AAI Ltd v 92 Lichfield Street (in req and in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-409-000143 [2016] NZHC 90

BETWEEN

AAI LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

92 LICHFIELD STREET (IN RECEIVERSHIP AND IN LIQUIDATION)

Defendant

CIV-2015-404-001712

BETWEEN  92 LICHFIELD STREET (IN RECEIVERSHIP AND IN LIQUIDATION)

Plaintiff

ANDAAI LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

C Langstone for Plaintiff
S Munro and V Heward for Defendant

Judgment:

5 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J

[1]      On 19 November 2015 the Court of Appeal allowed AAI Limited’s (AAI)

appeal from the judgment of Associate Judge Osborne.1

1      AAI Ltd v 92 Lichfield Ltd (in rec and in liq) [2015] NZHC 1421.

[2]      The Court held that 92 Lichfield Limited’s (Lichfield) use of a statutory demand was an abuse of process and that AAI was entitled to costs.  It referred the matter back to the High Court for costs to be determined.

[3]      On the issue of costs, the Court of Appeal declined to award indemnity or increased costs on the appeal.  However, it considered that issues concerning abuse of process could be considered in the context of the fixing of costs in the High Court.2

[4]      AAI then requested that the costs of all steps taken in the High Court be considered at the same time. Those steps arose in two sets of proceedings being:

(a)      CIV-2015-409-143 (“the statutory demand proceedings”) concerning AAI’s  application  to  set  aside  the  statutory  demand  issued  by Lichfield;

(b)CIV-2014-404-1712 (“the liquidation proceedings”) concerning Lichfield’s   use   of   the   statutory   demand   to   issue   liquidation proceedings against AAI.

[5]      I agreed that it was sensible for all issues of costs in both the statutory demand proceedings and the liquidation proceedings to be dealt with at the same time, and made timetabling directions for the filing of costs memoranda accordingly.

AAI’s costs claim

[6]      AAI claims disbursements of $3,742.20 as set out in schedule B to its costs memorandum.  It also claims legal costs which, calculated on a 2B basis, would be

$25,066.  However, AAI says these do not fairly compensate it for the costs to which it  has  been  put  by the  statutory demand  and  liquidation  proceedings.    It  seeks increased costs of $50,132 (being schedule costs with an uplift of 100 per cent),

along with disbursements, on the following grounds:

2 At [63].

(a)      by knowingly issuing an improper statutory demand Lichfield pursued an   unmeritorious   claim   (and   defence)   within   the   meaning   of High Court rr 14.6(3)(b)(ii) and (d).

(b)Lichfield failed to accept an offer of settlement, without reasonable justification, under High Court r 14.6(3)(iii); and

(c)      Lichfield issued and pursued liquidation proceedings based upon a statutory demand which was found to be improperly issued, particularly when AAI had provided evidence of its solvency and where the full judgment sum had been paid into its solicitor’s trust account.

Relevant background

[7]      It is necessary at the outset to rehearse some of the background to the issuing of the proceedings as it is relevant to the claim by AAI for increased costs.

[8]      In mid 2013, AAI’s loss adjuster…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AAI Ltd v 92 Lichfield Street (in req and in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 90
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, AAI Limited, the plaintiff, sought costs from 92 Lichfield Street, the defendant, in two sets of proceedings: statutory demand proceedings and liquidation proceedings. AAI's claim arose from its successful appeal against a decision by the Court of Appeal that found Lichfield's use of a statutory demand was an abuse of process. The Court of Appeal referred the matter back to the High Court for the fixing of costs. AAI sought a 100 per cent uplift on the 2B costs in both sets of proceedings. It argued that Lichfield had knowingly issued an improper statutory demand, failed to accept an offer of settlement, and pursued liquidation proceedings based upon a statutory demand which was found to be improperly issued. Lichfield opposed the application for increased costs, arguing that AAI's conduct in bringing the subsequent applications could not be ignored and that the Court of Appeal's subsequent finding that the use of the statutory demand procedure was an abuse of process did not support an award for increased costs after the initial judgment. The Court found that Lichfield had knowingly used an improper statutory demand to force payment of the settlement sum and had failed to withdraw it despite being warned of the consequences. AAI was entitled to a 100 per cent uplift on costs incurred on the application to set aside the statutory demand. However, the subsequent applications should not necessarily be seen in the same light as Lichfield had a judgment in its favour at the time. The Court found that costs should lie where they fall for the stay applications. AAI was entitled to costs, again with a 100 per cent uplift, for the three listed steps in the liquidation proceedings. Costs should lie where they fall in respect of the application to correct the error in the judgment. AAI was entitled to costs for preparing the memoranda as to the timing and procedure of dealing with costs in the High Court and for preparing its costs submissions. The total amount awarded was $30,870.20.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established