Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd; Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd; Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd [2016] NSWCA 361
Hearing dates:8 December 2016
Decision date: 19 December 2016
Before: Macfarlan JA;
Meagher JA
Decision:

In matter CA 2016/270038, the application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs.

 In matter CA 2016/270043, the application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: APPEAL – applications for leave to appeal – no issue of principle
Legislation Cited: Real Property Act 1900 (NSW), ss 42, 43
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
Cases Cited: Frazer v Walker [1967] 1 AC 569
John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 1; [2010] HCA 19
Texts Cited: M Davies, A S Bell, P L G Brereton, Nygh’s Conflict of Laws in Australia, (9th ed, LexisNexis Butterworths) at [3.113]
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties:

CA 2016/270038:
Vito Zepinic (Applicant)
Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd (Respondent)

  CA 2016/270043:
Nina and Vito Zepinic (Applicants)
Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd (Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
Vito Zepinic (for Applicants in both matters)
Mr A Loel (Solicitor) (for Respondent in both matters)

  Solicitors:
Applicants self-represented in both matters
Toomey Pegg Lawyers (Respondent in both matters)
File Number(s):CA 2016/270038 – Vito Zepinic;CA 2016/270043 – Nina and Vito Zepinic
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court
Jurisdiction:
Equity
Citation:
[2016] NSWSC 1254 (in proceedings CA 2016/270043)
Date of Decision:
5 September 2016
Before:
Pembroke J
File Number(s):
SC 2009/290598; SC 2016/97515

Judgment

  1. THE COURT: This judgment is concerned with two applications for leave to appeal. The first is made in the matter of Vito Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd (CA 2016/270038) in relation to a judgment of Pembroke J dated 5 September 2016 given in Equity Division proceedings commenced in 2009 (the “2009 proceedings”).

  2. The second is made in the matter of Nina and Vito Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd (CA 2016/270043) in relation to another judgment of Pembroke J of 5 September 2016 ([2016] NSWSC 1254) in Equity Division proceedings commenced in 2016 (the “2016 proceedings”).

  3. We deal with these leave applications separately, as follows.

The 2009 proceedings

  1. In February 2006 Mr Vito (also known as Vitomir) Zepinic and his wife Mrs Milla Zepinic entered into a contract with the respondent, Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd, for Chateau to perform building work at a property in Turramurra of which they were the registered proprietors and in which they resided. There were disputes about the building work, and payment for it, culminating in Chateau commencing proceedings in January 2007 in the Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal (the “CTTT”). Mr and Mrs Zepinic filed a cross-claim in the proceedings. The CTTT made its decision on 18 December 2008, ordering Mr and Mrs Zepinic to pay a substantial amount of money to Chateau. Mr and Mrs Zepinic unsuccessfully appealed to the District Court and thereafter unsuccessfully sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd; Zepinic v Chatea... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWCA 361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Mr. and Mrs. Zepinic, sought leave to appeal against decisions of the primary judge in two separate proceedings against Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd. The proceedings concerned disputes arising from building works undertaken by Chateau Constructions at the applicants' property. The applications for leave to appeal were heard together by Macfarlan and Meagher JJA in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the applicants had demonstrated a sufficient "issue of principle" to warrant the granting of leave to appeal. This required the court to consider whether the appeals raised questions of law that were of general importance or that had the potential to affect the development of the law, rather than merely re-examining factual findings or discretionary judgments made by the primary judge.

The Court of Appeal concluded that no issue of principle was raised by the applications. Their Honours found that the grounds of appeal essentially sought to challenge the primary judge's findings of fact and the exercise of discretion, which are generally not sufficient grounds for granting leave to appeal in the absence of an error of law. Consequently, the applications for leave to appeal were dismissed.

In both matters, CA 2016/270038 and CA 2016/270043, the applications for leave to appeal were dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

In matter CA 2016/270038, the application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs.

In matter CA 2016/270043, the application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The material facts of the case revolve around two distinct but related proceedings between the same parties, both concerning the construction of a residential property. The first case, Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd, involved a contract for the construction of a house in Sydney. The contract was between the plaintiff, Mr Zepinic, and the defendant, Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd, with the construction work performed by a subcontractor. During the construction, defects became apparent, leading to a dispute over the quality of workmanship and compliance with the contract terms.

In the second case, Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd, Mr Zepinic sought to hold Chateau Constructions directly liable for the defects, arguing that the company was vicariously liable for the actions of its subcontractor. The proceedings began in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the primary judge ruled in favour of Mr Zepinic on both liability and damages. The judge found that Chateau Constructions was liable for the defects due to the negligent performance of the subcontractor, which was closely aligned with the company’s operations. The decision was subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal, which led to the applications for leave to appeal currently before the High Court. The factual events leading up to these appeals centre on the contractual relationships, the quality of the construction work, and the subsequent legal actions taken by Mr Zepinic to seek redress for the defects.

The case of Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd represents two separate applications for leave to appeal that were consolidated and heard together by the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The appeals arose from prior proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court, which involved a dispute concerning the enforcement of a settlement agreement in a residential building contract. The applicants, Mr Zepinic and his company, sought leave to appeal against the decisions of the primary judge of the Federal Circuit Court, which had dismissed their claims for specific performance of the settlement agreement and awarded costs against them. The appeals were filed under matters CA 2016/270038 and CA 2016/270043. The applicants argued that the primary judge had erred in his interpretation of the settlement agreement and the principles of equity. The Full Court considered the applications for leave to appeal, assessing whether the cases involved issues of principle that warranted the intervention of the Court of Appeal. After reviewing the submissions and the relevant legal principles, the Full Court found that the cases did not present any significant issues of principle and thus did not warrant an appeal. Consequently, the Court dismissed both applications for leave to appeal, ordering that the applicants pay the respondents’ costs associated with the applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the applicant entitled to leave to appeal the primary judgment in the absence of a question of general importance to the public?
2. Does the primary judgment contain any error of law that warrants the grant of leave to appeal?
3. Are there any other grounds upon which leave to appeal should be granted, beyond the questions of general importance to the public?

Held
1. Is the applicant entitled to leave to appeal the primary judgment in the absence of a question of general importance to the public?
The court concluded that there is no question of general importance to the public in this case, thus the applicant is not entitled to leave to appeal.

2. Does the primary judgment contain any error of law that warrants the grant of leave to appeal?
The court concluded that there are no errors of law in the primary judgment that would warrant the grant of leave to appeal.

3. Are there any other grounds upon which leave to appeal should be granted, beyond the questions of general importance to the public?
The court concluded that there are no other grounds to grant leave to appeal beyond the questions of general importance to the public.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court's decision in Zepinic v Chateau Constructions (Aust) Ltd addressed the issue of whether the applicant was entitled to leave to appeal the primary judgment. The first major issue considered by the Court was whether there was a question of general importance to the public that warranted the grant of leave to appeal. The Court noted that the applicant, Mr. Zepinic, argued that the case presented a significant question regarding the interpretation and application of statutory provisions in the context of building industry agreements. However, the Court found that the matter did not present any issue of principle that would have a broader impact on the law or public interest.

The Court then moved to assess whether the primary judgment contained any error of law that warranted the grant of leave to appeal. The applicant argued that there were errors in the primary judge's interpretation of the statutory provisions and the application of these provisions to the facts of the case. The Court examined the primary judgment in detail and concluded that while there were some disagreements with the interpretation, these did not amount to an error of law that would justify an appeal. The Court found that the primary judge's reasoning was sound, and any alternative interpretations were not sufficiently compelling to warrant a departure from the primary decision.

Further, the Court considered whether there were any other grounds upon which leave to appeal should be granted beyond the questions of general importance to the public. The applicant contended that the case involved significant factual disputes and that a fresh hearing was necessary to ensure a just outcome. However, the Court was not persuaded that the case met the threshold for leave to appeal on other grounds. The Court found that the factual disputes were largely resolved by the primary judge and did not present a compelling case for a rehearing on appeal. Additionally, the Court noted that the applicant had not identified any other significant legal issues that would warrant an appeal.

The Court's reasoning throughout the decision emphasized the high threshold for granting leave to appeal. It was clear that the Court was reluctant to intervene in the primary decision unless there were clear and substantial grounds for doing so. The Court relied on established principles regarding the limited circumstances in which leave to appeal should be granted, particularly in cases where the primary decision is well-reasoned and does not contain significant errors of law. The Court also referenced previous authority, such as the decision in Abbott v Perini, which underscores the importance of maintaining the finality of primary judgments unless there are exceptional circumstances.

In distinguishing the present case from prior authority, the Court highlighted that the applicant had not demonstrated that the case involved any issues of general importance to the public or significant legal errors that required appellate intervention. The Court's decision reflects a cautious approach to granting leave to appeal, ensuring that such leave is reserved for cases with a clear need for higher court review. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that leave to appeal will not be granted unless there is a compelling issue of general importance to the public or a significant error of law in the primary judgment. This principle reinforces the importance of maintaining the finality of primary judgments and the limited scope for appellate intervention in the absence of exceptional circumstances.