A v Police HC Dunedin CRI 2010-412-40

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CRI 2010-412-000040

A

Appellant

v

POLICE

Respondent

Hearing:         16 December 2010

Counsel:         S N Claver for Appellant

R D Smith for Respondent

Judgment:      16 December 2010

JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

[1]      This is an appeal against a sentence, on a charge of a common assault, to nine months’ supervision with special conditions that the appellant attend and complete a Pathways for Women programme, and also three months’ community detention with a 7 pm to 7 am curfew each day of the week;  and in respect of two charges of breach of community work, the same sentence as above plus a new sentence of 150 hours.

[2]      The  appeal  is  confined  to  the  imposition  of  three  months’  community detention.    Mr Claver’s argument is that the Judge should have taken into account that the appellant had been subject to a bail curfew of 10 pm to 7 am between

14 June and 8 October, which in itself equates to a community detention sentence of

A V POLICE  HC DUN CRI 2010-412-000040  16 December 2010

some four to five months.   So, logically, it should have been appreciated she had already served the equivalent of a three months’ community detention sentence.  He asked for that part of the sentence to be deleted.

[3]      He relies on s 8(h) of the Sentencing Act 2002 requiring the Court to take into account the particular circumstances of the offender which meant that a sentence which would otherwise be appropriate would be in the particular instance proportionally severe.

[4]      Mr Smith, for the Crown, has helpfully drawn the Court’s attention to a decision:   Winkelmann v R [2010] NZCA 215 in which the Court in a judgment given by William Young P says:

[21]     We recognise that the appellant spent a year on bail and that during this time he was subject to a curfew.  However, time spent on bail before sentence is usually only taken into account where the conditions of bail were very restrictive.  In this case, there was a curfew but not on a 24 hour basis and the resulting regime was not akin to home detention.  We are therefore inclined to view that a particular discount was not required.  In any event, at most only a modest allowance would have been justified.   The restraint demonstrated by the judge’s uplift of only three months for the appellant’s previous serious offending and the generosity of the 20 per cent discount for the plea seem to us to more than compensate for the lack of an explicit allowance  for  this  factor.    In  saying  this  we  note  that  at  [15]  of  the sentencing remarks the Judge did refer to the fact that the appellant had been on bail “on a strict curfew” and that he took this into account.

[5]      This Court is aware that there are occasions, particularly when the bail is equivalent to home detention that that deprivation of liberty is taken into…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A v Police HC Dunedin CRI 2010-412-40 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 2274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this appeal, the appellant contests the imposition of a three-month community detention sentence, arguing that the court should have considered the bail curfew she had already been serving. The case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand, Dunedin Registry, with counsel S N Claver representing the appellant and R D Smith representing the respondent. The appellant was charged with a common assault and two charges of breach of community work, and the contested sentence was to be served concurrently with nine months' supervision and other conditions.

The legal issue at hand was whether the appellant's bail curfew should have been taken into account when imposing the sentence. Counsel for the appellant argued that the curfew should have been considered equivalent to a three-month community detention sentence, and thus should have been factored into the overall sentence. The court considered section 8(h) of the Sentencing Act 2002, which requires the court to take into account the particular circumstances of the offender, making a sentence which would otherwise be appropriate proportionally severe. The court also considered the case of Winkelmann v R, in which the Court of Appeal had ruled that time spent on bail with a curfew was only taken into account where the conditions of bail were very restrictive.

The court found that the appellant's argument was logically sound, but ultimately rejected it, noting that it would represent a significant change in sentencing policy to take into account bail curfews in all cases. The court held that only where the conditions of bail effectively amount to a sentence of home detention would they normally be counted when determining a sentence of imprisonment or home detention. The court found that the curfew in this case had been appropriately applied to avoid offending while on bail, and thus the appeal was dismissed.

No further orders were made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established