Zefi v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

ZEFI v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2024] SASC 42

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Blue 

27 March 2024

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT – GROUNDS

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - GROUNDS - GENERALLY

The appellant appeals against his conviction of driving a motor vehicle at a speed exceeding a relevant speed limit by 45 kilometres per hour or more in contravention of subsection 45A(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA).

The conviction was based on evidence given by affidavit by Senior Constable Greenwood that he operated a LIDAR traffic speed analyser in respect of a Holden Commodore driven by the appellant on Seacombe Road, Seacliff Park, which indicated a speed of 111 kilometres per hour.

The appellant appeals on two grounds:

1the Magistrate erred in finding that the evidence of Senior Constable Greenwood was sufficient evidence to establish the speed limit that applied to his vehicle;

2the Magistrate erred in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant to prove that the speed detection device was not in proper order and/or operated properly.

Held (allowing the appeal):

1There was sufficient evidence to establish the speed limit that applied to the appellant’s vehicle: ground 1 is not established (at [44]).

2The Magistrate erroneously reversed the onus of proof onto the defendant to prove that the traffic speed analyser was not properly operated: ground 1 is not established (at [57]).

3There was no evidence as to the operation or proper operation of the traffic speed analyser and it was not open to the Magistrate to find the charge proved (at [70]).

4An acquittal must be substituted for the conviction rather than remittal to the Magistrates Court for a fresh trial (at [60], [72]).

ZEFI v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2024] SASC 42

Criminal Appeal: Single Judge

  1. BLUE J: Kristian Zefi appeals against his conviction of driving a motor vehicle at a speed exceeding a relevant speed limit by 45 kilometres per hour or more in contravention of subsection 45A(1) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) (the Act).

  2. The conviction was based on evidence given by affidavit by Senior Constable Greenwood that he operated a LIDAR traffic speed analyser in respect of a Holden Commodore driven by Mr Zefi on Seacombe Road Seacliff Park, which indicated a speed of 111 kilometres per hour.

  3. Mr Zefi appeals on two grounds:

    1the Magistrate erred in finding that the evidence of Senior Constable Greenwood was sufficient evidence to establish the speed limit that applied to his vehicle;[1]

    2the Magistrate erred in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant to prove that the speed detection device was not in proper order and/or operated properly.[2]

    [1]     Ground 1 of the Grounds of Appeal.

    [2]     Ground 2 of the Grounds of Appeal.

    Background

  4. On 26 October 2022 Senior Constable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zefi v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Zefi appealed against a conviction for exceeding the speed limit on 26 October 2022. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia, where two grounds of appeal were presented. The first ground of appeal was that the Magistrate erred in finding that the evidence of Senior Constable Greenwood was sufficient to establish the speed limit that applied to Mr Zefi's vehicle. The second ground of appeal was that the Magistrate erred in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant to prove that the speed detection device was not in proper order and/or operated properly.

The court considered the first ground of appeal, which related to the evidence provided by Senior Constable Greenwood. The court examined the procedure followed by Senior Constable Greenwood in conducting a field test on the LIDAR traffic speed analyser, including checking for damage, intact calibration seals, and the device being within 12 months of the last calibration. The court also reviewed the tests conducted by Senior Constable Greenwood, such as the self-test, fixed distance zero velocity test, and scope alignment test, all of which were passed by the device. The court concluded that the evidence provided by Senior Constable Greenwood was sufficient to establish the speed limit that applied to Mr Zefi's vehicle.

The court also considered the second ground of appeal, which related to the onus of proof. The court examined the legal principles surrounding the onus of proof in cases involving speed detection devices and concluded that the Magistrate did not err in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant. The court found that the evidence provided by Senior Constable Greenwood, including his training, competence, and precise operation of the device, was capable of proving beyond reasonable doubt that the use of the device on the particular occasion was appropriate.

In conclusion, the appeal was allowed, and Mr Zefi's conviction was quashed and an acquittal substituted. The court found that the evidence provided by Senior Constable Greenwood was sufficient to establish the speed limit that applied to Mr Zefi's vehicle, and the Magistrate did not err in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Zefi appeals on two grounds:1the Magistrate erred in finding that the evidence of Senior Constable Greenwood was sufficient evidence to establish the speed limit that applied to his vehicle;[1]2the Magistrate erred in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant to prove that the speed detection device was not in proper order and/or operated properly.[2][1] Ground 1 of the Grounds of Appeal.[2] Ground 2 of the Grounds of Appeal.Background On 26 October 2022 Senior Constable Lee Greenwood was based at Sturt Police Station attached to the Road Policing Section of Southern Tactical. He commenced his shift at 3 pm. At about 3.25 pm Senior Constable Greenwood conducted a shift field test on a LIDAR traffic speed analyser, being a Laser Technology Inc LTI 20/20 TruSpeed Laser serial number TS011380 (the LIDAR). The first part of the field test involved ensuring the following:1 that there was no damage to the LIDAR;2 that all calibration seals were intact; and3 that the LIDAR was within 12 months of the last calibration (which was6 December 2021). Senior Constable Greenwood then turned the device on. He observed that the device displayed that it had conducted its ‘self-test’ correctly without errors (test 4). Senior Constable Greenwood conducted a fixed distance zero velocity test at the range at Sturt Police Station, which the device passed (test 5). He conducted a scope alignment test, which the device also passed (test 6). Senior Constable Greenwood completed a standard form entitled Speed Detection Equipment Field Test Results, selecting ‘pass’ in respect of tests 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6 and recording the calibration date as 6 December 2021 (the Field Test Form). This form became exhibit P4. Shortly before 7.40 pm Senior Constable Greenwood parked his police vehicle facing east at 231 Seacombe Road Seacliff Park. He began conducting static laser duties for vehicles travelling both east and west. At 7.40 pm Senior Constable Greenwood saw a white Mitsubishi Triton followed by a black Renault Clio travelling west at what appeared to be about 60 kilometres per hour. There were no vehicles travelling east at that time. Senior Constable Greenwood saw a third vehicle, being a dark Holden Commodore sedan [the vehicle driven by Mr Zefi], about 200 metres east. It was travelling west with a fourth vehicle close behind. He observed the Commodore travelling at high speed towards him and it was very quickly increasing its distance ahead of the fourth vehicle to its rear. By this stage the first and second vehicles, the Triton and the Clio, had passed Senior Constable Greenwood and travelled further west out of sight. Senior Constable Greenwood activated the LIDAR and detected the Commodore. At this stage the fourth vehicle was about 100 metres behind the Commodore. The LIDAR displayed a speed of 111 kilometres per hour and a distance of 81.7 metres. A photograph of the rear of the LIDAR, showing it displaying that speed and distance, was tendered as exhibit P2.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 175 of the Act creates various evidentiary presumptions. It relevantly provides:175—Evidence(1)In proceedings for an offence against this Act, an allegation in an information that—(a) a specified place was a road or road-related area, or a specified kind or portion of road or road-related area; or…(c)a specified traffic control device was on, above or near a specified place; or(d) a traffic control device was of a specified form or was operating in a specified way; or…(i) a specified person was the owner, operator, person in charge or driver of a specified vehicle,is proof of the matters so alleged in the absence of proof to the contrary.…(3)In proceedings for an offence against this Act—…(baa) a document produced by the prosecution and purporting to be signed by the Commissioner of Police, or by any other police officer of or above the rank of inspector, and purporting to certify that a specified traffic speed analyser that is not a photographic detection device had been tested on a specified day in accordance with—(i)the appropriate Australian Standard for testing the analyser as in force on the day of testing; or(ii)if there was no appropriate Australian Standard for testing the analyser in force on the day of testing—the manufacturer's specifications,and was shown to be accurate to the extent indicated in the document, constitutes, in the absence of proof to the contrary, proof of the facts certified and that the traffic speed analyser was accurate to that extent on the day on which it was so tested and, for the purpose of measuring the speed of any motor vehicle, during the period of 1 year immediately following that day (whether or not the speed measured differed from the speed in relation to which the analyser was tested or the circumstances of the measurement differed in any other respect from the circumstances of the test);… Regulation 68 of the Road Traffic (Road Rules—Ancillary and Miscellaneous Provisions) Regulations 2014 (SA) (the Rules Regulations) relevantly provides:68—Evidentiary provisions(1)In proceedings for offences against the Rules or these regulations, an allegation in an information that—(a)a specified speed limit applied to a specified length of road; or…(h)specified information was on or with a specified traffic control device; or(i) a specified traffic control device applied to a specified length of road, portion of road or area; or(j) a specified traffic control device applied to a specified person in a specified place,is proof of the matters so alleged in the absence of proof to the contrary. Regulation 27 of the Road Traffic (Miscellaneous) Regulations 2014 (SA) (the Miscellaneous Regulations) relevantly provides:27—Apparatus approved as traffic speed analysers (section 53A of Act)Pursuant to section 53A of the Act, the following are approved as traffic speed analysers:…(e) a Laser Technology Inc. LTI 20/20 TruSpeed laser;… Rules 20, 21 and 25 of the Road Rules made by the Governor relevantly provide:20—Obeying the speed limitA driver must not drive at a speed over the speed limit applying to the driver for the length of road where the driver is driving.Offence provision.…Note 4—Part 20 Division 2 deals with the way in which a traffic sign applies to a length of road. Part 20 Division 3 deals with the way in which the traffic sign applies to drivers driving on the length of road.21—Speed limit where a speed limit sign applies(1)The speed limit applying to a driver for a length of road to which a speed limit sign applies is the number of kilometres per hour indicated by the number on the sign.Note—Length of road is defined in the dictionary.…(3)A speed limit sign on a road applies to the length of road beginning at the sign and ending at the nearest of the following:(a) a speed limit sign on the road with a different number on the sign;(b) an end speed limit sign or speed derestriction sign on the road;(c) if the road ends at a T‑intersection or dead end—the end of the road.…25—Speed limit elsewhere(1)If a speed limit sign does not apply to a length of road and the length of road is not in a speed limited area, school zone or shared zone, the speed limit applying to a driver for the length of road is the default speed limit.Note—Length of road is defined in the dictionary, school zone is defined in rule 23, shared zone is defined in rule 24, and speed limited area is defined in rule 22.(2)The default speed limit applying to a driver for a length of road in a built‑up area is 50 kilometres per hour.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given this conclusion, I have no option but to acquit Mr Zefi of the offence.Conclusion The appeal must be allowed. Mr Zefi’s conviction must be quashed and an acquittal substituted. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first ground is not established.Proper operation Ground 2 is that the Magistrate erred in reversing the onus of proof onto the defendant to prove that the speed detection device was not in proper order and/or operated properly. Although the ground of appeal is expressed to refer both to the question of proper order and proper operation, on the hearing of the appeal Mr Zefi confines his contention to the question of proper operation. In the first paragraph reproduced at [24] above, the Magistrate referred to the decision of Peek J in Police v Young.[4] In that case, Peek J said:A matter that may be very important in circumstances such as the present is the skill with which the police officer operated the device during the speed detection process. The obvious analogy is that a rifle may be perfectly made and accurate within itself, but if it is not skilfully used on a particular occasion the target will likely be missed.Further, it is critical to appreciate that the certificate procedure does not enact any presumption as to the expertise with which the device was used on any particular occasion. To pursue the rifle analogy, the certificate procedure may assist the prosecution to prove that the rifle is accurate within itself but it says nothing as to the person using it. Appropriate use of the device on the particular occasion had to be proven by the prosecution to the normal standard of proof, beyond reasonable doubt. Constable Hand gave evidence-in-chief that he had received training in the use of speed detection devices including training in relation to this particular device, the Ultralyte 100 LR laser speed gun in 2006, that he used the device very regularly and that he was competent in its use. He also described his precise operation of the unit during the timing of the appellant’s vehicle. The appellant did not ask Constable Hand any questions as to these matters and did not refer him to any documents relevant thereto.On my analysis of the evidence, the evidence given by Constable Hand, including as to his training (unchallenged in this context), was capable of proving beyond reasonable doubt that the use of device on the particular occasion was appropriate. I am not prepared to disturb the Magistrate’s finding in that regard.[5] [4] [2012] SASC 210.[5] At [103]-[106]. Earlier cases had established that the prosecution must prove that a device relied upon to prove a fact in issue (such as a breath analysis instrument or photographic detection device) was in proper order and was operated properly. In relation to breath analysis instruments, in Evans v Benson[6] King CJ (with whom Jacobs, Bollen and Olsson JJ agreed) said:A breath analysis instrument can only indicate a blood alcohol concentration if it is in proper order and is properly operated. If an instrument is not in proper order or is not properly operated, it cannot be said to indicate any concentration of alcohol. For that reason it is necessary for the prosecution to prove that the instrument was in proper order and was properly operated.[7][6] (1986) 46 SASR 317.[7] At 323.