.

The legal issues the court had to decide were whether the second plaintiff, Mumtaj Yunus Agarbattiwala, could represent AAM Limited in the proceeding and whether exceptional circumstances existed to justify granting the leave sought. The application was based on the financial difficulties faced by AAM and the argument that allowing Mumtaj to represent the company would not disadvantage the defendants.

The court found that it is a well-established rule that a company has no right to be represented in court except by a practising lawyer. The rationale behind this rule is to ensure that proceedings are appropriately pleaded and managed, and that the company's and shareholders' interests are properly represented. The court has a discretion to allow non-lawyers to appear on behalf of companies in exceptional circumstances, such as when counsel is not available or in straightforward matters where the assistance of counsel is not needed.

However, the court found that the present situation was not an emergency situation, nor could the circumstances be regarded as exceptional. The trial was not scheduled to take place until 29 April 2019, and the fact that AAM could not afford to retain a lawyer was not unusual or exceptional. Granting the application would go beyond the "exceptional circumstances" required to justify departing from the established rule. The court also noted that the case was not simple or lacking in complexity, as it involved 14 causes of action and substantial relief sought, including an injunction and damages.

For these reasons, the application for leave to represent AAM Limited was refused. The court found that the application was based substantially on the financial difficulties of AAM, but that alone was not sufficient to justify granting the leave sought. The court was bound by the decisions of the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court, which had affirmed the general rule that companies are to be represented in the High Court by counsel rather than an officer of the company.