ZGTeek Pty Ltd v Michael Lurie and Associates

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read
JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION : ZGTEEK PTY LTD -v- MICHAEL LURIE &
ASSOCIATES [2012] WASC 419
CORAM : COMMISSIONER SLEIGHT
HEARD
:  1 MAY & 14 AUGUST 2012
DELIVERED 
:  15 NOVEMBER 2012
FILE NO/S 
:  LPA 8 of 2011
BETWEEN  : ZGTEEK PTY LTD

Party Charged

AND

MICHAEL LURIE & ASSOCIATES

Practitioner

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Indemnity costs payable under the loan agreement - Review of taxation - Grounds of review different to grounds of objection before the taxing officer - Error in principle - Onus of proof on practitioner - Failure of party charged to cross-examine on affidavits of practitioner or call any evidence - Whether quantum so excessive as to manifest error in principle

Legislation:

Legal Practice Act 2003 (WA)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 66 r 53, r 55, r 56
Solicitors Costs Determination 2007 (WA)

[2012] WASC 419

Result:

Taxation remitted back to the Registrar

Category: B

Representation:

Counsel:

Party Charged : Mr J R Birman, Mr T Young & Mr S Forbes
Practitioner : Mr S Forbes

Solicitors:

Party Charged : Birman & Ride
Practitioner : Stewart Forbes

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Australian Coal and Shale Employees Federation v The Commonwealth (1956)
94 CLR 621
Clay v Karlson (Unreported, WASC, Library No 970424, 21 August 1997)
Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd v Ballato (Unreported, WASC, Library

No 9116, 25 October 1991)

EMI Records v Ian Wallace Ltd [1983] 1 Ch 59
Forbes v Frigger [2009] WASC 77

Mossensons (A firm) v Coastline Associates (Unreported, WASC, Library

No 970661, 2 December 1997)

Theocharides v Joannou [1955] 1 All ER 615

[2012] WASC 419

COMMISSIONER SLEIGHT

COMMISSIONER SLEIGHT:

Application

1              ZGTeek Pty Ltd applies for an order to review the taxation of

Registrar Whitby of a solicitor/client bill of costs of the practitioner. The practitioner had lodged a bill of costs claiming $79,736.99. On the taxation of the bill of costs the Registrar allowed the sum of $37,436.84. The application for review of the taxation is allowed for reasons set out below.

General background

2              The background to this matter is that ZGTeek entered into a loan

agreement dated 2 November 2004 (the Loan Agreement) with Skyvale Nominees Pty Ltd, pursuant to which Skyvale provided a loan to ZGTeek of $500,000 (the debt). For the purpose of these proceedings, it is common ground that ZGTeek defaulted in repayment of the loan to Skyvale. Skyvale was represented by the practitioner and instructed the practitioner to take steps in relation to recovery of the debt.

  1. The Loan Agreement contained a provision that relevantly provided that ZGTeek agreed to indemnify and pay to Skyvale on demand:

    [A]ll losses, liabilities, fees, costs (including legal costs on a full indemnity

    basis), expenses and Taxes incurred in connection with:

(a) any Event of Default or Potential Event of Default;
(b) the administration, and any actual or attempted preservation or enforcement, of any rights under any Facility Document.

4              An 'Event of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ZGTeek Pty Ltd v Michael Lurie and Associates and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 419
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ZGTeek Pty Ltd brought an action against Michael Lurie and Associates, seeking a review of costs taxed by a taxing officer. The central issue was whether the taxed costs were so excessive as to manifest an error in principle. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute arose from the interpretation of the indemnity costs provision in the loan agreement between the parties, which stipulated that the losing party would indemnify the winning party's costs, including reasonable taxation costs.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the grounds for reviewing the taxed costs differed from the grounds of objection presented to the taxing officer. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the onus of proof lay with the party seeking to challenge the taxed costs and whether the excessiveness of the taxed costs could be established without cross-examining the practitioner's affidavits or presenting additional evidence. The court also had to determine if there was an error in principle, as outlined in Australian Coal & Shale Employees Federation v The Commonwealth and Mossensons (A firm) v Coastline Associates, and if so, whether this error was so significant that it manifested a manifest error in principle.

The court found that the grounds for review differed from those of objection and that the onus of proof rested on the party charged with the costs to show an error in principle. It was established that the taxed costs were excessive and that no taxing officer, acting reasonably, could have taxed the particular item in the amount in question. The court relied on the principle that an error in principle may occur both in determining whether an item should be allowed and in determining how much should be allowed. The court concluded that the taxed costs were so excessive as to manifest an error in principle. The court reserved the matter for further hearing on final orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

ZGTeek Pty Ltd sought to recover indemnity costs from Michael Lurie and Associates under a loan agreement. The matter involved the review of a taxation decision made by a taxing officer, focusing on whether the indemnity costs were properly taxed. The key issue was whether the costs were so excessive as to manifest an error in principle in the taxation process. ZGTeek argued that the taxing officer had erred by taxing the costs at a level that no reasonable taxing officer would have approved, while Michael Lurie and Associates contended that the taxation was correct and within the bounds of reasonable discretion.

The case came before the court as a review application under the relevant procedural rules concerning the taxation of costs. The initial taxation of the indemnity costs had been conducted by a taxing officer who determined the amount payable. ZGTeek subsequently applied to the court for a review of this decision, arguing that the taxation contained an error in principle. The matter proceeded to a hearing where the court was required to assess the correctness of the taxing officer's decision and determine whether the costs were properly taxed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the taxing officer made an error in principle in determining the amount of indemnity costs payable.
2. If so, whether the error in principle was such that it resulted in costs being taxed at an amount that no reasonable taxing officer would have approved.
3. Whether the onus of proof on the practitioner to justify the taxed amount was met by ZGTeek.
4. Whether Michael Lurie and Associates failed to cross-examine on affidavits of ZGTeek or call any evidence to counter the claim of error in principle.

Held
1. The court concluded that the taxing officer made an error in principle in determining the amount of indemnity costs payable.
2. The error in principle was such that it resulted in costs being taxed at an amount that no reasonable taxing officer would have approved.
3. The onus of proof on the practitioner to justify the taxed amount was met by ZGTeek.
4. Michael Lurie and Associates failed to cross-examine on affidavits of ZGTeek or call any evidence to counter the claim of error in principle.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Australian Coal & Shale Employees Federation v The Commonwealth, Kitto J stated (authorities omitted): The court will always review a decision of a Taxing Officer where it is contended that he has proceeded upon a wrong principle, for the purpose of determining the principle which should be applied; and an error in principle may occur both in determining whether an item should be allowed and in determining how much should be allowed. Where no principle is involved, and the question is, whether the Taxing Officer has correctly exercised a discretion which he possesses and is purporting to exercise, the court is reluctant to interfere. It has undoubted jurisdiction to review the Taxing Officer's decision even where an exercise of discretion only is involved, and will do so freely on a proper case, using its own knowledge of the circumstances, but it will in general interfere only where the discretion appears not to have been exercised at all, or would have been exercised in a manner which is manifestly wrong; and where the question is one of amount only, will do so only in an extreme case (628). In Mossensons (A firm) v Coastline Associates (Unreported, WASC, Library No 970661, 2 December 1997) Ipp J stated: The point is that there must be an error in principle before a Judge will carry out a review under O 66 r 55. Although it is possible for an error in principle to be made in regard to the quantum allowed in respect of a particular item, that is generally regarded as unusual. In my opinion, an error in principle on this basis can only be established if it is shown that no taxing officer, acting reasonably, could ever have taxed the particular item in the amount in question (9). (See also Forbes v Frigger [2009] WASC 77 [37]; Clay v Karlson.) I will hear counsel as to final orders.