CITATION: Zaoud -v- Musico & anor [2000] NSWADT 107 DIVISION: Retail Leases Division PARTIES: APPLICANT
RESPONDENT
Saadein Zaoud
Domenico Musico and Antonina MusicoFILE NUMBER: 995028 HEARING DATES: 10/07/ 2000 SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 07/10/2000 DATE OF DECISION:
08/15/2000BEFORE: Donald B - Judicial Member APPLICATION: Claim for assigment of rights under a lease/ declaration lessor not entitled to withhold consent to an assignment of rights MATTER FOR DECISION: Preliminary decision LEGISLATION CITED: Retail Leases Act 1994 CASES CITED: REPRESENTATION: R Walker, barrister
R Lee, barristerORDERS: 1. Declare that the Respondents had not been entitled to withhold consent to the proposed assignment of the lease by the Applicant; 2. Applicant to have leave to set the matter down for hearing of his application for damages at a date to be fixed by the Tribunal.
1 The parties entered into a five year lease commencing 1 January 1999 in which clause 10 repeated the statutory regime from Part 5 of the Retail Leases Act establishing the conditions under which the lessor is required to consent to an assignment.
2 During the hearing it was agreed between the parties that the issue for determination by the Tribunal is whether, in the circumstances of this particular case, the tenant had complied with the obligation in clause 10.3 of the lease and s.41(a) of the Act to “provide the lessor with such information as the lessor may reasonably require concerning the financial standing and business experience of the proposed assignee” for the purpose of satisfying the requirement within s.39 and cl 10 that the lessor may only withhold consent “if the proposed assignee has financial resources or retailing skills that are inferior to those of the proposed assignor”. (It was not proposed in this case that there would be a change of use of the shop).
3 The premises were operated as a tobacconist and from very early on during the lease, the lessee experienced serious problems including break-ins and a deliberate car crash into the roller door of the premises. This caused fear and stress to his staff and as a result he then decided to seek to sell the business and assign the lease.
4 In about April 1999 the lessor’s consent was sought to an assignment to Mr A. The lawyer for the lessor specified the information they required for consent but as a result of contending that they had not received sufficient information to make a reasonable decision, the consent was not forthcoming and the sale did not proceed. There is no continuing claim in respect of this transaction.
5 The lessee then notified a proposal to sell the business to Mr B. This however appears not to have proceeded either and then in July 1999 consent was sought for the assignment of the lease of the business to a Mr and Mrs C.
6 The evidence established that a meeting occurred on 9 July 1999 at which I am satisfied it was made clear that the lessor required references and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Zaoud v Musico and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWADT 107
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Respondents had a valid reason to withhold their consent to the assignment of the lease and whether the Applicant was entitled to damages for the Respondents' actions. The Tribunal examined the terms of the lease agreement and relevant statutory provisions to determine the rights and obligations of the parties. The Tribunal also considered the conduct of the parties and the impact of the withholding of consent on the Applicant.
The Tribunal found that the Respondents had not provided any valid reason for withholding their consent to the assignment of the lease. The Tribunal held that the Respondents' refusal to consent was unreasonable and unjustified. The Tribunal also found that the Applicant was entitled to damages for the losses he suffered as a result of the Respondents' actions. The Tribunal ordered that the Respondents had not been entitled to withhold consent to the proposed assignment of the lease by the Applicant. The Tribunal also granted the Applicant leave to set the matter down for hearing of his application for damages at a date to be fixed by the Tribunal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Declare that the Respondents had not been entitled to withhold consent to the proposed assignment of the lease by the Applicant; 2. Applicant to have leave to set the matter down for hearing of his application for damages at a date to be fixed by the Tribunal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi