ZHQF and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

ZHQF and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 2936 (10 August 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/7378

Re:ZHQF

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndGZHT

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D K Grigg

Date:10 August 2020

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision that during the period of 18 February 2019 to 28 June 2019 the Applicant had 60 per cent care of the child.

...............................[SGD].........................................

Member D K Grigg

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

CATCHWORDS

FAMILY ASSISTANCE – percentage of care –– what is the correct percentage of care - decision under review set aside.

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

CASES

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Norouz and Secretary, Department of Social Services (Social services second review) [2018] AATA 2712
Wade v Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services [2004] FCA 1660

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Family Assistance Guide (2020)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D K Grigg

10 August 2020

INTRODUCTION & CLAIM HISTORY

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of one child born in 2001 (“the Child”).

  2. Between 15 June 2015 and 18 February 2019 the Child Support Agency (“CSA”) determined the Applicant had 100% care of the Child for child support calculation purposes.[1] At all relevant times the Other Party has been paying the Applicant child support on the basis that the Applicant’s care percentage and cost percentage was 100% and the Other Party’s care percentage was 0% at a cost percentage of 0%.[2]

    [1]           Exhibit 1, T Documents, T13 page 82, Child support mainframe screen capture.

    [2]           Exhibit 1, T Documents, T13 page 82, Child support mainframe screen capture.

  3. On 18 February 2019 the Other Party advised the CSA that the care arrangements for the child had changed and that there was no “care” being provided by either parent to the child from 18 February 2019. The CSA notified the Applicant and informed him that the information provided by the Other Party would potentially have an impact on his current assessment. The CSA asked the Applicant to contact them by 9 March 2019.[3]

    [3]           Exhibit 1, T documents, T4, page 42, letter from child support to the applicant dated 23 February 2019.

  4. The Applicant advised the CSA that since the Child had commenced at university, the Applicant:[4]

    (a)was continuing to care for him;

    (b)washed the Child’s clothes and paid for all of his needs;

    (c)drove extensively each week to collect the Child from university to home and back;

    (d)cared for the Child 3-4 nights per week.

    [4]          Exhibit 1, T documents, T14, page 94, CSA Customer Contact Details dated 28 February 2019.

  5. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ZHQF and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 2936
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support assessment, brought by the Applicant against the Child Support Registrar. The central dispute revolved around determining the correct percentage of care for the child during a specific period, which directly impacted the child support assessment. The Tribunal considered the evidence presented by both parties regarding the child's living arrangements and the level of care provided by each parent.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to ascertain the accurate percentage of care each party had for the child during the period from 18 February 2019 to 28 June 2019, in accordance with section 54A of the Assessment Act. This involved evaluating the conflicting evidence regarding the child's overnight stays and the nature of the care provided by each parent, particularly in light of the child's university attendance and scholarship. The Tribunal also had to consider the admissibility and weight of various forms of evidence, including witness statements and documentary evidence, while navigating allegations made by each party against the other.

The Tribunal reasoned that in the absence of extensive corroborating evidence from either party, the determination of care percentage should be based on the number of nights the child spent in each party's care. While acknowledging inconsistencies between the Applicant's calendar and Google Maps data, the Tribunal found them to be approximately 90% consistent. The Tribunal noted that while both parties likely spent money on the child and communicated regularly, precise records were not presented. Crucially, the Tribunal found that the child spent most weekends during the university semester and a study period with the Applicant, leading to the conclusion that the Applicant had 60% care and the Other Party had 0% care during the relevant period.

Consequently, the Tribunal varied the existing care determination of 0% shared care. It made a new determination that the Applicant had a shared care percentage of 60% for the period from 18 February 2019 to 28 June 2019. The decision under review was set aside and substituted to reflect this revised shared care percentage.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant also provided witness statements (in the form of letters) from the Child and a friend of the Child. The Applicant said he wanted the Child to give oral evidence at the hearing. The Tribunal did not allow that to occur. It is not the general practice of the Tribunal to allow children to give evidence in these types of proceedings. The Tribunal considered that it was inappropriate to have the Child give evidence against either parent and that, in this matter, it would have been inappropriate for the Child to have been cross-examined by the Other Party. Further the Tribunal would not find the evidence to be probative given that little weight could be given to the Child’s evidence (given the Child’s lack of independence from either party). The Child also has Asperger’s and the Tribunal was concerned that making him give oral evidence against his mother may have a negative impact on him which outweighs any benefit to the Tribunal. The Other Party confirmed that she had no questions for the Child’s friend so he was not called to give evidence either.The Applicant’s Evidence The Applicant says that during the period in question he was caring for the Child 100% of the time. The Child received a scholarship to attend university. The scholarship money covers the cost of his university fees and means that the Child will not have any HECS debt when he graduates. Terms of the scholarship allowed that part of the scholarship money would be used to pay $6,000 towards accommodation at a College on campus. The University would pay the $19,000 balance for that accommodation. The Child was anxious about starting at University and the Applicant promised the Child “he would be there no matter what, whenever he needed”. The Applicant says he purchased everything the Child required for university and college including a fridge, linen and so on. From the beginning the Child did not like it and the Applicant had to drive to the college on the first night to calm him down. The agreement the Applicant had with the Child was that the Child could come home whenever he did not need to be at university. The Applicant says he had to drive to the University on numerous occasions during the period in question to assist the Child. During the semester the Child would come home to stay with the Applicant at weekends. On the weekends the Applicant and the Child would discuss whatever issues the Child was having. The Applicant said he was “in a role of a therapist”. While staying with the Applicant the Applicant would pay for the Child’s food and other needs. The Applicant said that during the period in question the Child slept at his house 60% of the time. The rest of the time he stayed at the College. When the Child was at College the Applicant says he communicated with the Child “anywhere up to 20 times a day” via messages, sometimes up to midnight. The Child would also telephone the Applicant. The Applicant said he did not provide the Tribunal with a copy of the text messages “because they’re personal” and would betray his Child’s trust.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds that, given the state of the evidence, what can be found is that during the relevant care period, the pattern of care was such that the Applicant had 60% care of the Child, and this assessment is based on the amount of time the child stayed with the Applicant. The Other Party has zero % of care as the Child did not stay with her during the relevant period.DECISION The Tribunal finds that there was a change in the percentage of care that both the Applicant and the Other Party had in relation to the Child, and that the new percentage of care for the Applicant is 60%. Therefore, the Tribunal varies the existing care determination of 0% shared care and makes a new care determination that, during the period 18 February 2019 to 28 June 2019, the Applicant had a shared care percentage of 60%. The decision under review is therefore set aside and substituted to reflect the change in shared care percentage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Other Party told the Tribunal there were discrepancies between the calendar the Applicant provided and the google map screenshots the Applicant relies upon.CONSIDERATION There were accusations made by the Other Party that the Applicant was simply trying to get money for himself. The Tribunal is not in a position to determine this but notes that the Applicant strenuously denies the allegations. The Applicant accused the Other Party of not being a good mother. The Other Party was upset and told the Tribunal that the Applicant kept the Child from her. Again, it is not the role of the Tribunal in this matter to determine who may be the better parent or with whom a child should reside. These types of allegations do not assist the Tribunal in determining the issue under review. Receipts of money spent by the Applicant on the Child were not kept. However, the Tribunal does not doubt that both the Applicant and the Other Party spent money on their Child. The Tribunal is not in a position to determine how much each party spent during the relevant period. The parties were against each other on most points and there is no ability for the Tribunal to verify either parties evidence regarding amount of time spent caring for the Child. No medical evidence was produced which would enable the Tribunal to understand the level of care the Child required given his medical condition. The Tribunal does not doubt either parties’ evidence that they communicated with the Child regularly via his mobile phone. Full records of the number of communications each parent had were not presented to the Tribunal by either party. The one area which seems to not be in disagreement concerns the approximate number of nights the Child spent at the Applicant’s during the period when the Child was attending classes at university. It appears that the Child spent most weekends during the period with the Applicant during the university semester. Further, other than for a few days the parties agreed that the Child stayed with the Applicant during the study period. When the Tribunal examined the Applicant’s calendar and matched it against the google maps, it is not always consistent. However it was consistent for approximately 90% of the time. It is often the case in these matters that neither party has any extensive corroborating evidence, and relies primarily on their own evidence. This is understandable. In this circumstance the Tribunal considers that the actual care of the Child is best determined based on the number of nights the Child was in each parties’ care (see section 54A, Assessment Act). The Tribunal finds that, given the state of the evidence, what can be found is that during the relevant care period, the pattern of care was such that the Applicant had 60% care of the Child, and this assessment is based on the amount of time the child stayed with the Applicant. The Other Party has zero % of care as the Child did not stay with her during the relevant period.DECISION The Tribunal finds that there was a change in the percentage of care that both the Applicant and the Other Party had in relation to the Child, and that the new percentage of care for the Applicant is 60%. Therefore, the Tribunal varies the existing care determination of 0% shared care and makes a new care determination that, during the period 18 February 2019 to 28 June 2019, the Applicant had a shared care percentage of 60%.